Republicans Move to Shield Big Oil From Climate Liability
Eleven states, two tribal governments and dozens of municipalities have sued big oil over climate damage. A stalled Republican immunity bill could revive before Democrats take office.
By Amara Osei
4 min read

What's News
- April: Ted Cruz and Harriet Hageman introduced companion Senate and House versions of the Stop Climate Shakedowns bill.
- The bill has four parts, including dismissal of existing climate lawsuits, a bar on new suits and pre-emption of state action.
- Eleven states, two tribal governments and dozens of municipalities have sued fossil fuel companies.
- September: The bill stalled after the House Judiciary Committee failed to advance it.
- Five states enacted expansive legal protections for the fossil-fuel industry this legislative cycle, according to Shornstein.
By Amara Osei
Eleven states, two tribal governments and dozens of municipalities have sued fossil fuel companies over climate damage; Iyla Shornstein, political director for the Center for Climate Integrity, says a Republican bill would dismiss those cases.
Introduced in April by Republican lawmakers Ted Cruz and Harriet Hageman, the Stop Climate Shakedowns bill has companion Senate and House versions. According to Shornstein, it would also bar new lawsuits, void climate superfund laws and declare the federal government the sole authority over greenhouse-gas emissions and the climate crisis, pre-empting states.
Why are Republicans seeking legal immunity?
Cruz issued a statement announcing the Senate bill: “Radical environmental groups have waged a coordinated campaign to weaponize our judicial system against American energy producers, including many in Texas,” he said. “They’re using meritless lawsuits to bankrupt our energy industry, kill good paying jobs and drive up the cost of electricity and gasoline for hardworking families.”
The American Petroleum Institute made stopping climate lawsuits and superfund laws a top priority this year. The bill stalled in September when the House Judiciary Committee failed to advance it.
Shornstein said voters were confronting skyrocketing gas prices and record profits at big oil. “The elections sent a pretty clear message that our elected leaders need to be spending their time helping working families, not major corporations like big oil,” she said.
Can the bill pass before Democrats take office?
Following the blue-wave election, Republican lawmakers were rushing high-priority bills before newly elected Democrats take office. Hundreds of elected leaders, joined by climate groups, sent a letter to Democratic leadership urging rejection of any proposal shielding fossil fuel companies from climate liability.
Shornstein said lawmakers could still rush the bill through by year-end or attach immunity language to other legislation before the current Congress ends. She said Trump, the GOP and big oil’s allies wanted to bail out the fossil-fuel industry while they still held power, calling the effort a last-ditch attempt.
Kathy Mulvey, program director for fossil fuel accountability at the Union of Concerned Scientists, urged supporters to remain vigilant, mobilize and pressure Congress to reject the measure. She expects the lame-duck session to provide an opportunity to push through the Cruz-Hageman bill.
What is source attribution science?
The bill would bar source attribution science, a growing field that connects climate disasters to emissions from specific oil and gas companies. The measure says such efforts lack scientific credibility and are therefore arbitrary. Mulvey said targeting the field and the scientists leading it shows how threatened the industry feels about accountability for the harms it causes.
Which lawsuits and state laws would disappear?
The lawsuits draw on science linking climate disasters to fossil-fuel emissions and increasing evidence that companies deceived the public about internal warnings. New York and Vermont have enacted climate superfund laws designed to recover disaster costs by shifting the financial burden onto fossil fuel companies that caused them.
Both laws have faced opposition, including Department of Justice challenges. A judge struck down New York’s law in September, and Governor Kathy Hochul is appealing.
What precedents shaped the push?
The immunity campaign follows a pattern of industries asking Congress for liability protection, although not every effort has succeeded. In the 1990s, tobacco companies unsuccessfully lobbied Congress for a shield while facing dozens of lawsuits seeking costs from smoking-related illnesses.
In 2005, the National Rifle Association (NRA) secured the Protection of Lawful Commerce in Arms Act after a wave of lawsuits sought to hold gunmakers liable for violence. The gun law may have inspired the oil campaign.
Republican state attorneys general sought a liability shield for big oil in a letter last year to former U.S. Attorney General Pam Bondi, comparing the request directly with the 2005 gun shield. Mulvey said the fossil-fuel industry explicitly invokes the gun industry’s 2005 liability waiver as its model.
Is a state-level campaign underway?
ProPublica reported that immunity bills in a number of Republican-controlled statehouses formed part of a coordinated rightwing network involving activist Leonard Leo and the American Legislative Exchange Council. Leo did not dispute the findings. He argued that decades of left control had captured the institutions shaping society.
He said his enterprise supports groups committed to crushing liberal dominance and restoring balance. Five states enacted legislation this cycle providing expansive legal protections for the fossil-fuel industry, according to Shornstein. She described the strategy as a holistic effort to escape accountability.
The lame-duck session now tests whether Republicans can revive the four-part shield or attach its immunity language elsewhere before newly elected Democrats take office. Passage would dismiss existing climate lawsuits, bar new claims and void state superfund laws, the outcomes Shornstein and Mulvey are urging Congress to reject.
Original: climateintegrity.org
More from Amara Osei
Show full bio
Senior reporter covering companies, deals and strategy in entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.
2,260 articles