Private colleges now discount 57.1% of tuition as students walk away
Tuition discounts hit 57.1% at private colleges as yield rates fall and summer melt wipes out committed students. Campuses now spend millions to keep admits.
By Daniel Okafor
4 min read

What's News
- Private nonprofit colleges discounted 57.1% of first-time undergraduate tuition in 2025–26, up from 54.5%.
- Yield at public colleges fell from 32% in 2014 to 22% in 2024.
- Common App direct admissions reached 820,000+ students; participating colleges grew from 119 to 234.
- Georgia State cut summer melt from 22% to 8% with a $125,000 campaign, recovering $3.2 million in tuition.
- Only 66% of surveyed high schoolers want a bachelor's degree, down from 79% in 2025.
Private nonprofit colleges discounted an average 57.1% of published tuition and fees for first-time, full-time undergraduates in 2025–26, up from 54.5% a year earlier. The figure comes from preliminary estimates in a National Association of College and University Business Officers study of 258 institutions. The discount for all undergraduates hit 51.3%, above the prior peak of 50.8% in 2022–23. The number explains why campuses now admit students who never applied and send professors to recruit freshmen personally, as The Hechinger Report documented in a story also carried by NPR.
The demand side is thinning. An October report from Hanover Research, based on a July survey of 1,000 U.S. high school students aged 16 to 19, found only 66% interested in a bachelor's degree, down from 79% in 2025. Interest in associate degrees rose from 36% to 45%. The Bureau of Labor Statistics counts a parallel slide: 63% of high school graduates went straight to college in 2024, against 70% in 2016.
What does the demographic cliff do to campuses?
Undergraduate enrollment actually rose 0.6% this fall, per preliminary National Student Clearinghouse data. But the Western Interstate Commission for Higher Education projects U.S. high school graduates will fall from a record 3.9 million in 2025 to about 3.4 million a year by 2041. Every incoming class will face sharper competition. For tuition-dependent schools, an empty seat is revenue that never arrives.
Why do admitted students not show up?
Yield is the weak link. Federal figures cited by The Hechinger Report show public colleges converted 22% of admits into enrollments in 2024, down from 32% in 2014. Private nonprofits fell from 24% to 18%. Even a deposit guarantees nothing. The industry calls it summer melt: students commit, then skip the fall. Whittier College near Los Angeles lost roughly one in six committed students this year, a 17% melt rate, The Wall Street Journal reported. Hedging compounds the problem: 10% of admitted students placed deposits at more than one college in 2026, double the 2024 share, in a Human Capital Education survey of more than 72,000 admitted students at 91 institutions.
Money drives the hesitation. In that survey, 60% ranked affordability, financial aid or net price among their five most important factors, and nearly three in 10 waited for aid offers before choosing. Liz Colavita, director of survey research at Human Capital Education, said 21% of admitted students reported their families were insufficiently prepared to pay. Six percent of 2026 admits said they would attend no college that fall, up from 3% in 2025; 51% of them cited affordability. Anselment's colleague Colavita put the shift plainly: "Students aren't necessarily questioning whether education has value. They're asking what kind of education will be valuable to them."
How are colleges fighting back?
Common App's direct admissions program sent proactive offers to more than 820,000 students in the 2025–26 season. Participating institutions nearly doubled, from 119 in 2024–25 to 234 in 2026–27. Georgia State University spent $125,000 on a Facebook, Instagram and YouTube campaign aimed at admits and parents, first selling academic strengths and career outcomes, then pushing enrollment deadlines. The university credits the campaign, which won a CASE Circle of Excellence award, with cutting summer melt from 22% to 8% and generating $3.2 million in tuition revenue.
"Colleges can treat the enrollment deposit not as the finish line, but as a milestone marking the beginning of another critical stage in the student's journey," said Ken Anselment, senior director of enrollment strategy at Human Capital Education. He wants admissions, financial aid, housing and advising to watch whether students complete required steps and intervene early.
Price cuts are the blunter tool. Whitman College in Washington state will cap tuition at 10% of parental income for students entering in fall 2027. DePaul University raised institutional aid by nearly $15.5 million to roughly $372 million for fiscal 2027, citing rising student need. The Chicago school said declining enrollment among continuing undergraduates was its biggest challenge, and it cannot afford salary increases this year. Anselment warns the spending has limits: "The point of diminishing returns comes when an institution spends more to enroll students without generating sufficient additional revenue." Whether discounts or ad campaigns work, the schools that master the stretch between deposit and move-in day will hold the revenue edge as the applicant pool shrinks.
Source: fortune.com
More from Daniel Okafor
Show full bio
Correspondent covering money, funding and market shifts around entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.
2,189 articles