Appeals Court Rules US Wrongly Withheld $74 Million From New York
A federal appeals court says the Transportation Department 'arbitrarily' withheld nearly $74 million from New York over 33,000 immigrant trucker licenses it had no rule requiring the state to cancel.
By Olivia Hart
4 min read

What's News
- The 2nd Circuit ruled Friday the Transportation Department wrongly withheld nearly $74 million from New York.
- The dispute centered on nearly 33,000 commercial licenses the state refused to revoke.
- About 26,000 drivers were pulled off the road for failing English proficiency tests; 30,000 licenses were canceled.
- Immigrants make up about 20% of U.S. truck drivers; non-domiciled licenses cover about 200,000 drivers.
A federal appeals court ruled Friday that the U.S. Transportation Department wrongly withheld nearly $74 million in highway funds from New York over the state's refusal to cancel nearly 33,000 commercial driver's licenses held by immigrants.
A three-judge panel of the 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in Manhattan found that the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration, an arm of the Transportation Department, acted in a manner that was "arbitrary, capricious, or contrary to law" when it penalized the state. The panel's reasoning was narrow: New York cannot be faulted for declining to cancel licenses when a commercial driver lost legal status, because the rules that would have required cancellation were not in place at the time.
The licenses in question cover commercial vehicles — trucks, trailers, limousines and buses.
What does the ruling restore?
The money matters for the state's infrastructure budget. New York Attorney General Letitia James said when the lawsuit was filed in April that the federal government was unfairly holding back funds the state needs to repair roads and bridges. Governor Kathy Hochul called the cuts "devastating" in the spring and characterized them as "political payback."
Both officials welcomed the decision. Hochul and James called the ruling "a win for the millions of New Yorkers who rely on safe roads to travel" and for the "drivers who power our state" — an apparent reference to the truckers who move freight through the state's economy.
A court win, however, does not guarantee the money flows quickly. The Transportation Department retains enforcement tools and showed no sign of retreat.
How does the federal government respond?
The Transportation Department defended its position in a statement Friday, arguing it makes no sense for states to let trucking licenses for foreign drivers stretch years beyond the period they are legally in the United States.
"We've put a stop to the madness to keep the driving public safe," the statement said.
The department has acted on multiple fronts since the dispute began. It started enforcing existing English-language requirements for truckers in the summer of 2025. Audits conducted in every state uncovered numerous non-domiciled commercial driver's licenses that remained valid long after an immigrant's work permits had expired, or that were issued without properly verifying citizenship status.
The enforcement tally is substantial:
- About 26,000 drivers pulled off the road for failing to demonstrate English proficiency
- 30,000 commercial licenses canceled because they were issued illegally, according to the Transportation Department
Notably, the court's ruling addressed process — the absence of a cancellation rule at the time — not the underlying safety concerns. The department did not say whether it would now formalize such a rule.
Why did the crackdown intensify last year?
Concerns about truck driver qualifications sharpened after an August 2025 crash in Florida, where a truck driver was accused of performing an illegal U-turn that killed three people. Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy said that driver, who is from India, should never have been licensed in the first place.
Duffy had earlier tightened the rules governing when immigrants can obtain a commercial driver's license. Officials said they moved against states like New York after learning that some licenses remained valid long after an immigrant was no longer authorized to be in the country. New York issued licenses valid for eight years regardless of how long a driver's visa remained valid, according to authorities.
How large is the immigrant trucking workforce?
The scale explains why the stakes extend beyond New York. Immigrants account for about 20% of all truck drivers in the United States — roughly one in five. Non-domiciled licenses, the category immigrants can receive, represent about 5% of all commercial driver's licenses, or about 200,000 drivers.
That is a small share of total licenses, but a concentrated one: the category sits at the center of the federal enforcement effort.
Immigrant groups have said they believe many drivers are being unfairly targeted. The court's decision does not resolve that claim either; it turns on administrative law, not on whether individual drivers were treated justly.
The ruling forces the department to justify any renewed penalty under rules that now exist — and if the agency formalizes cancellation requirements, New York could face a second, better-documented attempt to withhold the same money.
Source: insurancejournal.com
More from Olivia Hart
Show full bio
Staff writer covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.
2,205 articles