Economy & Policy

Antalya Pact fails as Cop31 omits fossil-fuel transition

The Cop31 Antalya Pact went unadopted after the EU, UK and developing-country allies rejected a text that omitted fossil fuels, while wealthy nations faced criticism over adaptation finance.

By Olivia Hart

5 min read

Cop31 climate talks set to end in deep division as key deal rejected
Cop31 climate talks set to end in deep division as key deal rejectedjarmoluk / pixabay

What's News

  • Close to 200 countries met in Antalya for a fortnight under Turkish and Australian presidencies.
  • Talks due to end Friday overran into Sunday afternoon.
  • More than 130 countries demanded language endorsing a transition away from fossil fuels.
  • The Antalya Pact called for minimizing overshoot of the Paris Agreement's 1.5C threshold.
  • The main cover decision remained unadopted, while related decisions passed.

By Olivia Hart

The Cop31 Antalya Pact went unadopted Sunday after close to 200 countries failed to agree on the UN climate talks’ main outcome. More than 130 countries had demanded language endorsing a “transition away from fossil fuels,” but the final text omitted it.

Talks scheduled to end Friday ran into Sunday afternoon. The Turkish and Australian presidencies avoided an outright collapse of the Cop by adopting decisions on related matters, but they left out the “cover decision,” the summit’s principal agreement.

Why did the Antalya Pact fail?

  • The draft invited countries to electrify their economies.
  • It called on rich countries to finance poorer countries’ adaptation to climate impacts.
  • It asked all countries to minimize “overshoot” of the Paris Agreement’s 1.5C global heating threshold.

It also included carbon capture and storage provisions that campaigners said could perpetuate fossil fuels. Those provisions ran against the explicit transition language sought by more than 130 countries, leaving the two approaches without a stated reconciliation.

The reporting identified no dollar amount, allocation formula or timetable for the adaptation finance. Nor did it disclose safeguards or implementation rules for carbon capture and storage, so the compromise remained open to the charge O’Brien later made.

In plain terms, the pact offered broad economic language while leaving the central fossil-fuel question unresolved.

Why did the EU and other allies reject it?

Many countries, including the EU, the UK, many developing countries, small island states and some of the poorest countries, could not support the pact.

Ireland’s environment minister Darragh O’Brien, speaking for the EU, said the proposal “failed to meet the moment.” He added: “We will not endorse a decision that does not respond to the science and that actually risks deepening the chasm between global commitments and the action required. [It] does not even mention fossil fuels.”

O’Brien later rejected the final Antalya Pact in its current form. “It fails to meet the moment … We will not endorse a cover decision or an Antalya pact that does not even mention fossil fuels, which is the key driver of climate change,” he said.

The EU would not accept a decision “that greenwashes fossil fuels,” O’Brien said. His intervention drew applause, and Panama, the Marshall Islands and Norway followed with similar objections.

Bill Hare, chief executive of Climate Analytics, called the resistance a political turning point. “This feels like a real line in the sand moment. Countries are standing up to fossil fuel interests and saying no,” Hare said.

Hare’s language described political resolve, not negotiated substance. It showed that fossil-fuel language had become the fault line.

What kept the summit from ending outright?

Murat Kurum, Turkey’s Cop president, said no agreement existed on the draft cover decision, so delegates did not adopt it. “We have done our utmost; ultimately, we have not imposed this text on anyone, nor have we issued an ultimatum such as a ‘take it or leave it’ demand,” Kurum said.

“It is clear that there are parties in this hall who oppose this text. We recognise that there is no consensus on this document. Therefore, these decisions have not been adopted,” he said.

The presidents preserved the institutional process by passing decisions on related matters. The practical result was a fortnight-long summit with its main political text left unadopted.

Saudi Arabia defended the decision to include carbon capture and storage. The Africa group, China and Pakistan did not object, although some retained reservations. The record showed non-objection rather than explicit endorsement.

The result was procedural survival, not substantive agreement.

Why did poorer countries turn on wealthy nations?

Civil society groups, which had a mandated role at the talks, called Cop31 “the worst Cop ever.” African ministers delivered a blunt intervention on Friday: “We did not come here to beg.”

Power Shift Africa director Mohamed Adow used the same verdict on Friday. “The Cop presidents want to tell us this has been a great Cop. Well, I can tell you without any doubt that this has been the worst Cop ever,” he said.

Adow sharpened that criticism on Sunday.

“The EU has rejected this text, but it cannot wash its hands of the wreckage it helped create.... For countries facing failed harvests, destroyed homes and mounting debt, this amounts to abandonment by the wealthy nations most responsible for the crisis.

“Europe’s hypocrisy is staggering. Its governments demand fossil fuel roadmaps from others while expanding fossil fuels themselves”

His criticism reflected the pact’s silence on fossil fuels and the failure to quantify adaptation finance. Neither support for carbon capture nor procedural passage of side decisions answered that charge.

What made the deadlock harder to break?

The talks unfolded during a year of worsening extreme weather. Heatwaves claimed tens of thousands of lives, while a glacier collapsed in Nepal and droughts and floods intensified with a supercharged El Niño.

The slow pace had appalled even veteran participants. Mary Robinson, a former president of Ireland and former UN climate envoy, said negotiations lacked urgency. “There isn’t the sense of urgency to address these issues. That to me is very frustrating,” Robinson said as the talks neared their scheduled close.

She also faulted the leadership. “We have co-presidents who haven’t really been stepping up and giving that leadership,” she said.

Long periods of stalemate exposed what Adow described as a failure of collective will, especially in richer countries. The immediate test is whether another text can secure a fossil-fuel transition, clarify carbon capture and storage, and specify adaptation finance.

The talks produced no timeline for renewed negotiations. The Antalya Pact’s unadopted status therefore leaves substantive agreement unresolved.

Source: theguardian.com

Share this article:

More from Olivia Hart

Olivia Hart

Show full bio

Staff writer covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.

2,535 articles

Related articles

« Previous article