Economy & Policy

EU Takes 11 Years to Restrict PFAS; Most of 10,000+ Are Unregistered

EU auditors say PFAS restrictions take 11 years, most of more than 10,000 chemicals remain outside REACH, and decade-old food and water limits leave testing gaps.

By Grace Kim

3 min read

EU Moving Too Slowly to Tackle Health Risks From ‘Forever Chemicals,’ Auditors Say
EU Moving Too Slowly to Tackle Health Risks From ‘Forever Chemicals,’ Auditors Sayfotoblend / pixabay

What's News

  • EU restrictions on PFAS take 11 years on average, including six years for hazard assessment and five for the restriction process.
  • More than 10,000 PFAS exist and over 1,400 are manufactured, while most remain outside REACH registration.
  • Only substances imported above 1,000 tons a year require full toxicity testing data.
  • At maximum permitted levels, 7 grams of anchovies could push a person over the tolerable weekly PFAS intake.
  • ECHA is expected to submit its final assessment of a potential PFAS ban next month.

By Grace Kim

EU restrictions on PFAS take 11 years on average to come into force, according to the European Court of Auditors (ECA).

Joëlle Elvinger, the ECA member responsible for the report, said the average includes six years for hazard assessment and five years for the restriction process itself. In its Wednesday report, the ECA said the EU is moving too slowly to protect people from “forever chemicals.”

The auditors said PFAS break down very slowly in the environment and have been linked to higher risks of certain cancers, thyroid disorders, reproductive problems and weakened immune systems. The ECA said many substances remain untested and unrestricted.

Why are most PFAS still outside EU controls?

The ECA said the EU began restricting PFAS in 2006. More than 10,000 PFAS exist, and manufacturers produce more than 1,400, according to the report.

The report identifies two broad markets:

  • Consumer goods, including lipstick and frying pans.
  • Industrial sectors, including medical devices, semiconductors, construction and transport.

“We are in a race against time. Most PFAS are not registered under REACH, the EU’s system for regulating chemicals,” Elvinger told reporters.

Most fall outside REACH because they do not meet its registration criteria or its minimum import threshold of 1 metric ton a year, the ECA said. Only substances imported in volumes above 1,000 tons a year require full toxicity testing data.

Polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE), one of the most widely used PFAS polymers, does not require REACH registration. The ECA identified it as a key ingredient in non-stick cookware and waterproof textiles.

The core problem is scope: most of the 10,000-plus PFAS inventory sits outside the EU registration system.

Can stricter food and water limits reduce exposure?

The ECA said PFAS mainly enter the human body through food and drinking water contaminated by landfills, firefighting foam, industrial emissions, farming and wastewater.

The auditors found generally high compliance with existing EU drinking-water limits, and some countries have adopted stricter standards. Those limits, however, rest on science around a decade old, according to the ECA.

For food, the ECA found significant differences in compliance and testing among EU countries.

“If certain foods contained the maximum permitted PFAS level, a person could exceed their tolerable weekly intake after eating only around 7 grams of anchovies, 39 grams of wild salmon, 181 grams of eggs, or 237 grams of beef,” Elvinger said.

The report also said trifluoroacetic acid (TFA), a breakdown product of industrial chemicals and pesticides, goes unmonitored. The ECA described TFA as the most abundant PFAS present in the environment.

High drinking-water compliance does not close the gap created by decade-old limits, uneven food testing and an unmonitored breakdown product.

Can national restrictions outpace EU rules?

France and Denmark have introduced tighter restrictions instead of waiting for EU legislation, the ECA said. France’s January ban on imports and sales covers certain products containing PFAS, including cosmetics, clothing and ski wax.

More than a third of EU countries do not carry out checks to enforce existing rules, the auditors said.

The ECA cannot force policy changes, but its reports often increase pressure on the European Commission and EU governments to act.

The report also warned that restricting one PFAS often leads to “regrettable substitution.” In that pattern, a restricted PFAS is replaced by another PFAS that may pose similar risks, Elvinger said.

National restrictions can move sooner, but uneven checks and substitution risks can weaken their effect.

What is the EU preparing next?

A European Commission spokesperson said the Commission is considering a ban on PFAS in consumer goods such as cosmetics, food contact materials and outdoor clothing. The spokesperson said the plan would allow uses in critical cases under strict conditions until alternatives are available.

The European Chemicals Agency (ECHA) is expected to submit its final assessment of a potential PFAS ban next month. The Commission will use that assessment to develop its proposal.

ECHA’s assessment next month will give the Commission the basis for a proposal, but the ECA’s 11-year average restriction cycle leaves speed as the central test.

Source: insurancejournal.com

Share this article:

More from Grace Kim

Grace Kim

Show full bio

Market editor covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.

2,387 articles

Related articles

« Previous articleNext article »