Economy & Policy

Google refuses UK demand to remove Russell Brand's prison video

Google refused a UK government request to remove Russell Brand's prison video, viewed almost 850,000 times, as Labour's Jess Phillips says a second Online Safety Act is "very likely."

By Grace Kim

4 min read

New law ‘may be needed’ after Google rejects call to remove Russell Brand’s YouTube prison message
New law ‘may be needed’ after Google rejects call to remove Russell Brand’s YouTube prison messageJESHOOTS-com / pixabay

What's News

  • Google rejected a UK government request to remove a Russell Brand YouTube video with almost 850,000 views
  • Brand's channel has been suspended from YouTube monetisation since September 2023
  • The video was broadcast to 6.6 million subscribers days after his conviction
  • The 2023 Online Safety Act does not explicitly cover prisoners using social media
  • Jess Phillips said a second online safety act is "very likely"

Google has rejected a UK government request to take down a Russell Brand YouTube video that has drawn almost 850,000 views since his conviction — and Labour MP Jess Phillips says a second online safety act is now "very likely."

The video, broadcast by Brand's wife Laura to their 6.6 million YouTube subscribers just days after his conviction, carries a message claiming Brand was not guilty of the sexual offences a jury convicted him of. The Ministry of Justice opened an investigation into whether he broke prison rules. The Prison Service asked Google to remove the clip amid warnings it was causing distress to sexual abuse survivors. Google said no.

A Google spokesperson said: "We're aware of the new content and our teams are investigating. We suspended Russell Brand's channel from the YouTube partner program in September 2023. The channel has not been able to monetise on YouTube since then."

In plain words: the channel has earned nothing on YouTube for two years, but the video itself stays up.

Why can't the government force a takedown?

Phillips, a former minister for safeguarding and violence against women and girls, admitted the government lacks the power to compel platforms to remove this kind of distressing content. The reason sits in the 2023 Online Safety Act, which protects users from illegal content and shields under-18s from material such as pornography. It's being phased in, and this year additional legislation updated Ofcom's codes of practice. Nowhere does it explicitly address prisoners broadcasting to the outside world through social media.

"Ofcom codes on women's safety online are just voluntary and frankly voluntary codes to tech companies is the triumph of hope over experience," Phillips told BBC Radio 4's Today programme.

"This is an entirely new era and frankly the regulations are almost certainly not in place for the government to just demand that this be taken down," she said.

Her conclusion: the rules don't fit the case, so the rules need rewriting.

What would a second Online Safety Act cover?

Phillips didn't wait for a review cycle to say legislation is coming. "Regulatory frameworks, changes and potentially a second online safety act is needed, because before we haven't had prisoners who had massive YouTube followings," she said.

She argued pressure on Google will keep building — and framed the company's own calculus in blunt terms. "All Google do by leaving this up is show that those codes are not good enough," she said.

"I think it [a new online safety act] is very likely and the more that these companies show that they are not putting victims at the absolute heart of their policymaking in their content within their own content schemes. If Google want less regulation they will take this down."

Who else is piling on?

The victims' commissioner for London, Andrea Simon, called on Google to act, and ministers joined on Thursday morning. Josh MacAlister, the minister for children and families, pointed to a precedent: "I hope they make the same decision that Meta has." Meta, Facebook's parent company, disabled Brand's accounts for breaching standards prohibiting accounts "harmful to the community."

Housing minister Matthew Pennycook told Sky News: "It's quite a disturbing video, actually, but abhorrent in the message it's conveying."

"Imagine if you're one of the victims of Brand's heinous crimes and you see that video. Prisoners are already banned from making statements to the media. We think this is an exceptional case where MoJ ministers have asked Google to remove this specific content and we hope they'll do so."

Not everyone backs compelled removal. Conservative leader Kemi Badenoch said she was concerned if prisoners could send messages from prison, but noted Laura Brand is a separate person and YouTube is "a private platform." "Immediately demanding that private platforms take down without looking at whether a law has been broken is not where I would start from," she said.

The Brand case is the sharpest example yet, but not the first. Concerns have previously been raised about the far-right activist Stephen Yaxley-Lennon, known as Tommy Robinson, keeping a social media presence. For platforms, the immediate question is whether one video's 850,000 views are worth the regulatory fight Phillips is promising.

Source: theguardian.com

Share this article:

More from Grace Kim

Grace Kim

Show full bio

Market editor covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.

2,419 articles

Related articles

« Previous articleNext article »