Strategy

Job-seeker ghosting hits a three-year high, costing employers trust

Ghosting hit a three-year high: 53% of job seekers were left without a reply. Among affected workers, 48% would not reapply, while 2.6% stopped buying from the employer.

By Amara Osei

5 min read

Ghosted job seekers don’t forget: 48% say they wouldn’t apply to that company again
Ghosted job seekers don’t forget: 48% say they wouldn’t apply to that company againathree23 / pixabay

What's News

  • Criteria: 53% of job seekers were ghosted in the past year, a three-year high.
  • April LiveCareer: 48% of 1,008 U.S. workers would not reapply after being ghosted.
  • February study: A strong employer’s attractiveness score fell from 3.29 to 2.61 after a generic rejection.
  • July Selection Lab: 2.6% stopped buying from an employer after being ghosted.
  • September Greenhouse: AI reduced rejection drafting from 20-30 minutes to under three.

By Amara Osei

Fifty-three percent of job seekers were ghosted by an employer in the past year, a three-year high, according to a Criteria report. An April LiveCareer survey of 1,008 U.S. workers found 48% would not apply to the same company again after being ghosted; 42% would trust it less, and 37% would share the experience.

The candidate experience can consume hours of research, interview preparation, skills tests, references and hiring-manager meetings before a two-sentence rejection—or no response. Employers invest significant time and money building employer brands, yet many skip those final minutes of communication. The neglect carries a commercial cost beyond hiring.

“When employers spend money on branding, but don’t focus on the candidate experience, they’re missing out on the big picture,” Monster career expert Vicki Salemi, a former corporate recruiter, told Fortune.

What does a generic rejection do to employer appeal?

A February study in the International Journal of Selection and Assessment surveyed 236 working adults and final-year students in the Netherlands and Belgium. Researchers measured employer attractiveness before and after participants read hypothetical rejection letters.

For participants evaluating a company with a strong employer brand, attractiveness fell from 3.29 to 2.61 after a standard rejection letter. The score recovered to 2.89 a few days later but remained significantly below its starting level; an appreciative letter caused no statistically significant decline.

“The higher the employer brand equity, the more to lose with sending a generic rejection email,” Sanne Fijneman-Ghielen, the Tilburg University researcher and study lead author, told Fortune.

Where does candidate treatment hit customer spending?

A July survey by recruitment assessment company Selection Lab found 34.1% of ghosted applicants told friends or family about the experience. Another 22.3% would never apply again, 4.2% shared it online, and 2.6% stopped buying the company’s products or services.

An August PeopleScout survey of more than 1,000 job seekers across 10 markets found 36% of candidates with a negative hiring experience would stop purchasing from the company. Another 37% would discourage others from applying.

Salemi said respectful treatment can lead candidates to apply for future openings, recommend the company and remain loyal customers. Candidates who feel dismissed may do the opposite.

Can recruiters close the loop faster?

A thoughtful rejection email takes minutes and can protect a company’s reputation, yet many employers still omit one. Greenhouse’s chief people officer warned in 2023 that the practice could come back to hurt them.

Recruiters often manage multiple openings, review hundreds or thousands of résumés, coordinate interviews and track metrics such as time-to-fill. Communications with rejected candidates can fall through the cracks, Salemi said, but she does not regard heavy workloads as an excuse.

In a September Greenhouse blog post, Melissa Shannon, a recruiter at the hiring software company, described using AI to draft personalized rejections for candidates who completed onsite interviews. The tool reads scorecards and notes, identifies strengths and development areas, and leaves every draft for recruiter review before sending.

Shannon said the process cut drafting time from 20 to 30 minutes per candidate to less than three. “Ultimately, rejecting finalist candidates comes down to priorities and accountability,” Salemi said. “This stems from the top—from leadership and the company culture.”

What should a rejection email contain?

Salemi cited a rejection sent after multiple interview rounds: “Dear Applicant, Thank you for your interest. We have decided to not continue with your candidacy. Good luck in your job search.” The message omitted the candidate’s name, the position and any recognition of the hours spent interviewing.

At least it supplied an answer. “Yes, even a brief rejection letter is important to job seekers,” LiveCareer career expert Jasmine Escalera told Fortune. She added: “When a hiring manager lets the candidate know they have moved in another direction, it provides not only closure but also helps the job seeker know it’s time to turn their efforts to other opportunities.”

“Candidates who completed several rounds of interviews deserve more than the same automated message sent to candidates who submitted a resume and didn’t interview,” Salemi said.

Fijneman-Ghielen shared the study’s appreciative letter, which acknowledged the applicant’s interest and effort, said other candidates had more relevant industry experience, encouraged future applications and offered a discount code. It included:

“We understand that this may not be the news you were hoping for. However, we would like to emphasize that we were impressed by your skills and background and would like to ask you to keep an eye on our career page for future opportunities within organization X.”

Because the hiring scenario was fictional, the researchers had no information about the applicants’ actual qualifications. Fijneman-Ghielen said the letter showed how employers could express appreciation without providing individualized feedback.

She also cited Rituals, the Dutch beauty and lifestyle retailer. In a 2020 interview, Joan Carles Cifre, the company’s HR director for Spain and Portugal, said Rituals gave interviewees two miniature bath foams, one to keep and one to give away, carrying its giving philosophy into recruitment.

Should finalists get a phone call?

For finalists, Salemi recommends a phone call. During her corporate recruiting work, she called interviewed candidates to say they had not been selected, using standardized phone scripts or email templates that recruiters personalized.

“Sometimes candidates actually thanked me for rejecting them even when they wanted that coveted job offer,” Salemi said. They left knowing the company had taken time to acknowledge them as individuals.

Salemi said candidate treatment offers a view of workplace culture. A company unable to appreciate an interviewee’s time may leave candidates wondering how it would treat them as employees.

“Ultimately, rejecting candidates in a timely manner, especially when they reach the final rounds of interviews, isn’t just about protecting the employer’s reputation and/or brand,” Salemi said. “It’s about doing the right thing: Treating people with dignity and respect.”

For employers considering AI-assisted rejections, Shannon’s process sets a measurable standard: under three minutes of drafting, followed by recruiter verification. LiveCareer, Selection Lab and PeopleScout findings link candidate treatment to future applications, trust and customer spending.

Source: fortune.com

Share this article:

More from Amara Osei

Amara Osei

Show full bio

Senior reporter covering companies, deals and strategy in entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.

2,336 articles

Related articles

« Previous article