Deals & IPOs

Manhattan Beats Oregon: Trader Joe's Thanksgiving Haul Costs $143.31 vs $164.13

Business Insider shopped the same Trader Joe's Thanksgiving menu in Manhattan and Eugene, Oregon. The NYC haul cost $143.31; Oregon's ran $164.13 — and taxes explain almost none of it.

By Nathan Brooks

3 min read

We did a Trader Joe's Thanksgiving grocery haul in NYC and a smaller Northwest city. The cheaper one might surprise you.
We did a Trader Joe's Thanksgiving grocery haul in NYC and a smaller Northwest city. The cheaper one might surprise you.Matthew Moloney / unsplash

What's News

  • Trader Joe's Thanksgiving haul cost $143.31 in Manhattan vs $164.13 in Eugene, Oregon
  • Turkey priced at $2.49 per pound in both cities; ham at $6.49 per pound in both
  • Oregon has no sales tax; NYC shopper paid just $1.55 in tax on wine and cider only
  • Adjusting for wine, cheese and item swaps, the gap narrows to about $4
  • Walmart sells a $35 Thanksgiving basket for 10; Aldi's version runs under $39

A full Trader Joe's Thanksgiving basket rang up at $143.31 in Manhattan and $164.13 in Eugene, Oregon — and the big city won by roughly $21. Business Insider reporters Gabbi Shaw and Tristin Hoffman ran the experiment in November, shopping the suggested menu from Trader Joe's seasonal newsletter, the Fearless Flyer, at two very different stores.

The comparison lands in a holiday season where affordability dominates. Walmart is selling a $35 Thanksgiving basket that feeds 10 people. Aldi advertised a dinner for 10 at under $39. Trader Joe's skipped the bundled-basket route and instead published a shopping guide — meats, stuffings, cheeses, wines, desserts — with playful price callouts like $2.49 mushroom soup meant to "expand your sense of Trader Joe's value" and $3.79 fried onions pitched as a way to avoid "frying your budget."

What did each reporter buy?

The two hauls mirrored each other almost item for item, which is what makes the price gap interesting.

  • Turkey: Shaw paid $33.42 for a 13.42-pound pre-brined bird at $2.49 per pound on the Upper East Side. Hoffman paid $35.03 for a 14.07-pound all-natural brined turkey in Eugene — same $2.49 per pound.
  • Ham: An 8-pound spiral-sliced uncured ham cost $52.44 in Manhattan at $6.49 per pound. Eugene's fully cooked spiral ham ran $54.00 at the same per-pound price.
  • Sides: Turkey gravy cost $1.69 at both stores — Trader Joe's flaunts it as "better than Grandma's!" Cornbread stuffing mix was $4.99 in both cities.
  • Produce: Organic green beans cost $3.49 per pound in Manhattan versus $2.99 in Eugene. Cranberry sauce was $3.29 for 12 ounces in NYC and $3.99 for 16 ounces in Oregon. Persimmons hit $3.99 per pound at both.
  • Cheese: Shaw spent $10 on a white Stilton with cranberries ($12.99 per pound) and a triple-cream Brie with wild mushrooms ($13.99 per pound). Hoffman spent $6.30 on the same Brie plus $6.70 on Le Délice de Bourgogne triple-crème at $14.99 per pound.
  • Wine: Here the gap widens. Manhattan's Trader Joe's locations carry only a couple of small shelves of wine since the Union Square wine shop closed in 2022, so Shaw bought a $6.99 moscato and a $6.99 cabernet sauvignon. Eugene stocks Willamette Valley locals, and Hoffman chose King Estate's pinot noir at $24.99.
  • Dessert: Pumpkin pie cost $6.99 at both stores. Whipped cream split them: Manhattan was out of the classic $2.99 topping, while Hoffman paid $4.49 for Dairystar's whipped light cream.

What does this change for shoppers?

Taxes barely moved the needle. Oregon has no sales tax, while most groceries in New York City are tax-exempt — Shaw paid just $1.55 in sales tax, and only on the wine and cider. The $21 gap came almost entirely from choices, not geography.

Strip out the wine and cheese and adjust for the different salad kits (Hoffman's apple cabbage slaw at $4.49 versus Shaw's sweet onion kit at $3.99) and meat weights, and Hoffman's haul was only about $4 more. Had Manhattan's whipped cream been in stock, the receipts would have been virtually tied, with NYC still about $1.40 cheaper.

The practical takeaway: Trader Joe's per-pound pricing is essentially uniform across radically different markets — a refurbished NYC Department of Transportation warehouse in Manhattan versus the only store in a 178,000-person college town. What moves your total is the wine aisle and the cheese counter, not your zip code. Shaw's haul also fell short of a full spread — she noted there weren't enough sides or desserts for a complete meal, especially with two meats in the cart.

Source: feeds.businessinsider.com

Share this article:

More from Nathan Brooks

Nathan Brooks

Show full bio

News editor covering regulation, policy and their impact on entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.

2,611 articles

Related articles

« Previous article