Economy & Policy

Harvard's Black Freshman Share Fell From 18% to 9.3% Since 2023

The 2023 Supreme Court ruling didn't touch hiring law, but employers retreated anyway. Harvard's Black freshman share has nearly halved to 9.3%, and elite-campus hires are climbing.

By Grace Kim

5 min read

How the Supreme Court’s college admissions decision has changed the job pipeline for Black and Latino students
How the Supreme Court’s college admissions decision has changed the job pipeline for Black and Latino studentsAaron Douglas / unsplash

What's News

  • Harvard's Black first-year share fell from 18% in 2023 to 9.3% in 2026
  • Employers citing diversity as a recruiting priority fell from nearly 60% in 2022 to 31% in 2025 (Veris Insights)
  • White students' share of corporate internships rose from 50-53% to 59% in the fall 2024-summer 2025 cohort (NACE)
  • Half of surveyed HR professionals familiar with the ruling mistakenly believed it applied to workplaces (Columbia Business School)
  • Burning Glass tracked 300,000 graduates; elite-college share of top-company hires rose nearly a third from 2023-2025

Black students made up 18% of Harvard's incoming class in 2023. In 2026, they're 9.3% — a drop of nearly half since the Supreme Court struck down race-conscious admissions. That's the starkest single number in a broader shift now rippling from campuses into corporate hiring pipelines.

The court's June 2023 ruling barred colleges from giving Black and Latino applicants an edge over white and Asian applicants in the name of diversity. It did not change hiring law, and it said nothing about employer inclusion programs. Gallup found more than two-thirds of American adults called the decision "mostly a good thing."

Employers pulled back anyway. Reporting by The Hechinger Report and Soledad O'Brien Productions found many companies have dismantled campus efforts to recruit diverse workers since the ruling. A Columbia Business School survey of HR professionals found company leaders removed or revised diversity language, changed recruitment strategies and rethought how they built candidate pools. Half of surveyed respondents familiar with the ruling mistakenly believed it applied to workplaces; others feared lawsuits, public criticism or political attention.

The full jobs impact won't be measurable until 2028, when the first class admitted after the decision graduates.

What changed in the political climate?

In January 2025, as one of his first acts of his second term, President Donald Trump issued an executive order attacking DEI hiring programs across federal agencies and contractors. The order called such efforts "discriminatory and illegal" and pressured private employers — publicly traded corporations, large nonprofits, and universities with big endowments — to follow suit.

The Heritage Foundation urged businesses to strip out corporate DEI positions and warned governments not to contract with companies holding such statements. Conservative legal activists have used the admissions ruling as a road map for targeting workplace diversity programs.

More than three dozen major companies — among them Meta, Google, Walmart, Target and Goldman Sachs — declined to discuss their recruiting practices for this story. Dozens of colleges wouldn't make career staff available; several counselors talked only anonymously, citing fear of drawing the Trump administration's attention.

How much has recruiting narrowed?

A lot, and fast. Matt Sigelman, president of labor research firm The Burning Glass Institute, said that although the ruling covered admissions, employers "could see the writing on the wall and changed the way they were hiring." Companies folded in Department of Labor guidance plus the political shift and, in his words, "in many cases pulled back from their diversity goals."

Burning Glass tracked 300,000 college graduates who entered the workforce between 2023 and 2025. The share of hires at the most competitive companies coming from elite colleges rose by nearly a third over that period. The path to prestigious entry-level jobs now favors a smaller set of largely private elite colleges — places where entering classes are becoming less diverse.

Veris Insights, a recruiting research firm, found the same pattern: nearly 60% of 150 major employers named diversity as a priority for campus-recruiter placement in 2022; by 2025 that figure was 31%. Over the same period, the share of companies recruiting exclusively from a short list of schools rose from 17% to 26%.

Internships are narrowing too. The National Association of Colleges and Employers found white students made up 50% to 53% of corporate interns from 2021 to 2024. In the cohort running from fall 2024 through summer 2025 — spanning Trump's return to office — that share rose to 59%. NACE president and CEO Shawn VanDerziel cautioned that a weak job market, artificial intelligence and inflation make the trend hard to interpret.

What are campuses seeing?

At Occidental College, Jamila Chambers, executive director of the Hameetman Career Center, remembers recruiters who told students directly: "We're looking for BIPOC students. We're looking for first-gen students. We're looking for LGBTQIA+ students." Those pipelines, she said, have "dried up."

At UC Berkeley, Santina Pitcher, senior associate director of employer relations, said federal agencies "from the Peace Corps to the State Department" told her they can no longer explicitly recruit for diversity. At Pomona College, Hazel Raja said recruiters "weren't approaching us in the same way" after the ruling.

San Jose State University, where more than 40% of students are first in their families to attend college, renamed programs after the federal guidance changed. References to DEI disappeared; the former diversity job fair is now the October Fest job and internship fair.

Enrollment data shows the upstream effect: Black enrollment declined or stayed flat at nearly all of the 85 highly selective colleges that accept 25% or less of applicants, and Hispanic enrollment fell or held flat at more than half of them.

What do students and critics say?

Winnie Tuban, a Filipino first-generation San Jose State graduate, found her San Francisco startup job on her own, not through recruiters. "When you're living as a person of color and you hear that they're 'going to war on DEI,' it makes it feel like you're not welcome in that space," she said. Daniella Mensah, a psychology major whose family immigrated from Ghana, said diversity now "feels like an afterthought" to companies.

Critics of identity-based preferences read the shift differently. Frederick Hess of the American Enterprise Institute said diversity efforts "far too often seems to have been reduced to counting the number of people from a particular race or ethnic group." He argues real diversity spans region, class, religion and political outlook.

Natasha Warikoo, a Tufts University sociology professor who has studied affirmative action, called the retreat "clearly a backlash" to the post-2020 moment, when racial justice "felt like a moral imperative." The Urban Institute's Bryan J. Cook said early workforce trends concern him, though Democratic control of Congress could test whether lawmakers push back on anti-DEI efforts, including DOJ investigations into schools' admissions practices.

The bottom line belongs to Sigelman: "What started as a decision about who gets admitted to college ultimately plays out in who gets a shot at the best employment."

Original: npr.org

Share this article:

More from Grace Kim

Grace Kim

Show full bio

Market editor covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.

2,311 articles

Related articles

« Previous article