M3 Sets 2027 Finance Succession as CFO Dettman Retires
M3 named Brian Donarski senior vice president of finance, effective January 1, 2027, as CFO Beth Dettman retires after 35 years. Holmes Murphy added Joe Rehkamp.
By Daniel Okafor
3 min read

What's News
- Brian Donarski becomes M3's senior vice president of finance effective January 1, 2027.
- CFO Beth Dettman retires December 31, 2026, after a 35-year finance career.
- Donarski joined M3 in 2014 and is a partner and VP of finance and accounting.
- Dettman spent nearly 23 years at Madison Investment Advisors before joining M3 in 2018.
- Holmes Murphy hired Joe Rehkamp as client executive, property casualty.
M3 has named Brian Donarski its next senior finance leader, effective January 1, 2027, setting a two-year runway for the succession of Chief Financial Officer Beth Dettman. Donarski will hold the title of senior vice president of finance. The announcement signals a planned handover rather than a sudden vacancy: Dettman retires December 31, 2026, closing a 35-year career in finance, leadership, and service.
The timing matters for a privately held firm. M3 gave itself more than a full budget cycle between the announcement and the transition. That structure lets Donarski, currently a partner and vice president of finance and accounting, keep running daily finance operations while Dettman finishes long-horizon work on capital and governance.
Who is taking over?
Donarski joined M3 in 2014 and now stands at nearly 12 years with the firm. The company described him as a trusted leader and an important contributor to M3's financial strategy and performance. His promotion, the firm said, supports a thoughtful transition and continued leadership across the finance and accounting functions.
The move keeps the succession internal. M3 did not conduct a public search; it elevated an executive who already runs finance and accounting and holds an equity stake as a partner.
What is Beth Dettman's record at M3?
Dettman joined M3 in 2018 and has shaped the organization's long-term strategic direction, according to the firm. Her portfolio at M3 reads like the job description of a CFO at a privately held brokerage: she advised the executive leadership team and the Board of Directors on:
- capital structure planning
- shareholder perpetuation
- investment strategy
- governance and compliance
- enterprise risk
She also supported M3's growth and acquisition strategies and served as a trusted partner to the firm's banking, legal, accounting, tax, and consulting advisors. For a private company that grows through deals, that advisory web is the mechanism behind the balance sheet.
Where did Dettman build her career?
Before M3, Dettman spent nearly 23 years with Madison Investment Advisors, after beginning her career in public accounting. That path — public accounting first, then more than two decades in investment management, then CFO of a private brokerage — spans the 35 years the firm cites.
Inside M3, she contributed to a series of committees and initiatives, including:
- Board Search
- Retirement Plan
- Information Security
- Retirement Resource
- Culture Committee
She also served six years as president of the M3 Foundation.
What about the second move?
Holmes Murphy, a fellow insurance brokerage, added Joe Rehkamp as client executive, property casualty. The source announcement carried no further detail on Rehkamp's background, prior role, or start date.
What does the succession mean?
The two-year transition gives M3 continuity in the functions Dettman built: capital planning, governance, and acquisition support. Donarski takes a finance operation he has helped run since 2014, and the January 1, 2027 start date means one full calendar year — 2026 — of overlap before Dettman's December 31, 2026 retirement takes effect. For a privately held firm managing shareholder perpetuation, that overlap is the point.
Source: insurancejournal.com
More from Daniel Okafor
Show full bio
Correspondent covering money, funding and market shifts around entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.
2,282 articles