Leadership

Citizens Property Insurance CEO Tim Cerio to Step Down in January

Citizens Property Insurance CEO Tim Cerio will step down in January after nearly four years, during which the state insurer shrank from over 1.4 million policies to 216,447.

By Amara Osei

3 min read

BREAKING: Florida Citizens’ CEO Cerio to Step Down in January
BREAKING: Florida Citizens’ CEO Cerio to Step Down in JanuaryJayMantri / pixabay

What's News

  • Tim Cerio announced Nov. 20 he will leave Citizens in January after nearly four years as CEO.
  • Citizens' policy count fell from more than 1.4 million in September 2023 to 216,447 as of end-October this year.
  • Cerio took over in January 2023 after CEO Barry Gilway retired, amid 10 carrier insolvencies.
  • Cerio stays on Donalds' transition team and as vice chairman of the State University System board.

Tim Cerio, president/CEO and executive director of Citizens Property Insurance Corp., will leave the Florida state-created insurer in January to return to the private sector. He announced the move in a message to Citizens staff on Friday, Nov. 20.

"After nearly four incredibly rewarding years as your president/CEO and executive director, I will be leaving Citizens in January to return to the private sector," Cerio wrote. He didn't say what he plans to pursue next.

Cerio took the top job in January 2023, after former CEO Barry Gilway retired. A lawyer by training, Cerio had previously served as Citizens' general counsel in 2015 and 2016. He holds both his bachelor's degree and his law degree from the University of Florida.

It's unclear who might replace him. "Over the next several weeks I will be working with our Board of Governors on a transition plan, so stay tuned for more specifics," Cerio's message reads.

What happened to Citizens' policy count?

Cerio inherited the insurer near the worst of Florida's property insurance crisis. Ten insurance carriers went insolvent and rates soared, pushing policyholders across the state toward Citizens, where premium increases are limited by statute.

By September 2023, Citizens' policy count had passed 1.4 million, making it by far the largest property insurer in the state. Then the math reversed. After Florida enacted 2022 and 2023 legislative changes that curbed runaway claims litigation, Citizens shrank to 216,447 policies in force as of the end of October this year — its smallest level in more than 20 years.

"The reforms enacted by the Florida Legislature provided the tools to change course," Cerio noted in his message. "But legislation alone doesn't create results."

He said Citizens has become a more-focused organization while maintaining financial discipline and readiness. He credited staff for the turnaround, noting that shrinking an organization can be more challenging than growing one.

"Many of you took on new responsibilities, adapted to changing processes and supported colleagues through transitions," he wrote.

What did the board say?

Citizens Board Chairman Carlos Beruff praised Cerio's leadership in a statement sent by Citizens on Friday morning.

"Mr. Cerio has been a steady, principled leader for Citizens during one of the most critical periods in the history of Florida's property insurance market," Beruff said. "Tim has a long track record of public service, and he leaves Citizens stronger and better positioned for the future. On behalf of the Board, I thank him for his service to Citizens and to the people of Florida."

What's next for Cerio?

Cerio isn't leaving public life entirely. He will continue as a member of Governor-elect Byron Donalds' transition team and as vice chairman of the Board of Governors of the State University System, according to the Citizens press release.

His departure hands the incoming CEO a very different institution from the one Cerio joined: a depopulated, financially disciplined insurer rather than a fast-swelling residual market absorbing the fallout from insolvencies. Whoever the Board of Governors selects will take over an organization still managing the transition Cerio described — with the transition plan itself expected to take shape over the coming weeks.

Source: insurancejournal.com

Share this article:

More from Amara Osei

Amara Osei

Show full bio

Senior reporter covering companies, deals and strategy in entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.

2,503 articles

Related articles

« Previous article