Startups

NFL Fines Made Caddix a $6 Million Marketing Story

The NFL fined Caleb Williams $35,823 for flashing Caddix's logo. The four-person startup turned the penalty into an estimated $6 million in earned media as orders outpace inventory.

By Amara Osei

4 min read

Why the NFL is making players disguise their Caddix cleats
Why the NFL is making players disguise their Caddix cleatsjarmoluk / pixabay

What's News

  • The NFL fined Caleb Williams $35,823 in October for showing the Caddix logo in back-to-back games.
  • More than 80 NFL players have worn Caddix cleats this season despite the brand lacking a league license.
  • Meltwater estimates the post-fine media coverage was worth about $6 million; Caddix expects just over $3 million revenue in 2026.
  • Caddix has four employees and sells its cleats for around $230 a pair; revenue was under $1 million last year.
  • An NWSL logo fee of $100,000 led Caddix to skip league licensing; fines on Kayla Sharples were later rescinded.

The NFL fined Chicago Bears quarterback Caleb Williams $35,823 in October for showing the Caddix logo in back-to-back games — and that penalty turned a four-employee cleat startup into a national story worth an estimated $6 million in earned media.

Caddix, which sells its flexing-stud cleats for around $230 a pair, isn't one of the league's three licensed footwear brands — Nike, Adidas, and Under Armour. The NFL has approved the cleats for games, but players must tape over the logo or wear unbranded pairs. More than 80 players have worn Caddix cleats this season by the company's count, including Joe Burrow, Williams, and Cooper Kupp in Week 9 alone.

The paradox is stark: Caddix has solved the hardest problem in sportswear — elite athlete adoption — and now faces the unusual second problem of getting anyone to notice. "We look up on Sunday," founder and CEO Jack Rasmussen says, "and we see guys wearing the cleats that we have no idea how they got a hold of them."

Why do players tape over the logo?

The difference in a Caddix cleat sits underneath. Standard studs dig into turf and hold — until a planted foot meets a turning knee, and ligaments tear. Caddix builds its studs to flex and swivel slightly in any direction. The company says they grip like normal studs until twisting force gets too high, then release the foot.

A 2013 study of 555 high school football players, led by University of Calgary researcher John Wannop, found that players whose cleats had the most rotational grip suffered noncontact leg injuries at more than four times the rate of those with the least grip. Whether Caddix's cleats actually reduce injuries hasn't been independently established. Rasmussen says the cleats tested better than any other, but he has called those results "privately owned" and never released them. Wannop told Yahoo Sports that most of Caddix's specific claims aren't supported by public data.

Players wear them anyway. Williams says his ankles, knees, and feet have bothered him less than with other cleats, and that a small edge compounds over a long career. Rasmussen makes the same case: "The longer you play, the more valuable you are."

What does visibility cost?

Rasmussen estimates an NFL footwear license would cost tens of millions of dollars. "We don't have a fraction of that money," he says. He and his father, Jeff, began developing the cleat in 2015 and started selling it in December 2024. Revenue was just under $1 million last year, and Rasmussen expects just over $3 million in 2026. Most sales go direct, from high schoolers to NFL equipment managers; the rest move through retailers including Dick's Sporting Goods and Scheels.

Caddix has never paid an NFL player to wear its cleats, Rasmussen says, though some players are turning down shoe deals to do so. He hasn't named any. Super Bowl-winning quarterback Joe Flacco, now a Caddix investor, wore the first pair on an NFL field in 2024 with the Colts. Equipment managers on all 32 teams have since bought them.

The National Women's Soccer League posed a similar barrier. This year it began charging brands a league fee plus player fees to show cleat logos — $100,000 for the league piece alone, which Rasmussen called "a serious detriment to our business." He instead sent the $5,000 player fee to Kansas City Current defender Kayla Sharples, a Caddix investor and the first NWSL player in the cleats. The league fined her anyway, then rescinded those fines in a settlement with the players' union.

How did the fines pay off?

When the NFL fined Williams, Caddix pledged to cover both penalties and rented Chicago billboards reading "Caleb, we'll pick up the tab." Williams has no endorsement deal with Caddix; he bought his first pair himself, and the company has since made him a custom pair plus the unbranded pair he switched to in November.

After the first fine was reported on October 24, news and social media mentions jumped to nearly 300 per day, according to media-monitoring firm Meltwater. The firm estimates buying that coverage would have cost about $6 million — nearly twice the revenue Caddix expects this year. Baylor sports marketing professor Lane Wakefield told Yahoo Sports that Williams's unpaid praise worked like a commercial, only more believable.

Orders are now arriving so fast that Caddix is short on inventory, and current and former NFL players have reached out about investing. Rasmussen still wants the logo on an NFL field someday — but for now he's betting on locker-room spread. "It's very organic," he says. "The product is speaking for itself."

Original: espn.com

Share this article:

More from Amara Osei

Amara Osei

Show full bio

Senior reporter covering companies, deals and strategy in entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.

2,503 articles

Related articles

« Previous article