Democrats’ Midterm Win Does Not Solve Trump’s Tariff Problem
Democrats gained ground in the Nov. 3 midterms on tariff affordability, but a two-thirds veto hurdle, Republican resistance and $370 billion in tariff revenue complicate repeal.
By Olivia Hart
6 min read

What's News
- Yale University’s Budget Lab says the average U.S. tariff rose from about 2.5% in January 2025 to 11.2%.
- The Budget Lab estimates tariffs cost the average U.S. household about $900 a year.
- Trump’s tariffs generated nearly $370 billion over the last two budget years, according to The Associated Press.
- The AP Voter Poll surveyed more than 100,000 midterm voters; about two-thirds said tariffs hurt the national or local economy.
- Overriding Trump’s veto requires two-thirds majorities in both chambers, according to The Associated Press.
The average U.S. household now faces about $900 a year in tariff costs, according to Yale University’s Budget Lab, as the average U.S. tariff rose from roughly 2.5% in January 2025 to 11.2%. U.S. importers pay the tariffs and often pass the charges to consumers, the Budget Lab said.
Why did tariffs become a winning issue?
The Associated Press linked that burden to inflation and higher gasoline prices caused by Trump’s war with Iran. Democrats’ stunning gains in the Nov. 3 midterms followed a campaign focused on tariff-driven price increases.
About two-thirds of voters said Trump’s tariffs had hurt the national economy or their local economy; only about two in 10 said they had helped, The AP Voter Poll found after surveying more than 100,000 midterm voters. Voters who saw a negative impact overwhelmingly supported the Democratic candidate in their local U.S. House race, the poll found.
For months, Democrats had argued that import taxes raised prices for families already frustrated by the high cost of living, the Associated Press reported. James Talarico, a Democrat who ran for a U.S. Senate seat in Texas, tied Trump’s tariff on Mexican tomatoes to the price of chips and salsa.
“Chips and salsa,” he said, “are sacred in Texas.” Talarico became the first Democrat elected to Texas’s U.S. Senate seat since 1988, the Associated Press reported. “Americans don’t like tariffs,” said Scott Lincicome at the Cato Institute’s Center for Trade Policy Studies. “They connect them to the cost of living.”
Republicans controlled Congress during the period, yet they did not reassert their tariff authority or challenge Trump’s aggressive use of the taxes, the Associated Press reported. Voters penalized the tariffs, but the election did not settle what Democrats should replace them with.
Can Democrats repeal Trump’s tariffs?
The U.S. Constitution gives Congress tariff power, but lawmakers have ceded it to the president over time, the Associated Press reported. Trump used that authority in his first term to launch a trade war with China and tax steel and aluminum imports as national-security threats.
In his second term, the Supreme Court rejected his most ambitious tariffs in February. Yet a high protective wall remained around the U.S. economy under the broad authority Congress had given up, the Associated Press reported.
Trump’s use of tariffs has proved erratic. Last year, he imposed a 50% tariff on Brazil because its government had prosecuted his friend, former Brazilian President Jair Bolsonaro; the Supreme Court struck down that tariff, among others, the Associated Press reported.
“Trade policy has sort of gone off the rails and has lost a strategic focus,” said Inu Manak, senior fellow at the Peterson Institute for International Economics. “Now, we’re just using tariffs as a blunt cudgel instead of addressing real challenges.”
Democrats divide over the remedy, the Associated Press reported. Some favor a return to the low-tariff policies Trump dismantled; others want tariffs to confront unfair trade practices and U.S. adversaries such as China.
“There’s going to be a big debate over what should the Democrats’ tariff and trade policy be,” said Ryan Majerus, a former U.S. trade official during Trump’s first term and in the Biden administration. “It can’t just be: We don’t like what Trump’s doing.”
Tariff revenue adds another obstacle. The taxes generated nearly $370 billion over the last two budget years while federal debt stood at $40 trillion, the Associated Press reported. The AP did not specify how much revenue each Democratic proposal would surrender.
Sally Laing, former chief trade counsel for the Senate Finance Committee and now a partner at Akin Gump, said Democrats have “just been elected to come in and address concerns about affordability.” “It’s not as easy as people may think,” she added.
In response to questions from The Associated Press, White House spokesman Matthew Middleton said: “President Trump will never waver from putting Americans and America First, whether in trade negotiations or through an economic agenda of tax cuts and deregulation.” Trump remains committed to his protectionist agenda, the Associated Press reported.
Democratic campaign proposals would repeal the July tariffs on 60 U.S. trading partners for allegedly failing to curb trade in forced-labor products or require Congress to approve Trump’s levies, the Associated Press reported. Democrats also promised to cancel some tariffs and curb his legal authority.
Every proposal faces Trump’s veto. Overriding it requires a two-thirds majority in both chambers, and even a sweep of every congressional race still undecided this year would leave Democrats short of the votes alone, the Associated Press reported.
The midterms make “a veto-proof vote more possible,” said Majerus, now a partner at King & Spalding. “Are Republicans willing to break with Trump? I’m still skeptical.” The AP described Republican defections as uncertain, not secured.
Which tariffs could draw Republican votes?
Oregon Sen. Ron Wyden, the top Democrat on the Senate Finance Committee who will be its chair when Democrats take over, sees ending Trump’s 50% August tariffs on $20 billion of Canadian imports as a possible Republican opening. “That’s what we’re focused on, figuring out a way to beat Trump and his veto,” he said.
The levies damaged relations with a neighboring ally, prompted retaliatory tariffs from Ottawa and hurt U.S. companies dependent on trade with Canada, the Associated Press reported. “The Canadian tariffs, these tariffs on our allies, are wildly unpopular,” said Sally Laing.
Gellert Global Group, a food importer based in Elizabeth, New Jersey, is contending with tariffs on Canadian cheese. “We are paying millions of dollars in additional costs and tariffs to maintain our distribution and have our products on the shelf,” said co-CEO Thomas Gellert. “We’re absorbing that today. It’s not sustainable for our business.”
The Liberty Justice Center represents Gellert Global Group in a lawsuit against the Trump administration over the Canada tariffs, the Associated Press reported. The furor over those levies contributed to longtime Republican Sen. Susan Collins’s loss in Maine, even after Trump exempted products from the tariffs to aid her reelection bid.
Wyden told Republicans they can “help lower costs for American families or they can continue to defend Trump’s tariffs and make clear whose side they’re on.” His words frame repeal as a test of party priorities, not a settled policy package.
Wyden’s next test is whether he can recruit enough Republicans to target the Canada levies; absent that coalition, the tariff program Democrats used in the midterms will remain largely in force.
Source: Fast Company
More from Olivia Hart
Show full bio
Staff writer covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.
2,205 articles