Innovation & Tech

Only 5-10% of ChatGPT Referrals Come From Brand Websites

Only 5-10% of ChatGPT referrals come from brand websites, per McKinsey data cited by Go Social's Courtney Sandora, who says brands not optimized for AI search will become invisible fast.

By Nathan Brooks

5 min read

I’ve Spent the Past Year Analyzing Why AI Recommends Some Products Over Others. Here’s How to Win the Holiday Shopping G
I’ve Spent the Past Year Analyzing Why AI Recommends Some Products Over Others. Here’s How to Win the Holiday Shopping GZulfugar Karimov / unsplash

What's News

  • A McKinsey study found only 5-10% of ChatGPT referral sources come from websites, according to Courtney Sandora.
  • Sandora, founder of Go Social, started analyzing client visibility on ChatGPT about a year and a half ago.
  • AI cited niche trade publication Whiskey Wash as an authority over bigger consumer titles, Sandora found.
  • Press releases get discounted by AI, which recognizes them as promotional rather than editorial content.
  • Sandora has run her own business for about 16 years.

By Nathan Brooks

Only 5% to 10% of ChatGPT's referral sources come from brand websites, according to a McKinsey study cited by Courtney Sandora, founder of the digital marketing agency Go Social. That single statistic explains why she believes brands that don't optimize for AI search will fade from view — and why the holiday shopping season is now being fought inside answer engines, not just Google rankings.

Sandora, whose agency specializes in the spirits industry, laid out her approach in an as-told-to interview. Her core message for practitioners: answer engine optimization (AEO) is not SEO with a fresh coat of paint. It's a discipline built on storytelling, third-party credibility and knowing which consumer questions your brand can credibly own.

How She Stumbled Onto the AI Shortlist

Sandora started her own business about 16 years ago and has spent her career tracking how new channels change brand discovery. "Post-influencer marketing, AI visibility is what I've been super excited about," she said.

About a year and a half ago, she began searching for her clients — who work heavily in wine and whiskey — on ChatGPT. The results surprised her. "I was like, 'Wow, ChatGPT is citing the publication Whiskey Wash' and some of these trade publications that quite honestly when you tell clients, 'Oh, I got you in that,' they're like, 'Meh, it's okay.'"

The lesson: AI doesn't weigh prestige the way humans do. It cited Whiskey Wash not because it rivals Men's Journal, but because it reads the niche outlet as an authority. For marketers, that changes the math on which placements actually matter.

Her warning to clients is blunt. "Brands that aren't optimized for AI will become invisible really fast," Sandora said. "I'm not saying SEO is totally going away, but there's a reason I never went into SEO." SEO, in her framing, is technical — site links, keywords. AEO is about positioning: where a brand is relevant in consumers' lives and which questions it can genuinely answer.

What Does the McKinsey Data Actually Change?

The practical question for any brand team: if AI pulls almost none of its answers from your website, where does it pull from? The McKinsey finding, as Sandora reads it, reflects user behavior. People rarely ask an LLM to compare two brands in the same portfolio or interrogate an ingredient — the kinds of queries that send the model to a product page.

Instead, they ask things like: "I'm going to San Francisco. What's a great bar downtown?" That's a recommendation query, and it's decided by third parties.

"AI is not going to pull its response from a brand's website; it's smart enough not to do that," Sandora said. "So knowing how to tell a story and seeding the right message with third-party authorities like journalists and creators becomes critical."

Not all third-party signals carry weight, though. Go Social runs plenty of social media for clients, and while LinkedIn matters for B2B, Instagram isn't driving results on LLMs, she said. Reddit, which AI once leaned on heavily, has seen its influence decline recently. Press releases fare worst of all: AI is "savvy enough to say, 'This is a press release. This isn't an article,' and not give it the same weight."

Start With the Category, Not the Brand

Sandora's process begins with the consumer, not the product. Her team maps the entire category — say, bourbon — and studies what questions people ask ChatGPT about it. You can't see every individual query, she notes, but they cluster into recognizable groups.

Then comes the honest audit: does your brand appear in the answers? If not — common for newer brands — you have to decide which questions you could credibly own.

That word "credibly" does the heavy lifting. "You don't want to go out there and say, 'I want to be the best bourbon.' Good luck," Sandora said. One Go Social client was trying to own a specific cocktail that nobody was asking about. Her team had to ask whether the effort was worth it at all. If no one is asking the question, owning the answer changes nothing.

Once the landscape is mapped, execution means seeding stories across PR, creators and even the short product descriptions on retailer websites. Sandora points out that those retailer blurbs are a real positioning surface — the intended message needs to be there too, consistently.

Why Consistency and Availability Decide the AI Shortlist

Sandora's bourbon example shows the stakes. Some bourbons own the gifting category — an important, heavily queried space. If such a brand stops appearing in gift guides, "you make room for a competitor to slide in."

The mechanism is pattern recognition. "The more AI sees a third party recommending you, the more likely you'll appear in AI searches," she said. But she adds a hard commercial caveat: "You also have to have retail availability. If people can't purchase, that's going to be a problem."

Skeptics remain. Sandora recalls early Reddit discussions where people dismissed AEO as a fad that would never compete with SEO. Even now, clients tell her their SEO contact says an FAQ page and some website tweaks will do the trick. "That doesn't hurt, but it's not going to move the needle. AEO is a different beast," she said.

She expects the tooling layer to consolidate — much as scheduling tools that businesses sold were absorbed into social platforms overnight, leaving those vendors shuttered. Early movers helping brands navigate LLMs will likely get pushed aside as tools get smarter and more integrated.

But her bet survives the churn: "I'm banking on the idea that people are still going to need help figuring out the story they want to own and how to tell it." For brands heading into the holiday season, that's the working thesis — find the question you can answer, seed it with third parties, and stay on the shelf.

Original: thegosocial.com

Share this article:

More from Nathan Brooks

Nathan Brooks

Show full bio

News editor covering regulation, policy and their impact on entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.

2,232 articles

Related articles

« Previous articleNext article »