Gen Z job seekers understate rehire odds by 3 percentage points
New York Fed data shows unemployed workers under 30 understate rehire odds by 3 percentage points, while two-year employees face half the actual layoff risk they perceive.
By Grace Kim
4 min read

What's News
- Workers under 30 swung from a 6.3-point job-finding overestimate to a 3-point underestimate after the pandemic.
- The study uses the Current Population Survey and Survey of Consumer Expectations and follows workers unemployed for four weeks or less.
- Business Insider reported that 25% of workers ages 16 to 24 lost their jobs in 2020.
- After two years in a job, the actual job-loss rate is half the perceived rate.
By Grace Kim
Workers under 30 swung from overestimating their job-finding odds by 6.3 percentage points before the pandemic to understating them by 3 points afterward, according to a November 2026 analysis from the New York Federal Reserve's Liberty Street Economics blog.
Business Insider's summary of the study says “workers are far too pessimistic about their ability to find a job,” with the sharpest mismatch among younger unemployed workers. That finding reverses the pre-2020 pattern and leaves job seekers more cautious than their actual rehire results justify.
What did the New York Fed measure?
Researchers compared workers' expected job-finding rates with their actual success in securing a new role. The analysis uses the Current Population Survey and the Survey of Consumer Expectations to compare expectations with outcomes.
It follows newly unemployed Americans who had been jobless and looking for work for four weeks or fewer. For that group, the study tracks the expectation of finding work against the actual arrival of a new job.
Before 2020, the two measures tracked closely across American workers. The pandemic drove them apart, and the New York Fed analysis says they have not realigned since.
Post-pandemic expectations no longer track observed job-finding outcomes closely.
How large is the younger-worker gap?
Workers under 30 previously tracked above their actual results. The New York Fed data show a sharp reversal:
- Before the pandemic: workers under 30 overstated their expected job-finding rate by 6.3 percentage points.
- After the pandemic: they understated it by 3 percentage points.
Those figures leave the younger-worker group's expected job-finding rate below its actual rate. The New York Fed analysis says the overall pessimism is especially concentrated among workers under 30.
Younger workers now understate the rehire odds that the data show.
What happened to Gen Z in 2020?
Business Insider reported that 25% of workers ages 16 to 24 lost their jobs in 2020. Gen Z workers bore a disproportionate share of layoffs at the immediate onset of the pandemic, according to the report.
The report links that shock to workers' current pessimism. It says pandemic-era labor-market scars may explain why Gen Z workers who lose a job now expect that they will not land another role, even though the rehire data show otherwise.
The explanation remains plausible rather than proven. The New York Fed study measures the expectation gap; the 2020 layoff figure supplies a documented shock that may have shaped it.
The data establish the pessimism; the 25% layoff rate is a plausible source, not a settled cause.
Are tenured workers overestimating layoffs?
The New York Fed analysis finds a second mismatch among experienced employees. Historically, the longer a worker stays in a job, the less likely that worker is to lose it. Actual job-loss rates reflect that pattern; worker perceptions do not.
After two years in a role, the actual job-loss rate is half the perceived rate. The New York Fed analysis therefore finds that long-tenured employees are more secure in actual outcomes than they feel.
Business Insider also suggests that layoffs may have left workers unusually conscious of risk even when tenure works in their favor. The result is a measurable mismatch between perceived and actual job loss.
Tenure has given workers more protection than they believe.
Why do millennials remain wary?
The report points to millennials as another group carrying recession-era scars. They were more likely to face layoffs during the comedown from the post-pandemic, zero-interest-rate hiring spree, according to the source.
Those layoffs may now shape how securely established employees assess their standing, even when their actual job-loss risk is low. The New York Fed data support the mismatch; Business Insider presents the millennial experience as a possible contributor.
Millennials may explain part of the fear among otherwise secure, long-tenured workers.
What do the numbers mean for employers?\n
Two findings sit at the center:
- Newly unemployed workers under 30: actual job-finding rates exceed expectations by 3 percentage points.
- Workers with two years of tenure: actual job-loss rates are half their perceived rates.
The first result says job seekers may be underselling their own rehire prospects. The second says employers may face more internal layoff anxiety than their two-year retention data would justify.
If the patterns persist, recruiting teams may encounter applicants who discount their rehire odds, while established employees may remain more fearful of layoffs than their tenure data warrant. The near-term test is whether worker expectations catch up with actual outcomes; so far, the New York Fed analysis finds the gap remains open.
Source: feeds.businessinsider.com
More from Grace Kim
Show full bio
Market editor covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.
2,447 articles