High Achievers’ All-or-Nothing Thinking Derails Year-End Goals
A 10-pound goal shows how rigid success-or-failure thinking can derail high achievers. A psychologist recommends tracking habits, smaller gains and course corrections rather than quitting.
By Grace Kim
4 min read

What's News
- Niebes-Davis’s 10-pound example asks what happens at one-, two- and three-pound gains.
- Niebes-Davis says nobody reaches 100% of a goal 100% of the time.
- Dhawan’s year-end plan includes eliminating alcohol and sugar, writing for 30 minutes and meditating every morning.
- January 1 serves as the year-end deadline in the discussion of goals that may not reach 100% completion.
A 10-pound weight-loss goal can turn a one-, two- or three-pound gain into a non-event, says licensed psychologist Allison Niebes-Davis. Her test of rigid goal-setting is blunt: “If you’re only going to give yourself credit or positive reinforcement when you lose ten pounds,” she says, “what happens at one pound? Two pounds? Three pounds?”
For Niebes-Davis, the distinction is practical: treat setbacks as information, not failure. Her guidance for high achievers is to measure smaller steps, identify what moves the needle, and course-correct before abandoning a goal. Niebes-Davis runs a practice in Downers Grove, Illinois.
What turns progress into failure?
Niebes-Davis defines the problem as an “all-or-nothing” mindset, which sorts situations into absolutes without nuance or middle ground. In a review of a week, month or year, an ambitious person may focus on a falter and describe it as terrible or say they blew it, she says.
Ahead of January 1, Niebes-Davis’s analysis warns that doubts about reaching a goal 100% by year-end can turn one difficult period into a reason to quit.
Niebes-Davis says the brain constantly assigns meaning, doing so quickly and efficiently as a survival tool. But she says speed does not guarantee accuracy: the brain does not always draw the most accurate or nuanced conclusions. A fast verdict can become a mistaken one.
She says many high achievers see themselves in dichotomous terms. Self-criticism pushes them toward the language of failure, success, win and lose, and some believe the rigid frame will motivate them. She says a setback can then overshadow the progress around it. The practical cost is lost momentum.
Why can binary thinking persist?
Niebes-Davis says all-or-nothing thinking may have worked for some people in the past or in other areas of life, but it is unlikely to be healthy and sustainable over time. She connects thoughts and emotions directly and says the path to a goal rarely runs in a straight line.
Nobody reaches 100% all the time, Niebes-Davis says. If success and failure are the only available labels, ordinary struggles and setbacks become failures, she says. That response does not motivate people to keep working or trying.
Erica Dhawan, an author, keynote speaker and adviser to CEOs and leaders, has ticked off many goals she set for herself this year, including family and keynote speeches. Her weight goal exposed the cost of binary thinking. “I do get into a wave of good health, but then when I lose it, I don’t fall back on progress,” she said.
Dhawan describes herself as ambitious and highly achieving. She wonders whether the pattern is perfectionism: achieving the perfect goal in some areas while failing to do so in others. A setback should trigger adjustment, not abandonment.
How does culture reinforce the pattern?
Dhawan says social media presents idealized images that can condition people to see anything less as inadequate. She also points to a wider weakness around nuance: situations become either/or choices and extremes, while children do not learn a flexible vocabulary early enough.
Niebes-Davis recommends replacing rigid verdicts with specific observations. A person can note three difficult areas, acknowledge that the month was hard and identify choices that did not align with the goal. In her approach, that wording shifts attention from an arbitrary outcome to progress. Specific language leaves room for adjustment.
What should high achievers track?
Niebes-Davis recommends focusing on process rather than outcomes. Her alternative asks which processes contribute to movement around a goal, a harder question that people often overlook because they tend to see and celebrate outcome-based approaches, she says. Tracking behavior gives people a way to connect daily actions with the target.
The payoff is smaller, measurable feedback. Celebrating one-, two- or three-pound progress supports what Niebes-Davis calls a data-driven mindset: track smaller changes, pay attention to what moves the needle and use a setback as evidence for adjustment.
If someone gains a pound, the response can focus on choices that were out of line with the goal, followed by a course correction. The target does not have to be treated as lost.
Dhawan has not abandoned her weight goal. She says she is practicing healthy habits through year-end, including:
- Eliminating alcohol and sugar.
- Writing for 30 minutes.
- Meditating every morning.
Niebes-Davis frames the shift as deliberate training. People tend to give more attention to goals they struggled with or failed to align with, she says. Her countermeasure is to recognize successes deliberately, including smaller ones. She says that work and intention can put people in a healthier place for goals, relationships and health.
As January 1 approaches, small wins give ambitious people a concrete reason to keep going.
Original: drallisonandassociates.com
More from Grace Kim
Show full bio
Market editor covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.
2,301 articles