Leadership

22 Executives Explain How to Enforce Accountability Without Fear

Twenty-two Fast Company Impact Council members — from ServiceNow, Twilio, Bonterra, UNICEF USA — share how they enforce accountability without fear, with AI decisions now carrying named human owners.

By Grace Kim

3 min read

22 leadership insights on ensuring accountability without instilling fear
22 leadership insights on ensuring accountability without instilling fearRonaldCandonga / pixabay

What's News

  • 22 Fast Company Impact Council members shared accountability methods
  • Bonterra's Scott Brighton requires a named human owner for every AI-related decision
  • ServiceNow CHRO Jacqui Canney urges shifting from 'don't break this' to 'let's try this'
  • Trust & Will reviews trackers weekly in open executive meetings to keep accountability structural
  • Twilio CEO Khozema Shipchandler calls for 'a culture of permissible failure'

By Grace Kim

Twenty-two members of the Fast Company Impact Council have laid out how they enforce accountability inside their companies without breeding fear — a question that has grown sharper now that artificial intelligence sits inside everyday business decisions.

The core problem they identify is definitional. If something goes wrong, whoever is accountable gets blamed. That dynamic makes some employees avoid roles with heavy accountability, and even those who step up stop taking needed risks.

What role does fear actually play?

Muneer Panjwani of Engage for Good | The Halo Awards draws a hard line between two kinds of fear. "Fearing your boss is different from fearing you didn't do your best work," he said. "Top-down fear can produce compliance, but rarely excellence." His fix: clear quarterly and annual goals, professional development funds, and honest conversations so people hold themselves to a standard.

Scott Brighton, CEO of Bonterra, flips the premise entirely. "I would argue that it is the lack of accountability that creates fear," he said. Each AI-related decision at his company carries a named human owner, with clear rules of engagement. "Fear breeds in darkness: Create light."

How do leaders set the tone?

Modeling comes up repeatedly. Megan Noel of Covista treats misses as information and names her own failures out loud first. Michele Walsh of UNICEF USA described presenting a dashboard with outdated targets, owning the error when a team member flagged it, and thanking them. "Small moments like that set the tone for the big ones," she said.

Jacqui Canney, ServiceNow's chief people officer, frames it as a mindset shift from "don't break this" to "let's try this." When leaders take a smart risk, own what follows, and adapt quickly, she said, people do the same.

Helen Andrews of Johannes Leonardo puts it bluntly: showing vulnerability "removes the bullshit and gives folks the support they need to own their accomplishments, warts and all."

What systems keep accountability structural?

Several council members built processes rather than slogans:

  • Cody Barbo, Trust & Will: weekly tracker reviews in executive meetings, with blocked items called out openly — "Fear creeps in when accountability feels personal or arbitrary."
  • James Chester, WVN: agree on the measure before work starts, write it down, review on a fixed schedule. "Clarity is kindness, as they say."
  • Khozema Shipchandler, Twilio: let team members own outcomes and cut endless approval chains, building "a culture of permissible failure."
  • Brad Weber, InspiringApps: employees set their own timing and scope bars, then demo finished products publicly.

Colby Proffitt of Seekr keeps the destination fixed and the path flexible. When something goes sideways, his first question is "What happened?" not "Who did this?" Maurice Twomey of Roto asks "What happened, and what support do you need?"

Where do AI and alignment fit?

Maril MacDonald of Gagen MacDonald argues most accountability failures are alignment failures in disguise: What are we doing, why, by when, and what's feasible? Leaders who settle those questions at the start treat accountability as a clarity question, not a punishment question.

Felicia Curcuru of Binti offers the sharpest self-critique in the set. A few years ago she leaned too far into being accommodating, and expectations slipped. Her old framing — "We're not where we need to be" — created fear. Coaching moved her to "This is what excellence looks like. How can we get there?"

Jaymes Black of The Trevor Project, having experienced fear-based leadership early in his career, replaces punitive reactions with two-way dialogue to uncover blockers. George Kailas of Prospero.ai separates the person from the outcome: "Fear makes people hide problems. Clarity makes them easier to solve."

The other contributors — Grace Keith Rodriguez (Caliber Corporate Advisers), Max Friedman (Givebutter), Leerom Segal (Klick Health), Meredith Rosenberg (NU Advisory Partners), Celia Jones (FINN Partners) and Phillip Haid (Public Inc.) — converge on the same operating principle: agreed expectations set in advance, honest feedback delivered early, and public demonstration of finished work.

The through-line across all 22: accountability stops frightening people the moment it's agreed before the work, applied at every level including the CEO's, and treated as data rather than judgment.

Original: fcimpactcouncil.com

Share this article:

More from Grace Kim

Grace Kim

Show full bio

Market editor covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.

2,582 articles

Related articles

« Previous article