Leadership

Counteroffers Fail: Replace Raises With Deferred Pay, Executives Say

Counteroffering top performers with raises makes them price-sensitive, one founder argues. Deferred compensation and supplemental retirement plans reward tenure without diluting equity.

By Amara Osei

3 min read

I Used to Counteroffer My Best Employees With More Money. Now I Rely on These 3 Strategies.
I Used to Counteroffer My Best Employees With More Money. Now I Rely on These 3 Strategies.Pexels / pixabay

What's News

  • Replacing an employee costs upwards of 200% of their salary, per HR Morning statistics.
  • McKinsey estimates top-value roles make up about 5% of a workforce but contribute 800% more.
  • The author identified fewer than 10 roles whose vacancy would materially hurt his business.
  • Deferred compensation grows tax-free while employees stay, without inflating payroll.
  • Supplemental executive retirement plans can reduce churn among the highest-paid performers, per SmartAsset.

Replacing an employee costs upwards of 200% of what they were making, according to statistics reported by HR Morning. That figure is probably conservative, because losing a valuable team member triggers lowered productivity and tabled projects as colleagues scramble to absorb the departed employee's workload.

That math pushed one business leader to abandon the standard playbook of counteroffering resigning top performers with raises, bonuses and equity. Writing for Entrepreneur, he argues the tactic almost always worked in the short run — but it backfired.

"It was a tactic that almost always worked, but it didn't create loyalty," he wrote. "Instead, it made those people price-sensitive, and they eventually found organizations willing to pay more, so they left anyway."

He isn't suggesting that counteroffering with money is wrong. His objection is structural: it's reactive and arbitrary. Without a cap on how high you'll go, negotiations become what he calls "a moving target that's out of your control." You may delay the departure, but you won't prevent it without proactive measures.

Which roles actually deserve retention plans?

Not every position drives enterprise value. Citing an older McKinsey and Company article, the author notes that the roles that matter most likely make up about 5% of a workforce — and contribute 800% more than others across the organization.

In his own companies, he says he could typically name fewer than 10 roles that would materially impact the business if left vacant for an extended period. His recommendation: name those roles explicitly, then build a retention plan for each one.

Deferred compensation is his first tool of choice. These structures let team members grow their money tax-free as long as they stay with the organization. The incentive is tied to tenure, not merely performance, and because it applies only to a small group of high-value employees, it doesn't inflate compensation across the company or bloat overall payroll.

Why he stopped giving away equity

Equity once seemed like an obvious retention lever. When he mapped out the risks and rewards, he found massive long-term costs instead.

The core problem: equity permanently dilutes your ability to use it later. If employees already hold a chunk of the company, you can't bargain with it when negotiating with potential investors. Handing out equity also complicates organizational governance and blurs the financial picture, he writes.

His revised approach treats equity as a last resort — something to consider only if it will genuinely bring out an employee's long-term ownership behavior. He advises talking with a professional who has designed executive benefit and compensation structures that retain key people while protecting tax exposure and equity. As a starting resource, he points to Colin Steinberg, a partner at Institutional Architects, who frequently shares advice on executive planning.

What replaces the raise?

The author points to business-friendlier alternatives beyond handing a departing employee more money or equity:

  • Deferred compensation, which delays income in a way that benefits both employer and employee.
  • Supplemental executive retirement plans, which layer additional retirement benefits on top of existing ones, tied to both tenure and performance. These help C-suite employees see meaningful future value in putting down roots, and — as SmartAsset explains — can trim churn among a company's highest-paid performers.

Structured correctly, these tools avoid immediate strain on the balance sheet. They also let employers improve tax efficiency, reduce volatile compensation models and keep control of their equity, the author writes.

His conclusion cuts against the usual framing of retention as a culture problem. Founders who lose their most valuable people — while otherwise building solid, fair companies — don't have a retention problem, he argues. They have a problem with how they've structured long-term compensation for their most impactful roles. The employers with real leverage, he writes, are the ones who build smarter systems that incentivize key players without losing ground on payroll, taxes or the cap table.

Original: hrmorning.com

Share this article:

More from Amara Osei

Amara Osei

Show full bio

Senior reporter covering companies, deals and strategy in entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.

2,393 articles

Related articles

« Previous article