Economy & Policy

Spender’s 40% CGT plan could raise $590 million more

The Parliamentary Budget Office estimates Allegra Spender’s broader 40% CGT discount could raise $590 million more than Labor’s innovation-linked concession, which major business groups support.

By Grace Kim

5 min read

A chef deserves a better CGT plan as much as a tech founder
A chef deserves a better CGT plan as much as a tech founderHG-Fotografie / pixabay

What's News

  • Spender proposes a 40% CGT discount on active business assets, including shares and employee options.
  • The PBO estimates the proposal could raise $590 million more than Labor’s startup-concession model.
  • Labor’s IBCC requires companies to show more than half of at least two of assets, workers and income relate to qualifying innovation.
  • On a $1 million gain, the 40% proposal would add $47,000 in tax, including Medicare, for a top-rate taxpayer versus Labor’s 50% discount.
  • Chalmers plans to restore indexation for gains accrued from July 2027.

By Grace Kim

The Parliamentary Budget Office estimates that Wentworth MP Allegra Spender’s alternative to Labor’s innovation-linked startup concession could raise $590 million more than Labor’s model with the concession retained. She wants a 40% capital gains tax (CGT) discount on active business assets, including shares and employee options, rather than limiting relief to businesses that meet Labor’s innovation test.

What does Spender want to change?

Her alternative to the Innovative Business CGT Concession (IBCC) would make the 40% discount available to anyone starting a business, not only startups. The discount would cover active business assets, including shares and employee options.

The Startup Daily column frames the difference with a hypothetical restaurateur who bootstraps, pledges her house as security, signs a two-year lease and hires six people before selling a product. It argues that she took more risk than a VC partner who ordered the fish entree.

The tweak also lets the Labor government address its original premise: changing the tax treatment of investment properties to make housing more affordable. The column reserves that policy debate for another article.

Takeaway: Spender replaces an innovation test with broader eligibility for active business owners.

Why do Australia’s 1999 CGT rules still matter?

In 1985, when Back to the Future reached cinemas, Paul Keating introduced Australia’s broad CGT for the first time. Indexation addressed the effect of inflation on gains.

The column uses a simple example: an asset bought for $100 and sold for $110 after 10% inflation has no real gain. It also favors restoring averaging, which let taxpayers soften the impact of booking years of gains in one tax return and could help investors or owners with a windfall in one year.

By 1999, John Ralph’s Review of Business Taxation gave the Howard government reason to revisit the paperwork. Then-Treasurer Peter Costello froze indexation, abolished averaging and introduced a 50% discount for eligible assets held for at least 12 months.

Costello said of the old system: “I have great doubts whether people are complying with it”.

The reforms followed privatisations including Telstra, CBA and Medibank. Costello aimed to encourage investment and make tax compliance easier as Australia became a nation of shareholders.

Twenty-seven years later, Treasurer Jim Chalmers is taking indexation back for gains accrued from July 2027. The column says that does nothing for an owner who starts with nothing and faces tax a decade later on sweat equity.

It adds that if the RBA’s current measures have their intended impact on inflation, that objection becomes academic, apart from anyone with a paperwork obsession. Because Chalmers’s political science PhD focused on Keating, the column invokes Keating’s dictum: “The legislation is complex because the issues are complicated.”

Takeaway: The core dispute is whether CGT rules should smooth inflation and windfalls or favor long-held investment assets.

What does Labor’s innovation test require?

Under Labor’s IBCC, a company must show every year that more than half of at least two of three measures relate to qualifying innovation:

  • Assets
  • Workers
  • Income

Chalmers has objected to Spender’s plan, which would make some startup founders pay more. Treasury doubts the proposal would be simpler, fairer or more productive and sees scope for gaming. Chalmers wants to target companies whose innovations benefit the wider economy. He said he wrote to Spender after Treasury examined her proposal.

The Startup Daily column challenges that position. CPA Australia puts the cost of the Labor compliance burden to business at hundreds of millions. The column says most tell the author the work is unwanted because it does not help build successful businesses.

The tax trade-off is concrete. On a $1 million gain, a founder entitled to Labor’s 50% discount would declare $500,000. Under Spender’s 40% discount, the founder would declare $600,000. For a taxpayer on the top marginal rate, that adds $47,000 in tax, including Medicare.

The column frames the change as a question of risk allocation. A founder may price equity before a later change in the business removes the concession, leaving the individual to absorb more of the downside.

Takeaway: Spender’s proposal trades a 10-percentage-point discount for broader eligibility, with a $47,000 tax difference for a top-rate taxpayer on a $1 million gain.

Who supports the broader discount?

The PBO estimate comes with a warning: the underlying data has gaps. Even so, the column argues that the available figures justify a hearing for Spender’s alternative.

Greens Senator Nick McKim spoke to Spender, called her idea “very interesting” and is open to a Senate inquiry. The Greens’ votes to pass Labor’s legislation remain unsettled.

Only a fortnight of parliamentary sittings remained in 2026 when the article was published. With the Coalition opposed, Green support mattered to Labor’s pre-Christmas timetable more than another peak-body press release.

The Business Council, the Council of Small Business Organisations Australia (COSBOA), the Australian Chamber of Commerce and Industry (ACCI), and Ai Group have backed the broader discount.

The column urges founders and venture capitalists to sign Spender’s open letter and tell senators why they support a change that could cost them personally.

Its practical pitch is to bring a chef to Canberra to explain the hours and risk required to build a restaurant; a software founder can then book the table.

Bottom line: The broader discount’s next test is whether enough senators support an inquiry before Labor’s pre-Christmas timetable closes.

Source: smartcompany.com.au

Share this article:

More from Grace Kim

Grace Kim

Show full bio

Market editor covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.

2,301 articles

Related articles

« Previous articleNext article »