Pitchfork founder Ryan Schreiber breaks silence on Condé Nast sale
Pitchfork founder Ryan Schreiber says it was "harsh to be under her thumb" under Anna Wintour, in his first interview since selling the site to Condé Nast in 2015.
By Olivia Hart
3 min read

What's News
- Ryan Schreiber sold Pitchfork to Condé Nast in 2015.
- Schreiber calls working under Anna Wintour "harsh to be under her thumb".
- It is his first interview since leaving the company.
- A 2021 Pitchfork review described Imagine Dragons' music as "emotions fired out of a T-shirt cannon".
- Phoebe Bridgers says she thinks of Pitchfork's Jet review — a monkey urinating in its own mouth — once a day.
Ryan Schreiber, the founder of music site Pitchfork, has given his first interview since leaving the company — and he says it was "harsh to be under her thumb," referring to Condé Nast chief content officer Anna Wintour.
Schreiber sold Pitchfork to Condé Nast in 2015, a move that shocked the industry and drew accusations that he had sold out to corporate media. In the new interview, he speaks openly about the deal, his departure, and his life since — including living as an out gay man.
The timing of the conversation is notable. On the early November day the interview took place in New York City, Pitchfork dominated social media conversation once again — this time over a resurfaced tweet. Jon Ossoff, the newly re-elected senator from Georgia, wrote sincerely in 2012: "Looking forward to your writeup of the new @imaginedragons album."
The joke lands because Pitchfork built its reputation on savaging exactly that kind of mainstream act. A 2021 Pitchfork review described Imagine Dragons' music as "emotions fired out of a T-shirt cannon." Ossoff's earnest anticipation of a Pitchfork writeup of the band reads, in retrospect, as gloriously misplaced.
Why does the resurfaced tweet matter?
The Ossoff moment joins a canon of viral Pitchfork references that musicians and public figures keep alive. Phoebe Bridgers has said she thinks about the site's review of Jet's second album once a day. That review consisted of a video of a monkey urinating in its own mouth — perhaps the most famous pan in the site's history.
Halsey went further. The singer tweeted a wish that the Pitchfork office, located on the site of the 9/11 attacks in New York, would "collapse already." The remark illustrates how sharply the site's verdicts could cut — and how personally artists took them.
These episodes form the cultural backdrop to Schreiber's account. The site he founded became famous enough that a sitting senator's decade-old tweet about it can still trend. That is the brand Condé Nast bought in 2015.
What does Schreiber actually reveal?
Three things stand out from the interview, according to the published excerpt:
-
The Wintour dynamic. Schreiber describes the experience of working under Wintour's oversight in blunt terms, calling it "harsh to be under her thumb." Wintour, as Condé Nast's chief content officer, held authority over the company's editorial titles, including Pitchfork after the acquisition.
His personal life. For the first time since leaving, Schreiber speaks about his new life as an out gay man — a disclosure he had not made publicly during his tenure at the company.
The reasons he quit. He addresses why he walked away from the site he founded, though the full details sit behind the interview's paywall.
The 2015 sale itself remains the pivotal event. At the time, the industry reaction treated the acquisition as a betrayal of Pitchfork's indie credentials — the outlet that made its name with the monkey video was now part of the publishing group behind Vogue.
What is the takeaway?
Schreiber's account fills a decade-long gap: he stayed silent about the sale and his exit until now, while the site he built kept generating headlines he no longer controlled. The full interview promises his unvarnished view of what corporate ownership cost him — personally and editorially.
Source: theguardian.com
More from Olivia Hart
Show full bio
Staff writer covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.
2,535 articles