Economy & Policy

Zucman Takes Billionaire Tax Fight Global After $300 Million California Defeat

Three weeks after California voters rejected a billionaire tax, economist Gabriel Zucman rallies US and European politicians in Paris behind a 2% levy on the largest fortunes.

By Nathan Brooks

4 min read

A French billionaire hunter is taking his fight global after California tax defeat
A French billionaire hunter is taking his fight global after California tax defeatPexels / pixabay

What's News

  • Opponents including Sergey Brin spent over $300 million to defeat California's billionaire wealth tax at the polls.
  • Gabriel Zucman hosts a summit against 'international oligarchy' in Paris on Saturday, less than three weeks after the California loss.
  • His 2% minimum annual tax on largest fortunes was rejected by the French Senate last year.
  • Wealth-tax bills are in the works in the Netherlands, Belgium and Spain; UN tax convention talks run November 30 to December 10 in Nairobi.
  • Economist François Geerolf estimates the tax would raise €2-6 billion in France, not the claimed €20 billion.

California billionaires and their allies spent more than $300 million to kill a wealth tax backed by economist Gabriel Zucman. Less than three weeks after that defeat at the polls, the 40-year-old French economist is hosting a summit against "international oligarchy" in Paris on Saturday, according to POLITICO.

Google cofounder Sergey Brin was among the opponents who outspent the initiative's supporters in California. Zucman isn't treating the loss as a verdict. "Everywhere, we see very, very strong popular support for taxing billionaires," he told POLITICO this week. "That's true even in the United States."

He's drawing encouragement from the US midterms, where several Democrats who campaigned on taxing the ultra-rich won their races. Rep. Ro Khanna of California is flying in for the Paris gathering. "Now our party has a choice to make: Are we going to stand with the working class or the tech lords?" Khanna told POLITICO. "The same inequality is fueling anger and distrust not only in America, but also in France and around the world."

Who's backing the Paris gathering?

Khanna and Rep. Pramila Jayapal of Washington will speak at the Théâtre de la Concorde, a city-owned venue off the Champs-Élysées loaned by Emmanuel Grégoire, Paris's socialist mayor. Left-wing leaders from Italy, Brazil, Spain and the UK are also expected to attend.

A "Paris Manifesto" published Friday calls for a minimum tax on the largest fortunes, protections for independent media, and rules for artificial intelligence. Eva Joly, the former French investigating judge who jailed Elf's boss in the 1990s and later served as a Greens MEP, called it "a real program to save our democracy" and said Zucman "carries it brilliantly."

Not everyone accepted the invitation. Zucman said he invited former EU competition chief Margrethe Vestager and former Italian Prime Minister Mario Draghi; both declined. A Vestager spokesperson declined to comment.

What does this change for wealth-tax policy?

Zucman's signature proposal — a minimum annual 2% tax on the largest fortunes — was rejected by the French Senate last year. Global talks on taxing the super-rich have stalled this year under the US presidency of the G20, and Zucman expects the impasse to persist while Donald Trump sits in the White House. He hopes to revive the debate when Britain takes over the G20 presidency next year.

In Brussels, tax legislation generally requires unanimity among all 27 EU governments, which makes a bloc-wide deal unlikely. So Zucman expects individual countries to move first, the way France pioneered value-added tax in the 1950s and several EU states rolled out digital services taxes on their own. Wealth-tax bills are in the works in the Netherlands, Belgium and Spain, he said, and the British government has begun studying the idea.

There's movement on corporate taxation too. European Council President António Costa is weighing a tax on US tech giants to help fund the EU's next seven-year budget, POLITICO reported Thursday, after Trump's weak midterm showing eased fears of retaliation. "Europe cannot afford to calibrate its tax policy to America's mood swings," said Paul Monaghan, chief executive of the UK's Fair Tax Foundation. UN negotiators, meanwhile, meet in Nairobi from November 30 to December 10 for the next round of talks on a global tax convention, with a final text due in 2027.

Why did California fail — and who's pushing back in France?

Zucman said billionaires flooded California voters with "disinformation" claiming the tax would bankrupt the health system, even though 90% of the revenue would have gone toward health care. Money wasn't the only factor: unions split over the measure, and Gov. Gavin Newsom campaigned against it. A state-only wealth tax "creates economic incentives for money and jobs to leave the state," his chief of staff Nathan Barankin said.

In France, the criticism is getting sharper. Sciences Po OFCE economist François Geerolf argues in a paper updated last month that Zucman exaggerated how undertaxed billionaires are and proposed a remedy that could do more harm than good. Geerolf conceded the ultra-rich can shield income through holding companies but said the fix is closing that loophole, not an annual fortunes tax. He also questioned the estimate that the tax would raise €20 billion a year in France, putting likely proceeds at €2 billion to €6 billion. His verdict: "A real problem, a false diagnosis, a bad remedy."

A campaign group backed by business executive Eric Maumy, Trop c'est trop, presented a study Wednesday calling the proposal confiscatory and unconstitutional. Politically, only France Unbowed and the Greens have fully embraced the 2% tax ahead of next spring's presidential election; MEP Raphaël Glucksmann proposes instead a higher rate on inheritances above €1.8 million plus a one-off 5% levy on fortunes over €100 million.

Zucman flips the radicalism charge back at his critics. "Do you think it's normal that billionaires can pay zero personal tax?" he said. "It's the current situation that is radical." Saturday's turnout in Paris won't pass any law, but it will test whether a cross-border coalition can outlast a $300 million defeat.

Source: feeds.businessinsider.com

Share this article:

More from Nathan Brooks

Nathan Brooks

Show full bio

News editor covering regulation, policy and their impact on entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.

2,611 articles

Related articles

« Previous article