Economy & Policy

Trump Labor Rule Makes It Easier to Classify Workers as Contractors

The Labor Department scrapped the Biden-era test and adopted a control-based standard favored by business. Employees cost up to 30% more than contractors. The rule takes effect in January.

By Olivia Hart

3 min read

Labor Department Makes it Easier for Companies to Classify Workers as Contractors
Labor Department Makes it Easier for Companies to Classify Workers as ContractorsSergio-sq / pixabay

What's News

  • The Labor Department finalized the rule on Thursday; it takes effect in January, 60 days after formal publication.
  • Employees can cost businesses up to 30% more than contractors, according to several surveys.
  • The new test replaces the 2024 Biden-era rule and focuses on company control and opportunity for profit or loss.
  • Industries affected include trucking, healthcare, retail sales and app-based services such as Uber.

By Olivia Hart

The U.S. Labor Department finalized a rule on Thursday that makes it easier for companies to classify workers as independent contractors rather than employees, scrapping a Biden-era standard that business groups fought to repeal. The change takes effect in January, 60 days after formal publication.

The Department of Labor said the 2024 rule it replaced was legally flawed and that the new test creates a clearer standard for businesses and workers to follow. That claim of clarity deserves scrutiny. Labor standards that shift with each administration rarely give either side durable guidance — this is now the third federal standard on the books in five years.

What does the new rule change?

The Biden-era rule established multiple factors for determining whether a worker is an employee or a contractor under federal wage law, and any single factor could tip the scales toward employee status. The rule finalized on Thursday narrows that inquiry. It focuses on whether workers are under a company's control, or whether they have a genuine opportunity for profit or loss based on their own initiative or investment.

The new standard resembles a regulation adopted during Trump's first term. That earlier rule said workers who own their own businesses or can work for competing companies — a driver who works for both Uber and Lyft, for example — can be treated as contractors.

The takeaway: the controlling question is now who directs the work and who bears the financial risk, not a basket of weighing factors.

Who gains, and by how much?

The rule could lower costs for companies in trucking, healthcare, retail sales and app-based transportation and delivery services such as Uber — industries that rely heavily on contractors. The stakes are concrete. Employees can cost businesses up to 30% more than contractors, according to several surveys, because employees are entitled to the minimum wage, overtime pay, unemployment insurance, reimbursements for expenses and other protections contractors do not receive.

Those same companies routinely face lawsuits accusing them of misclassifying workers to save money. The companies deny the accusations. A friendlier federal test narrows one avenue of attack, though it does not touch state classification laws, where much of the litigation actually lives.

The takeaway: a 30% cost gap is a large incentive, and the rule shifts the legal balance toward the employers who capture it.

What did the Labor Department say?

Labor Secretary Keith Sonderling defended the rewrite in a statement: "It's more important than ever to ensure our labor regulations keep pace with the changing ways that Americans choose to work, and businesses choose to operate."

The statement frames the change as modernization. It does not address what worker advocates call the core issue: whether the protections being trimmed were being delivered at all.

Why the fight is not over

Worker classification has been one of the most contentious employment-related issues of the last decade. Trade groups lobbied heavily to repeal the 2024 rule after an effort by Republicans in Congress to block it stalled. Supporters of the Biden-era rule argue misclassification is rampant in some industries and that repeal lets employers strip workers of basic legal protections.

The department's statement does not quantify how many workers the change affects, how many lawsuits it might blunt, or how much employers will save in aggregate. What is on the record is a directional claim — lower costs for companies — and an untested promise of clarity.

The takeaway: expect the rule to be challenged in court by unions and worker groups, as prior classification rules were, with the January effective date as the next fixed point.

Source: insurancejournal.com

Share this article:

More from Olivia Hart

Olivia Hart

Show full bio

Staff writer covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.

2,465 articles

Related articles

« Previous articleNext article »