£1.1bn for hiring Neets: the employers Milburn needs barely exist
Milburn's Neet review offers £1.1bn in hiring subsidies, but 17% of firms say the money would change their hiring — and 1 in 4 UK jobs are 'bad jobs'.
By Grace Kim
4 min read

What's News
- Roughly 1 million UK 16- to 24-year-olds are not in education, employment or training
- Of £3.6bn cut from young people's benefits, £1.1bn goes to businesses that hire Neets
- Only 17% of surveyed businesses say a government payment would change their hiring
- 1 in 4 British jobs are 'bad jobs', rising to 1 in 3 in London (LSE's Kirsten Sehnbruch)
- Press use of 'economic inactivity' is up 1,500% since 2017, per James Morrison's The Workless
Alan Milburn's review wants to hand businesses £1.1 billion of the £3.6 billion taken from young people's benefits to reward them for hiring Neets. The catch: most British companies have no employees at all.
That's the core problem Aditya Chakrabortty lays out in his Guardian column dissecting the review, which has become the first big policy of Andy Burnham's new government — even though Burnham never commissioned it. The headline number everyone repeated this week is 1 million: roughly one million 16- to 24-year-olds are not in education, employment or training.
Chakrabortty builds his case on three figures that, he notes, have appeared nowhere in this week's coverage.
How much louder did the panic get?
Try 1,500%. Press discussion of "economic inactivity" has grown that much since 2017, according to James Morrison's new book The Workless: Stigma, Unpaid Labour and the Myth of Economic inactivity. By 2024 the phrase appeared thousands of times, often on front pages. Usage of "sicknote" surged similarly, and young people are the recurring motif.
Yet Milburn himself concedes the Neet rate has stayed roughly flat for a quarter of a century. This is a chronic problem rooted in economic and social failure, not a sudden shock. Chakrabortty argues Britain's rightwing media manufactured urgency — and points to Isabel Oakeshott of Reform UK attacking "parasites" who "prefer to just sit on the sofa and order their Deliveroo and drive their Motability free vehicle and take everything that the state can offer," remarks delivered on a Rupert Murdoch-owned channel before she moved to Dubai, outside the UK tax system.
Milburn, a Blair-era health secretary who went on to make millions from private equity healthcare, frames poverty and inequality as "at the core" of the problem — while proposing policies that strip many young disabled people of benefits and make them poorer.
Who is supposed to do the hiring?
The number zero. The overwhelming majority of UK companies are sole traders with no staff — Uber drivers, gas fitters, pilates instructors. Milburn's subsidy model assumes a country of toolmakers and assembly lines. Burnham promises to "reindustrialise Britain"; George Osborne once pledged a "march of the makers." In reality, Britain's largest private employers include Tesco, Asda and Amazon warehouses. The land of Volkswagen and Siemens is called Germany.
You can't push people into jobs that aren't there, Chakrabortty writes. One of Milburn's own surveys found only 17% of businesses think a Whitehall payment would prompt them to hire more young people than they otherwise would. The likelier outcome: companies pocket the three grand for hires they'd have made anyway.
How bad are the jobs on offer?
One in four. Kirsten Sehnbruch of the London School of Economics calculates that a quarter of all British jobs are "bad jobs" — precarious contracts, poor pay, poor conditions. In London, it's one in three. That share has stayed huge despite low unemployment, so market forces clearly aren't fixing it.
After 20 years advising governments on labour markets, Sehnbruch has a rule: land in the bad-job economy and you're unlikely to get out. Universal credit shuffles people from one bad job to another, and good state-subsidised training doesn't exist. Milburn's review expects Neets to take zero-hours contracts (which the new workers' rights law limits but doesn't scrap), minimum wage and dehumanising work.
What did earlier reviews find?
Westminster has been here before. In 2017, when headlines focused on Deliveroo drivers and Sports Direct warehouses, Theresa May asked Blairite grandee Matthew Taylor to report on modern workplaces. His key finding: British jobs suffered from "one-sided flexibility," where only employers benefited. Almost none of his recommendations became law — perhaps, Chakrabortty suggests, because the review offered too much realism.
What would actually work?
Chakrabortty points to Burnham's own stated goals: a council housebuilding boom and a national care service. Rather than hoping the private sector delivers them, he argues, the public sector should build both directly — as it did before the "40 years of neoliberalism" the prime minister criticises — and train up young people in the process.
Labour market researcher Thanos Angelopoulos notes that approach would redirect taxpayer money away from landlords and private care agencies, lift millions of families out of bad housing and care worries, and create significant public assets. It would also give the next generation good jobs, which "work coaches" and three-grand bungs won't.
Source: theguardian.com
More from Grace Kim
Show full bio
Market editor covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.
2,419 articles