Economy & Policy

Lush Faces Up to $546,000 Per Breach in Australia-First Pay Ad Case

Fair Work Ombudsman's first case under new ad-pay laws alleges Lush advertised $27.91 hourly rates against a $34.76 award minimum, with penalties up to $546,000 per breach.

By Grace Kim

3 min read

Lush faces Australian-first court challenge over allegedly unlawful pay rates in job ads
Lush faces Australian-first court challenge over allegedly unlawful pay rates in job adsPexels / pixabay

What's News

  • Lush faces penalties up to $546,000 per breach, with two alleged breaches cited.
  • Ads listed $27.91 (Adelaide) and $27.81 (Fountain Gate) hourly versus the $34.76 award minimum for adults.
  • Lush signed an enforceable undertaking in 2020 to repay over $2.44 million to underpaid workers.
  • A directions hearing is scheduled for December 4 in Sydney.

Cosmetics retailer Lush faces penalties of up to $546,000 per breach after the Fair Work Ombudsman filed its first-ever legal action under Australia's laws banning job ads that offer pay below minimum hourly rates.

The case, lodged in the Federal Circuit and Family Court, targets Lush Australasia Retail Pty Limited over two advertisements for seasonal casual sales assistants published on the careers section of the company's own website in July and August.

One ad covered a store in Adelaide; the other targeted the Fountain Gate shopping centre in Melbourne.

What do the ads allegedly say?

The numbers sit at the centre of the case. The Adelaide ad listed hourly pay of $27.91 for an adult worker and $12.61 for a junior aged under 16, according to the ombudsman. The Fountain Gate ad specified $27.81 an hour.

The ombudsman alleges those figures fall well short of the legal floor. Under the General Retail Industry Award 2020, the minimum hourly rate — including casual loading — for the lowest-level casual retail employee is:

  • $34.76 for adults
  • $15.64 for juniors under 16

That puts the alleged shortfall at roughly $6.85 to $6.95 an hour for adults, before a single shift is worked.

Why did the regulator sue?

Federal government amendments to the Fair Work Act now require advertised pay rates to meet the minimums set by an industrial award, an enterprise agreement, or the national minimum wage. This is the ombudsman's first court test of those rules.

Fair Work Ombudsman Anna Booth said a key factor in the decision to prosecute was history: in 2020, Lush entered into an enforceable undertaking to repay underpaid workers more than $2.44 million plus interest.

"Lush committed to implementing measures to ensure future compliance with workplace laws and it is entirely unacceptable for the company to now be allegedly advertising jobs at unlawfully low rates," Booth said in a statement.

She added that stamping out job ads with dodgy pay rates helps prevent vulnerable workers from being underpaid and keeps the playing field fair for businesses doing the right thing.

The ombudsman is seeking penalties for two alleged breaches of the Fair Work Act. AAP has contacted Lush for comment.

What about Lush's ethics pitch?

The court action lands awkwardly against the retailer's own branding. On its website, Lush states that all business should be ethical, all trade should be fair, and that it commits to exceed government minimum standards on staff wages and conditions.

"No company should be trading from an unethical position and society has a right to expect as the norm fairness and resource stewardship from the companies that supply them," the site states.

A $27.91 advertised rate against a $34.76 award minimum is the kind of gap that turns a values statement into evidence.

What happens next?

A directions hearing is set down for December 4 in Sydney. The outcome will set the template for how Australia's new advertising-pay rules bite — and how much a first offence against them costs a repeat player.

Source: smartcompany.com.au

Share this article:

More from Grace Kim

Grace Kim

Show full bio

Market editor covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.

2,178 articles

Related articles

« Previous articleNext article »