Economy & Policy

Blackstone, Apollo Chase €80 Billion in EU Insurance Overhaul

Solvency II changes effective Jan. 30 could release €80 billion in insurer capital. Blackstone, Apollo and Pimco are circling — but regulators warn buffers will thin.

By Olivia Hart

4 min read

Private Capital Giants Target €80 Billion From EU’s Insurance Regulatory Revamp
Private Capital Giants Target €80 Billion From EU’s Insurance Regulatory RevampOleksandrPidvalnyi / pixabay

What's News

  • EU Solvency II changes take effect Jan. 30 and could free €80 billion in regulatory capital, per S&P Global Ratings.
  • Capital charges on some private equity and senior structured credit will fall by more than half; long-term equity investments qualify for a 22% charge versus 49% for most unlisted assets.
  • Risk-weighted floors on senior securitizations are set to drop to 5% from 10% under a preliminary agreement.
  • Europe had almost €1.3 trillion of securitizations outstanding at end-June, up 2.7% year on year, per AFME.
  • CLOs are 15% of US life insurers' books but securitizations are under 1% of EU insurers' books, per MetLife's Laila Kollmorgen.

A regulatory overhaul taking effect on Jan. 30 could free up €80 billion in regulatory capital held by European insurers — and Blackstone Inc., Apollo Global Management Inc. and Pimco are already positioning to capture it.

The changes to EU insurance rules, known as Solvency II, lower capital charges on complex securitized assets and stand to unlock billions in funding for EU priorities including digital sovereignty, defense and decarbonization. The €80 billion figure is an immediate estimate based on insurers' existing holdings, according to S&P Global Ratings.

What does the reform actually change?

Capital requirements for some private equity and senior structured credit investments will fall sharply — in certain cases by more than half. Easier rules for long-term equity investments will allow more holdings to qualify for a 22% capital charge, compared with 39% for ordinary listed shares and 49% for most private equity and other unlisted investments.

A parallel package will overhaul securitization rules — the creation of tradeable assets out of credit and company stakes. Policymakers have reached a preliminary agreement to cut risk-weighted floors on the senior portions of certain securitizations to 5% from 10%, Bloomberg News reported last month. Banks will also face lower capital requirements on their exposures.

The prize is access to part of the EU's €10 trillion ($11 trillion) insurance asset pile. But some rule changes will not directly affect Europe's largest insurers such as Allianz SE, AXA SA and Generali, which use internal models to calculate capital charges. The vast majority of European insurers stand to benefit, according to S&P.

How fast will insurers move?

Slowly, most observers concede. "Insurance companies, institutional investors, they are no speed boats," said Fabian Gerlich, head of insurance and public pensions coverage for Germany at Deutsche Asset Management in Frankfurt. "Requirements for investor due diligence, transparency and data collection as well as documentation are vast and can prove a hurdle to onboard securitization as a new asset class."

Insurers must still approve new mandates, build expertise and match less-liquid investments to their liabilities. The memory of opaque mortgage securities' role in the 2008 financial crisis has made regulators cautious — and that caution has spread to institutional investors.

Proponents of the reform argue the old rules trapped savings. Huw van Steenis, Oliver Wyman's former vice chair and now an Apollo partner, argues Solvency II made long-term infrastructure projects and packages of small-business loans economically unattractive for insurers. Former Bank of France governor Christian Noyer said in a 2024 report that Europe retained excessive prudential penalties calibrated to practices that were no longer relevant.

"Insurers want to invest more in Europe's needs," said Apollo's Diego De Giorgi, head of Europe since earlier this year. "We are there as a provider of long-term capital, but also as a provider of solutions and a potentially great partner to all these financial institutions," De Giorgi said at Bloomberg's Global Credit Forum in London on Wednesday.

"We're seeing growing interest in securitized assets as insurers assess the opportunities created by Solvency II reform, with collateralized loan obligations and private investment-grade credit among the clearest beneficiaries," said Dan Leiter, who oversees Blackstone's credit and insurance business outside the US. "Some insurers will move more quickly than others, and a slower adoption can be healthy for market dynamics."

Why are regulators worried?

The European Insurance and Occupational Pensions Authority has warned the capital relief risks eroding the system's buffers. "The reality is that once these changes take effect, the impact on solvency ratios may appear small, but there will be less actual capital in the system backing that number up in today's environment of interconnected risks and high uncertainties," said EIOPA chair Petra Hielkema. "The capital relief is not intended to simply fund payouts for shareholders and managers." The ECB has voiced similar concerns. Doubt over valuations in private credit and buyout firms remains elevated, raising the risk of broader financial turbulence.

Europe had almost €1.3 trillion of securitizations outstanding, including CLOs, at the end of June, according to the Association for Financial Markets in Europe — up 2.7% over a year, but still a fraction of the US market.

Will the money stay in Europe?

Not necessarily. Booming US debt markets, driven by the AI build-out's immense capital needs, are producing higher-yield opportunities faster than any European market. Nuveen, which manages $2.6 trillion, said in marketing materials this year: "The US provides scale where allocations can happen in the near term as the European market looks to recover lost ground."

The growth potential is nonetheless large: CLOs make up 15% of US life insurers' investment books, while securitizations of all types account for less than 1% of EU insurers' books, according to Laila Kollmorgen, global head of CLO tranche investments at MetLife Investment Management. "The solvency regime really was the only regime in the world that did not include securitizations and very specifically CLOs," she said. "Solvency II for European CLOs is going to have a huge, huge impact."

The reform's promise of €80 billion is real on paper; how much of it reaches European projects, rather than US debt markets or shareholder payouts, will depend on insurers' appetite to move.

Source: insurancejournal.com

Share this article:

More from Olivia Hart

Olivia Hart

Show full bio

Staff writer covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.

2,319 articles

Related articles

« Previous article