Economy & Policy

Half of America's TV Time Now Sits Beyond FEMA's Emergency Alerts

Tuesday's FEMA alert test will hit broadcast, cable and radio—but Nielsen data shows half of U.S. TV time now flows through streaming platforms the EAS cannot reach.

By Olivia Hart

4 min read

FEMA has a cord-cutting problem
FEMA has a cord-cutting problemu_tu0otx0ph2 / pixabay

What's News

  • Nielsen data shows U.S. consumers spend half their TV viewing time on digital video platforms like YouTube and Amazon Prime.
  • Virtual pay TV operators—YouTube TV, Fubo, Hulu + Live TV—do not participate in the Emergency Alert System.
  • Federal alerting began in the 1950s for Soviet nuclear attack warnings; mobile phones were added in 2012.
  • A 2021 Motion Picture Association filing called expanding alerts to streaming 'enormously technically difficult, if not entirely impracticable.'
  • No regulation currently requires ATSC 3.0 TVs to interrupt streaming with emergency alerts.

By Olivia Hart

Half of all U.S. TV viewing time now goes to digital video platforms such as YouTube and Amazon Prime, according to recent Nielsen data—and that is exactly the audience FEMA's Emergency Alert System will miss when it runs its national test on Tuesday.

The one-minute test will interrupt live broadcasts, cable reruns, and radio programming across the country. Subscribers to Netflix, Disney+, or any other streaming service, however, will likely notice nothing at all. The math is blunt: roughly one in every two minutes of American television consumption now happens on channels the alert system cannot reach.

What does the cord-cutting gap actually cover?

The gap is wider than Netflix and Disney+. Consumers who swapped cable for internet-based "virtual" pay TV services—YouTube TV, Fubo, Hulu + Live TV—also fall outside the EAS, because those operators do not participate in the system and do not interrupt programming to carry warnings.

The result is arbitrary. A YouTube TV subscriber watching ABC's Dancing With the Stars may still see an alert, because that feed is ingested from a local broadcast affiliate that works with FEMA. A neighbor watching Bravo's Southern Charm on the same service gets nothing. The difference is not geography or risk. It is the channel lineup.

Why hasn't the system caught up?

Federal alerting dates to the 1950s, when it was built to warn of a possible Soviet nuclear attack. It has been modernized since—including an expansion to mobile phones in 2012. But regulators and emergency management officials have struggled to keep pace with shifting media habits and the restructuring of the TV business.

The industry is not quietly waiting to be drafted. In a 2021 regulatory filing, the Motion Picture Association—whose members include Netflix, Disney, and Skydance—argued that expanding emergency alerts to streaming would be "enormously technically difficult, if not entirely impracticable." The association's stated obstacle is structural: Tuesday's test is national, but real warnings about wildfires or flooding are local. Relaying them would require a service like Netflix to build monitoring infrastructure in every state, it argued.

That claim deserves scrutiny. Virtual pay TV operators already track each subscriber's location to deliver local broadcast channels, and John Bergmayer, legal director of the nonprofit advocacy group Public Knowledge, says they have the technical means to act on it. "Regardless of the other aspects of regulation, when it comes to public safety issues, [traditional and internet-based pay TV services] should be on equal footing," Bergmayer said. "And like cable, they have the technical capacity to both interrupt a program or to add some sort of crawl along the bottom of the screen."

Notably absent from the industry's filing is any cost estimate for the state-by-state monitoring it calls impracticable, or any comparison to the location infrastructure these services already operate for advertising and content rights.

Could new technology fix it?

Some pin hopes on the Advanced Television Systems Committee (ATSC) 3.0 broadcast standard, which brings modern capabilities to antenna TV. In theory, a TV with an ATSC 3.0 tuner could interrupt a Netflix stream the moment it receives an alert over the air. In practice, no regulation requires this. Critics also warn the standard's content protection technologies could actively hamper emergency warnings.

Hamilton Bean, a University of Colorado Denver communications professor who studies public alert and warning systems, frames the requirement plainly. "It is vital that emergency alert systems adapt to changes in consumer technologies," Bean said. "Whether through streaming services, mobile devices, or IoT [Internet of Things], emergency alerts work best when they reach people where they are—at home, at work, or in public settings."

What is the realistic path forward?

Art Botterell, author of To Warn Is Human: A Cultural History of Public Warning, rejects any single-technology answer. "There is no silver bullet," Botterell said. His preference is investment in civic infrastructure and neighborhood ties so people can alert and help one another directly. "We need to facilitate that person-to-person sharing," he said.

That approach also covers the viewer who tuned into the wrong show at the wrong moment. Until regulation or the industry moves, Tuesday's test will measure a system built for the cable era against an audience that has already left it.

Original: nielsen.com

Share this article:

More from Olivia Hart

Olivia Hart

Show full bio

Staff writer covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.

2,221 articles

Related articles

« Previous articleNext article »