Economy & Policy

Carbon Removal Makes Its First Appearance in a Cop31 Deal Text

Carbon removal and capture entered a Cop31 negotiating text for the first time, backed by a record 700 CCS lobbyists, as the UN says 320bn tons of CO2 must be removed this century.

By Nathan Brooks

4 min read

Controversial efforts to suck carbon from atmosphere championed at UN climate talks
Controversial efforts to suck carbon from atmosphere championed at UN climate talksmarcinjozwiak / pixabay

What's News

  • CCS and CDR appeared in a Cop31 negotiating text for the first time on Friday, forming the basis of a final deal.
  • A record 700 CCS lobbyists are at Cop31 — more than the smallest 50 national delegations combined, per CIEL.
  • The UN estimates 320 billion tons of CO2 must be removed this century to return below 1.5C of warming.
  • Technological carbon removal has captured just 2 million tons of CO2, versus 2 billion tons removed annually, mostly via reforestation.

Carbon dioxide removal and carbon capture appeared in a Cop31 negotiating text for the first time on Friday, marking a procedural breakthrough for technologies that until now lived mostly in climate models. The text will inform the basis of a final deal at the UN climate summit under way in Antalya, Turkey, jointly presided over by Turkey and Australia.

The lobbying muscle behind this shift is record-breaking. A record 700 lobbyists at this Cop are advocating for carbon capture and storage (CCS), where carbon is captured at a polluting facility and buried underground, according to the Center for International Environmental Law (CIEL). That's more delegates than the smallest 50 national delegations combined.

What does this change for the carbon removal industry?

For practitioners, Friday's inclusion signals that CDR — heat-trapping CO2 taken from the atmosphere and stored underground, in oceans or in products like carbonated drinks — is finally entering the formal negotiating machinery. Advocates at the summit's Think Negative pavilion want a new global agency to coordinate carbon removals, and they've pressed both presidency countries to keep CDR in the final outcome.

"CDR still sounds unreal to people but we spent a whole year trying to make it into the agenda of Cop31," said Göker Avci, a decarbonization strategist at CDR Türkiye. "We spoke with the presidency about making it into the final decision and they have started to realize the potential."

The scale problem is stark. The world currently removes around 2 billion tons of carbon a year, almost all of it through reforestation. Technological efforts to vacuum CO2 from the air have removed just 2 million tons — roughly 0.1% of the total — with leading companies underperforming and struggling financially. Investor cash is flowing elsewhere, largely into artificial intelligence, leaving the sector nascent and under-resourced.

Yet the UN estimates the world will need to remove an enormous 320 billion tons of CO2 this century to get back under the 1.5C threshold. The UN has already acknowledged the planet will soon surge past 1.5C of warming since the pre-industrial period, and even with reduced emissions, temperatures won't fall below that level for thousands of years without rapid removal.

What's the pushback?

Environmentalists see a dangerous trade. CCS draws criticism over its costs, its mixed track record and its potential to prolong fossil fuel reliance. Rachel Kennerley, carbon capture campaigner at CIEL, called CCS a "greenwashing exercise" used by large oil and gas companies to extend the age of fossil fuels. She argued CDR and CCS both play "similar kind of diversionary roles from mitigation" and are "allowed for prolonging fossil-fuel use, basically."

"The focus should always be on cutting emissions now, it's very dangerous to assume that we can put more emissions into the atmosphere and then assume we will have technology in the future to just remove them again," Kennerley said. "These are hypothetical technologies and part of the problem we're seeing here is that we're seeing the normalization of this overshoot peak and return pathway. That return element is at the moment hypothetical. I mean, I think it's impossible."

Her preferred pathway: keep the 1.5C exceedance as small as possible by eliminating fossil fuel use, then let reforestation slowly absorb the excess CO2 over many hundreds of years.

Can CDR actually scale?

Removal methods vary — direct air capture, crushing carbon-locking rocks, and protecting or seeding forests and mangroves. Countries have long relied on the theoretical promise of removal in their climate plans, and that promise now has to become reality to bend the temperature curve rather than just flatline it.

"CDR's really been missing from the discussion and debate even though it's been in all the models for decades," said Injy Johnstone, a net zero expert at the Max Planck Institute. "It's the only solution that we have to actually balance out those emissions and it return from the state of overshoot."

She also argued the effort shouldn't rest on entrepreneurs alone: "Really these efforts shouldn't have to be led by the entrepreneurs kind of doing their thing on the ground, we have to get more vocal about it and actually also start to put in place these kinds of procedures."

Johnstone's framing of the scale required is the one practitioners should sit with: "We need this, we need this fast, and we need to be really seeing it on a scale that rivals the global energy industry in terms of its kind of footprint in the world." If Cop31's final text keeps CDR in, the industry's binding constraint shifts from political recognition to capital — and right now, that capital is choosing AI.

Source: theguardian.com

Share this article:

More from Nathan Brooks

Nathan Brooks

Show full bio

News editor covering regulation, policy and their impact on entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.

2,232 articles

Related articles

« Previous articleNext article »