Economy & Policy

UK Faces 'Polycrisis' Risks With Only Two Cable Repair Ships, Lords Warn

A Lords report accuses ministers of complacency, citing China's 90% share of a key antibiotic compound and 95% of UK food supplied by nine firms.

By Daniel Okafor

4 min read

UK exposed to polycrisis of threats amid government ‘complacency’
UK exposed to polycrisis of threats amid government ‘complacency’851878 / pixabay

What's News

  • About 90% of the world's 6-APA, the basis of penicillin-type antibiotics, comes from China.
  • Almost 95% of UK retail food is supplied by just nine companies from 131 distribution hubs.
  • BT has access to only two undersea cable repair ships, one of which is 35 years old.
  • The report demands a national resilience strategy within six months.
  • The Cabinet Office cites over £1bn invested in pandemic security.

About 90% of the world's 6-APA, the organic compound behind penicillin-type antibiotics, comes from China — and the UK has no integrated penicillin facility of its own. That figure sits at the centre of a parliamentary report that accuses the government of complacency in the face of increasingly interconnected national threats.

The report, written by the Lords national resilience committee after months of expert hearings, calls the UK underprepared for a "polycrisis" — several disruptions blending into one another at the same time. Current plans, it says, are out of date and fragmented, each one built around a single emergency such as a power loss, a water failure or a cyber-attack.

"In the face of potentially catastrophic risks and despite the recent launch of the Be Ready campaign, the government appears complacent and the UK is underprepared. We need to move fast to turn things around," the committee warned.

What does the report want changed?

The committee sets out a series of structural recommendations. The central one is political: a dedicated cabinet minister for resilience, plus an annual statement to parliament in which the prime minister sets out the country's level of preparedness.

Other proposals include:

  • A national resilience strategy from the Cabinet Office within six months, properly funded and more coherent than the current national risk register, which lists 87 separate items.
  • A pause to plans for switching off the Freeview-style digital terrestrial TV signal, in case other communication systems fail.
  • A booklet sent to every household on preparing for and responding to an emergency, following the Danish and Swedish model.
  • A national register of volunteers and civil reservists, with possible paid leave for people taking resilience-based training.

The government's existing "Be Ready" campaign, launched recently by Labour, advises households to stockpile food and water. The committee said most of the public remain unaware of the scale of potential threats — cyber-attacks, proxy acts of violence, strikes on undersea cables, extreme weather and flooding. It also warned that AI is "supercharging" the risk from cyber-attacks.

How exposed are medicine and food supplies?

The report identifies medicines and food as particular vulnerabilities, both dependent on highly centralised and international supply chains with few or no back-up options.

On antibiotics, the bulk are now made in China or India. Years of price pressures and cost-based procurement, the report says, have left Europe with only one integrated penicillin facility and the UK with none. One witness told the committee that reliance on overseas-made items as basic as scissors and medical staplers means a disruption could badly affect many everyday surgical operations.

The food picture is similarly concentrated. Almost 95% of UK retail food is supplied by just nine companies from 131 distribution hubs. Disruption to a handful of firms, the report found, could create very significant disruption nationwide. Household stockpiling of several days of food and water, as Be Ready recommends, counts as something — but it does not address the strategic risk to that centralised system.

Why do undersea cables matter?

The report highlights digital communications as a specific risk area, including possible attacks on undersea cables. BT, which holds a dominant position here, has access to just two cable repair ships. The report describes them as "one French-owned and generally unavailable, and one UK-based but 35 years old."

Emergency planning itself, the committee argues, remains "organised in silos around individual risks, organisations and sectors, rather than the continued operation of essential national functions."

What happens next?

Jean Coussins, the cross-bench peer who chairs the committee, said ministers should not be "squeamish" about setting out the risks. "Evidence shows that the public would be reassured, not alarmed, by candid information. People are more than willing to step up in an emergency, but less clear [as to] why and how," she said.

A Cabinet Office spokesperson said the government would "carefully review" the specific recommendations but insisted work was already under way at speed. "From launching a national campaign to raise awareness of the simple steps households can take to stay safe in everyday emergencies, to delivering the largest home defence exercise in recent history next year, and investing over £1bn in pandemic security – our work on resilience goes further than successive governments have ever gone before," the spokesperson said, adding that the government would keep "working with and learning from our allies."

The test now is whether the six-month deadline for a funded national resilience strategy produces a plan that matches the concentration risk the committee has documented.

Source: theguardian.com

Share this article:

More from Daniel Okafor

Daniel Okafor

Show full bio

Correspondent covering money, funding and market shifts around entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.

2,189 articles

Related articles

« Previous articleNext article »