Milburn Review: 440,000 Young People Need a 'Complete System Reset'
Alan Milburn's review targets moving 440,000 more young people into work, cutting the 13% Neet rate to 5% and flipping a £25-to-£1 benefits-to-support spending ratio.
By Grace Kim
5 min read

What's News
- Almost 1 million UK 16-to-24-year-olds are Neet — a 13% rate Milburn wants cut to ~5% within a decade.
- In 2024/25, £25 went on youth benefits for every £1 spent on work or education support; target by 2036 is £2 to £1.
- Review proposes replacing Pip and the UC health top-up for under-25s with a Youth Allowance and Additional Cost Allowance.
- Only 68% of children in England are school-ready at five; the review wants 90%.
- Youth Jobs Grant pays employers £3,000; Jobs Guarantee eligibility drops from 18 to 12 months on Universal Credit.
By Grace Kim
Almost one million UK young people aged 16 to 24 are not in education, employment or training — a 13% Neet rate that former health secretary Alan Milburn wants cut to around 5% within a decade. His government-commissioned review, due to be published in full on Tuesday, says sweeping reforms could move 440,000 more young people into work.
The money math is blunt. In 2024/25, for every £1 spent helping young people into work or education, £25 went on youth benefits. By 2036, the review says, that ratio should flip to £2 on benefits for every £1 on work support.
Milburn, a Labour MP from 1992 to 2010 and former health secretary, argues extensive change is needed to avoid a "lost generation" and address what he calls a "moral" crisis. Many young people are desperate for opportunity, he says, but get knocked back repeatedly.
What would the review change?
The review calls for intervention from early childhood through to adulthood, funded in part by radical changes to benefits for young adults. Its headline targets:
- A new target of 90% of children school-ready with basic life skills by age five — the figure is now 68% in England, against a current government target of 75% by 2028
- More emphasis on work skills in the school curriculum
- Instant access to mental health support without diagnosis
- A doubling of the number of young apprentices
- Employer incentives, including a lower National Insurance rate for young workers
At the heart of the plan sits a legal entitlement to support, delivered through a new "Youth Opportunity Service" in England. The service would connect a young person with a named adviser to secure an apprenticeship, college place, supported employment or a job within four months.
Many of the proposed changes apply to England specifically, though some welfare and tax measures cover all home nations.
Who pays for it?
Young adults would lose eligibility for the health top-up of Universal Credit — extra money for people whose health conditions limit their capacity to work — and for Personal Independence Payment (Pip), which covers the extra living costs of a long-term health condition or disability.
The review proposes replacing those benefits for under-25s with a new Youth Allowance, set at the current base rate of Universal Credit for young people, plus a new Additional Cost Allowance to replace Pip. The minority of young people unable to ever work would be supported through a new Severe and Complex Needs Insurance. Some of these welfare measures have already been announced by the government.
On the employer side, the review suggests gradually lowering the National Insurance rate employers pay on young adult staff. The existing Youth Jobs Grant — £3,000 for hiring a young person who has been looking for work for six months — would be retained, as would the Jobs Guarantee, in which the government underwrites a paid six-month job. The government has recently announced that young adults will qualify for the guarantee after 12 months on Universal Credit and looking for work, rather than 18.
What does it mean for young people on benefits?
Kat, 21, from Devon, receives Universal Credit with the health top-up and could face a much lower level of support under the new system. She has fluctuating physical and mental health problems, including occasional seizures caused by functional neurological disorder that recently left her needing crutches.
Kat says she "really wants to work", but has been unable to find a job where she can be employed in a "safe way" because of her health.
Josh, 19, has spent three years looking for work while on Universal Credit with the support of youth employment charity Spear. The charity helps with applications, but Josh says "none of them are getting back, and if they do they say you've not got the spot".
Grace Coates, who manages Spear St Helens, wants to see "more openness to employing people with limited experience".
The Institute for Fiscal Studies said reforms have a better chance of success if support for young people is balanced with incentives for businesses to hire them. It cautioned that while cutting benefit entitlements would immediately reduce the cash young people receive, an increase in employment might take longer to make up the difference for some.
How did politicians respond?
Conservative shadow work and pensions secretary Helen Whately called parts of the proposals "too cautious" and too reliant on the "expensive hand of the state". "Where Milburn gets it right, we'll back him," she said, but the review "fails to bring down the welfare bill, proposes billions more in government spending and won't make the slightest difference for young people stuck on welfare now".
Liberal Democrat deputy leader Daisy Cooper said cutting National Insurance for young workers would "only partly undo the damage of Labour's job tax". Her party's plans would "shut off the Neets pipeline at source, with 100 hours of real work experience before 18 and a careers coach for every young person".
Reform UK's shadow education secretary Suella Braverman said the 10-year wait to see changes from the proposals "would be consigning another generation to the scrap heap". "Reform UK would act now to axe Labour's jobs tax, double the number of apprenticeships and end university scam courses that laden students with debt," she said.
Green deputy leader Mothin Ali called the proposals announced so far "extremely concerning". "There is an alternative to threatening vulnerable people with benefits they need, an alternative to unsuitable short-term work," he said.
Tuesday's full publication will show how far the government intends to go on the welfare trade-offs — and how fast.
Source: BBC Business
More from Grace Kim
Show full bio
Market editor covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.
2,178 articles