Economy & Policy

Milburn Review Calls for NI Cuts for Under-25s to Tackle Youth Joblessness

Alan Milburn's review will urge a five-year NI cut for under-25 hires, a Pip ban for the young group, and a legal jobs guarantee as Neet numbers near one million.

By Amara Osei

4 min read

Cut national insurance for under-25s to create jobs, Milburn report to say
Cut national insurance for under-25s to create jobs, Milburn report to sayerwinbosman / pixabay

What's News

  • An immediate NI cut for 21 to 24-year-olds would cost £5.1bn, per Resolution Foundation research cited in the Milburn report.
  • Nearly one million UK 16 to 24-year-olds are not in employment, education or training, according to ONS data.
  • The government spends £22bn a year supporting economically inactive young people, Milburn said.
  • The NI payment threshold for 21 to 24-year-olds should double from £5,000 to £10,000, the report will say.
  • The extended jobs guarantee scheme aims to help more than 90,000 young people into work by March 2029.

Cutting employer national insurance for workers aged under 25 would cost £5.1bn if done immediately — and Alan Milburn's year-long review of youth unemployment will say the money is better spent cutting it gradually instead. The independent report, published on Tuesday, will recommend halving the tax burden on young hires over five years, starting with shops, bars and restaurants.

Milburn, a former Labour health secretary, wants the government to double the threshold at which businesses start paying NI for 21 to 24-year-olds, from £5,000 to £10,000. But he'll say this should only happen "when fiscal conditions allow". Given the UK's fiscal position, an immediate across-the-board cut in employer NI is, in his view, not the best use of several billions of pounds of public money.

The stakes are large. The government spends £22bn a year supporting young people who are economically inactive, according to Milburn. Office for National Statistics data shows nearly one million 16 to 24-year-olds are not in employment, education or training — the cohort known as Neets.

What does the report recommend?

The review makes several concrete proposals:

  • Reduce NI costs over five years for 21 to 24-year-olds, beginning in retail and hospitality, which together provide 37% of jobs for 16 to 24-year-olds.
  • Bar under-25s from claiming the health element of Universal Credit and from personal independence payment (Pip), the main disability benefit in England and Wales.
  • Provide a legal guarantee of a job, training or employment support, with those who refuse help potentially losing benefits.
  • Cut the UK's benefits bill, alongside wider recommendations on youth employment.

Milburn will also argue that helping young people develop skills is pointless if no jobs exist for them. Under Sir Keir Starmer, the government raised NI for firms — but Milburn will say the Neet problem was not caused by that rise.

How are employers responding?

Collette Osborne, who owns three salons in Nottingham, said she feels "suffocated by employment costs" including NI and the minimum wage. She used to employ eight apprentices a year; now she takes on none. Her workforce has more than halved, to 21 staff.

She told the BBC it costs "around £60,000 to train an apprentice before we can actually start allowing them onto customers' heads". Parents have become so desperate for their children to work in her salons that some have offered to pay their wages.

"I'm inundated with applications — and I mean inundated — which is heartbreaking because I can't take them on," Osborne said. "They promise breathing space. I feel suffocated, suffocated by employment costs."

What about the minimum wage?

Milburn told the BBC's Sunday with Laura Kuenssberg programme he agreed with Chancellor John Healey's move to slow the equalisation of the national minimum wage across age groups. Labour's manifesto pledged to remove "discriminatory age bands" and close the gap between adult rates and pay for 18 to 20-year-olds.

In his Budget, Healey said pay for 18 to 20-year-olds would rise from £10.85 to £11.27 an hour in April next year, while workers aged 21 and over will see wages increase from £12.71 to £13.21.

"I understand why because nobody wants to see young workers on poverty pay," Milburn said, though he added it "imposed a lot of costs on [the] government". He said: "I think we have got to look very carefully at the convergence issue."

Milburn also backs state-subsidised wages for businesses hiring young workers. "Because young people today are walking into the workplace often with a mental health problem, ADHD or anxiety, if you're a small business that's a cost that you've got to absorb," he said. "The state has a responsibility to help them with that."

What is the government doing now?

On Sunday, Work and Pensions Secretary Pat McFadden said the government will extend its subsidised jobs guarantee scheme for 18 to 24-year-olds claiming Universal Credit. Eligibility now kicks in after 12 months on benefits, down from 18, and the scheme covers England, Scotland and Wales.

McFadden said the scheme, which guarantees a six-month job, "will help more than 90,000 young people into work by March 2029".

Shadow work and pensions secretary Helen Whately dismissed the approach: "It is just absurd that they are taxing businesses here and they're going to subsidise things that look like jobs over here. Just stop doing the taxing." She said the Conservatives want to halve employer NI costs, citing businesses that "really want to employ young people but they just can't afford to anymore".

With one million young people outside work and study, and £22bn a year going to support them, the Milburn report hands Starmer's government a trade-off it can't dodge: tax relief for employers now, paid for by tighter benefit rules for the young.

Source: BBC Business

Share this article:

More from Amara Osei

Amara Osei

Show full bio

Senior reporter covering companies, deals and strategy in entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.

2,136 articles

Related articles

« Previous articleNext article »