30 Countries Break Ranks at Cop31 to Pursue Fossil Fuel Treaty
Panama's environment minister says the world is 'held hostage by the petroleum mafia' as 30 countries sign up for a fossil fuel treaty outside the UN process, with Cop31 down to two days of talks.
By Nathan Brooks
4 min read

What's News
- 30 countries have joined an effort to forge a fossil fuel treaty outside the UN Cop31 process
- Adaptation fund pledges stand at $50m, down from $135m at the same point last year
- The draft cover decision contains 144 items; only two official negotiation days remain
- At least 60 countries back a target of 35% of final energy from electricity by 2035
- Ethiopia hosts Cop32 next year and leads a 'group of negative emitters'
Thirty countries have signed up to negotiate a fossil fuel treaty outside the UN climate process, Panama's environment minister Juan Carlos Navarro announced Wednesday at Cop31 — with only two official days of talks left to settle the summit's core disputes.
Navarro did not mince words about why. The world is "being held hostage by the petroleum mafia," he said. "We are in love with our kidnappers. We love the petroleum guys. We can't live without them, and they are so smart they have convinced us that they are doing this for our own good."
He went further at the press conference for the Fossil Fuel Non-Proliferation Treaty Initiative: "They torture us for our own good, they destroy our planet for our own good. They destroy nature to help us, and they demand our unrequited, endless, unlimited, boundless love. And we are so stupid that we fall for it."
What's still unresolved at Cop31?
Two questions dominate the final stretch: whether the summit's outcome will recognize the need to "transition away from fossil fuels," and how to handle the "overshoot" of global temperatures beyond the 1.5C Paris agreement target.
The Australian presidency and the Turkish hosts convened a "divan" meeting of ministers Wednesday evening — the name borrowed from the Ottoman term for a council — to find compromises on a revised draft. A new draft was expected Thursday morning.
Dividing lines persist on climate finance, a "just transition" for fossil fuel workers, and helping poor countries adapt to extreme weather. The first draft of the cover decision, issued Monday, contained 144 separate items. Nearly 200 countries are attending the fortnight-long talks, and some negotiators worry the Australian approach of including "everything" could drag negotiations out longer.
No breakthrough was expected from the divan meeting, though negotiators told the Guardian countries were working toward compromises. Campaigners feared a feeble outcome.
Where's the money?
The adaptation fund tells the story. Rich countries have pledged just $50m so far, down from $135m at the same stage last year — a drop of nearly two-thirds.
"Rich countries are offering crumbs to the adaptation fund, while blocking the negotiations that should provide the money countries need," said Mohamed Adow, director of the Power Shift Africa thinktank. "Listening to ministers praise the adaptation fund before giving next to nothing, you have to wonder how they expect it to do the work they say is so important."
Anger also centers on the "just transition mechanism," meant to retrain workers in high-carbon industries while developing countries build green sectors. "We're seeing massive steps backwards on adaptation finance and just transition, relative to previous Cops," said Brandon Wu, director of policy and campaigns at ActionAid USA. "In both cases, the blocking is being led by the EU."
A loophole in the 35% electricity target?
Irene Vélez Torres, the former Colombian minister who convened April's Santa Marta talks on phasing out fossil fuels, flagged a specific risk in the proposed target of generating 35% of final energy from electricity by 2035. At least 60 countries explicitly support it, with tacit backing from more, including China.
"I'm very scared that [the target] is not going to be explicit about clean green energy, because it may imply that they are going to lock us in future dependencies on gas and coal power," she said. "If we don't explicitly declare that the electricity is going to be powered by green and clean energy, we may make a mistake."
The workarounds multiplying outside the UN process
Frustrated with UN pace, coalitions are forming on the margins. The Santa Marta process continues despite Colombia's change of government, with Tuvalu hosting the next meeting. The Fossil Fuel Non-Proliferation Treaty Initiative counts 30 members, and the Beyond Oil and Gas Alliance pursues a similar "coalition of the willing."
Ethiopia, which hosts Cop32 next year, leads a "group of negative emitters" aiming to absorb more carbon than they produce through carbon capture, tree-planting, and restoring carbon sinks like wetlands and peatlands.
"Slashing emissions is essential but no longer enough," said Ani Dasgupta, president of the World Resources Institute. "We must also actively pull carbon out of the atmosphere, to bring temperatures back down."
Ethiopian ambassador Samuel Addis Alemayehu called for financial backing: "Ethiopia is expanding nature-based solutions [such as tree-planting] and calls for scaled-up support, adequate finance and access to technologies that reduce emissions."
What does this change for practitioners? If the treaty bloc grows and the electricity target passes without a renewables mandate, expect parallel compliance regimes — one vague UN framework, one binding fossil fuel pact — and locked-in gas demand that no summit communiqué will undo.
Source: theguardian.com
More from Nathan Brooks
Show full bio
News editor covering regulation, policy and their impact on entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.
2,426 articles