Economy & Policy

Half of 2025 College Grads Work Jobs That Don't Need a Degree

Half of 2025 graduates work jobs that don't require a degree, up from a 39% pre-pandemic average. Indeed's economist blames a low-hire, low-fire market favoring senior talent.

By Nathan Brooks

3 min read

Half of recent college grads can't find a job that actually requires a degree
Half of recent college grads can't find a job that actually requires a degreeCparks / pixabay

What's News

  • 50% of 2025 bachelor's degree holders were underemployed 12 months after graduation, versus a 39% average for 2017-2019.
  • 73% of grads who start out underemployed remain so 10 years after college, per a 2024 Burning Glass Institute and Strada Institute report.
  • Entry-level software engineers average about $82,000 in base pay; retail salespersons average $37,310, per Indeed and 2025 BLS data.
  • Criminal justice, performing arts, and fine arts had the highest 2024 underemployment rates; nursing, aerospace and civil engineering the lowest, per the New York Fed.
  • Indeed economist Sneha Puri expects underemployment to stay elevated for the class of 2026.

Half of the class of 2025 landed in jobs that don't require a college degree within 12 months of graduating — the highest underemployment picture in years, and well above the 2017-2019 average of 39%. The figure comes from hiring-platform data from Indeed, which tracks the share of bachelor's degree holders working in non-degree roles a year after graduation.

The numbers translate simply: one in two new grads is doing work their diploma wasn't needed for. And it's not a blip — the share has climbed steadily over recent years, Indeed's data shows.

Why is this happening now?

Indeed economist Sneha Puri attributes the surge to a low-hire, low-fire job market that has defined the past few years. Employers who do add headcount want experience on day one. They've been leaning on people "who can hit the ground running, as evident from the growth in job postings being driven by senior-level roles," Puri said.

New graduates absorb the hit twice over. "That hits new graduates hardest, because they're most likely to apply for entry-level positions, which not only have seen job postings decline but also get several times as many applications as mid- and senior-level roles, including from people with more experience," Puri said.

So a grad applying to an entry-level opening isn't just competing with classmates. They're up against mid-career professionals bidding down the same postings.

What does underemployment cost over time?

Plenty. Daniel Zhao, chief economist at Glassdoor, laid out the long tail: "For workers who are underemployed or unemployed in their early years after graduating, that can have a stacking effect on their career over time, where they get knocked into a career trajectory that isn't as rewarding, isn't as engaging."

The pay gap is concrete. The Bureau of Labor Statistics lists no formal educational credential for retail salespersons — a job that paid an average of $37,310 a year in 2025 BLS data, versus the overall average wage of $69,770. Software developers typically need a bachelor's degree, and Indeed puts the average base salary for an entry-level software engineer in the US at about $82,000 — more than double the retail figure.

Escaping underemployment is the hard part. "Seventy-three percent of graduates who start out underemployed remain so 10 years after completing college, making them at that point about 3.5 times more likely to be underemployed compared with those who start out in a college-level job," a 2024 report from the Burning Glass Institute and Strada Institute found.

Zhao also flagged the employer side of the equation. A company that hires a college grad into a role below their fit risks getting a disengaged worker who would perform better elsewhere — a real cost when turnover and training budgets are tight.

Which majors are exposed?

Underemployment varies sharply by field. New York Fed analysis of Census Bureau data found that in 2024, criminal justice, performing arts, and fine arts majors posted the three highest underemployment rates. Nursing, aerospace engineering, and civil engineering sat at the bottom of the list — the safest bets for degree-aligned work.

One wrinkle: computer engineering ranks among majors with low underemployment, but it carries the second-highest unemployment rate. Grads there either find degree-level work or no work at all.

What's ahead for the class of 2026?

Puri expects underemployment to stay elevated for the class of 2026. Her conditions for a reversal are specific: "An uptick would only reverse once employers again start to recognize the importance of hiring and investing in entry-level talent to train tomorrow's senior level experts."

That puts the practical question to employers, not just grads. Firms that have stopped building entry-level pipelines are, in Puri's framing, hollowing out their own future senior bench — even as this year's numbers show they hold all the leverage in hiring.

Source: feeds.businessinsider.com

Share this article:

More from Nathan Brooks

Nathan Brooks

Show full bio

News editor covering regulation, policy and their impact on entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.

2,611 articles

Related articles

« Previous article