Milburn's Youth Jobs Plan Nets Treasury Just £200m a Year
Milburn's youth employment plan saves just £200m a year as £5.8bn in new spending swallows benefit cuts and tax gains, setting up a fresh Westminster welfare fight.
By Nathan Brooks
4 min read
What's News
- Milburn's plan saves the government only £200m a year in net terms.
- The new youth system costs £5.8bn, against £3.6bn in benefit cuts by 2036-37 and £2.4bn in extra tax receipts.
- Neet numbers reached 1m earlier this year — 13% of young people, second only to Romania in Europe.
- 18- to 24-year-olds would lose personal independence payments under a new youth allowance.
- Labour MPs forced Starmer to drop £5bn in benefit cuts in last year's welfare rebellion.
Alan Milburn's flagship plan to get young Britons back into work will save the government only £200m a year, because the cost of job support swallows almost all of the anticipated cuts to benefits. The former health secretary unveiled his long-awaited report on youth unemployment on Tuesday morning, urging ministers to cut disability and sickness payments for under-25s and redirect the money into back-to-work schemes. Figures inside the report show the plan won't deliver significant overall savings.
The numbers are political dynamite. The Conservatives are likely to seize on them as evidence that Labour isn't serious about reducing the welfare bill — a cause the opposition has put at the heart of its economic policy. But the modest bottom line also strengthens the argument from Milburn and the prime minister, Andy Burnham, that the year-long review was never motivated by cuts.
"The system I propose will spend less on compensating for economic inactivity, more on creating routes out of it; less on the consequences of failure and more on avoiding it," Milburn said in the report.
How the money moves
The arithmetic matters for anyone tracking the public finances. The government would spend nearly £2bn a year on a new youth opportunity service, providing support and advice to guarantee every young person a route into education, training or work. Another £2bn-plus would fund vocational training courses and apprenticeships, and a further £1bn would go to direct payments and tax breaks for companies that hire young people.
The funding comes largely from taking disability and sickness benefits away from young people and replacing them with a single youth allowance — considerably below what some can currently claim. People aged 18-24 would lose access to personal independence payments, replaced by a new allowance available only to those whose conditions are "well established, significant and ongoing."
The benefit cuts would save £3.6bn by 2036-37, with an additional £2.4bn generated by higher tax receipts. That £6bn gross haul would be almost entirely consumed by the £5.8bn cost of the new system — hence the £200m net annual saving.
Why the review happened now
Milburn began the review last year amid concern at the top of government over rising numbers of young people not in education, employment or training. The Neet count hit 1m earlier this year — 13% of young people, a higher rate than in any European country except Romania.
"Our country is at a fork in the road," Milburn argues in the report. "Go on as we are and see the Neet crisis grow. Or change course and make the difficult changes that can shift the trajectory."
He calls his proposals a wholesale rethinking of how the benefits and education system works for young people, and warns ministers against cherrypicking only the measures they like.
What does this change for the parliamentary arithmetic?
The real test is whether the government can sell a plan that cuts benefits for young disabled people while saving almost nothing overall. Milburn addressed Labour MPs on Monday night, alongside the work and pensions secretary, Pat McFadden, and told them plainly: "The Tories will say it's too expensive, you can cut faster. But you can't – or you'd drive young people into destitution with poor housing and ill health."
Ministers are hoping to avoid a repeat of last year's bruising welfare rebellion, when Labour MPs forced Keir Starmer to drop his plan to cut benefits by about £5bn a year. That humiliation arguably spelled the beginning of the end of Starmer's time in office. Several architects of that rebellion now hold government jobs, including the de facto deputy prime minister, Louise Haigh, and the chief whip, Anneliese Midgley — meaning the people who sank the last welfare bill now sit inside the room deciding this one's fate.
Milburn has public backing from the governments of both Burnham and his predecessor, Starmer. McFadden and Burnham will speak to the parliamentary party about the plans again on Tuesday morning. Whether a £200m-a-year saving survives contact with a Commons that has already rejected £5bn in cuts is the question that will define this proposal's prospects.
Original: guardian.co.uk
More from Nathan Brooks
Show full bio
News editor covering regulation, policy and their impact on entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.
2,249 articles