Economy & Policy

Workers Pay the Full $28,303 Family Health Plan — Like It or Not

The average family health plan hits $28,303 — 44% of a typical worker's wages. Consultants and vendors profit as costs rise; only workers gain nothing, Lo Sasso argues.

By Nathan Brooks

4 min read

Workers pay all of the $28,303 family health plan. Their benefits consultants earn more when it rises
Workers pay all of the $28,303 family health plan. Their benefits consultants earn more when it risesParentingupstream / pixabay

What's News

  • Average employer-sponsored family health plan now costs $28,303.
  • Family plan cost equals 44% of a typical full-time worker's pre-tax wages.
  • Roughly 100 million people get benefits from large self-insured employers.
  • Federal law requires consultant compensation disclosure, but not incentive structures.
  • Solution proposed: flat consultant fees and Medicare-based price benchmarks, no new legislation.

The average employer-sponsored family health plan now costs $28,303, and according to a Fortune commentary by Tony Lo Sasso, workers — not employers — ultimately pay every dollar of it.

Yes, workers see roughly a quarter of that cost deducted from their paychecks and assume the company covers the rest. The uncomfortable math says otherwise. Employers think in total compensation: cash wages, paid leave, retirement benefits, workers' compensation premiums and health insurance all draw from one pool. Economists have documented the wage-benefits trade-off for decades. When one line balloons, another shrinks — so rising premiums crowd out cash wage growth.

The scale is hard to overstate. The average family plan now equals 44% of a typical full-time worker's pre-tax cash wages, per federal wage data. Spread across 26 paychecks, the worker's share comes to a few hundred dollars per biweekly period — diffuse, nearly invisible, and easy to ignore.

Who's actually inflating the bill?

This isn't a story about insurers gouging employers. Roughly 100 million people get benefits from large companies that self-insure — the employer pays the health bills directly, and insurers act as hired administrators.

The problem starts with how "value" gets measured. Hospital deals are judged by discounts off billed charges, but those charges are widely known to be fiction, set by the hospitals themselves and paid by almost no one. Highmark, a Blue Cross plan, spells it out in its own employer materials: a facility charging $100 with a 60% discount gets paid $40, while one charging $70 with a 50% discount gets $35. The bigger discount costs more.

Milliman, the actuarial firm, notes that charges rise faster than negotiated prices precisely because they're less constrained — so discounts look bigger while real prices climb. The pattern repeats everywhere:

  • Out-of-network claims are often repriced by vendors paid a percentage of "savings" off billed charges — the higher the bill, the bigger the fee. A 2024 New York Times investigation of MultiPlan documented this.
  • Drug benefits are judged by rebates off list prices set by manufacturers.

In every case, rewards flow to whoever posts the highest list price. The comparison, Lo Sasso writes, is delighting in a big tax refund after withholding more all year. The number that matters is the price actually paid, net of discounts — judged against a benchmark providers don't control, such as Medicare.

Why doesn't anyone push back?

Large self-insured employers rely on a handful of big benefits consultants to design and contract their health benefits. Federal law requires brokers and consultants to disclose direct and indirect compensation — but not how incentives are structured. If consultant revenue rises with employer spending, or is richer for vendors they recommend, employers have their answer.

Corporate benefits staff have their own skewed incentives. If plan changes go wrong, they absorb the complaints, often with the CEO copied; if they save the company and its workers millions, they get none of the credit. From their seat, there's only downside — so nobody gets fired for the status quo.

What does this change for employers? Lo Sasso argues no new legislation is needed — just a sustained, CFO-level effort, because anyone below the CFO bears the pushback and reaps none of the reward. His minimum steps:

  • Put finance at the table. Treat the health plan like any other line item of this size, with the same scrutiny of contracts, prices and vendor margins.
  • Change the benchmark. Use price transparency data to demand comparisons against an external benchmark like a multiple of Medicare — noting Medicare is a benchmark, not an aspirational price.
  • Pay consultants a flat, disclosed fee. No commissions tied to premiums, no side payments from recommended vendors.
  • Make employees partners. Commit up front that savings show up as lower contributions and higher take-home pay, and report the numbers annually — or workers will read it as another cost grab.

Everyone in the employer health supply chain — hospitals, physicians, pharma, insurers, consultants — does better when spending rises with minimal pushback. The only parties gaining nothing, Lo Sasso concludes, are the ones paying the bill: workers. Employers aren't just stewards of those dollars; they carry a fiduciary duty to run plans in employees' best interests.

Source: fortune.com

Share this article:

More from Nathan Brooks

Nathan Brooks

Show full bio

News editor covering regulation, policy and their impact on entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.

2,611 articles

Related articles

« Previous article