Leadership

1,337 CEO Exits Set the Stage: A Champion's Coach on Filtering Advice

1,337 CEO exits in nine months mean a wave of new leaders facing advice overload. Aryna Sabalenka's coach Jason Stacy shows how filtering fixed 428 double faults.

By Olivia Hart

4 min read

I’ve coached the world’s most marketable athlete for 8 years. New CEOs should copy how her team handles expert advice
I’ve coached the world’s most marketable athlete for 8 years. New CEOs should copy how her team handles expert advice12019 / pixabay

What's News

  • Challenger, Gray & Christmas counted 1,337 CEO exits in the first nine months of 2025, including 111 in September.
  • John Ternus became Apple CEO on September 1, with Tim Cook staying on as executive chairman.
  • Aryna Sabalenka finished 2022 with 428 double faults, the most on tour; months later she won her first Grand Slam.
  • Jason Stacy has coached Sabalenka for eight years; she has spent over 100 weeks at world No. 1 and was named the world's most marketable athlete.

Challenger, Gray & Christmas counted 1,337 CEO exits in the first nine months of this year, including 111 in September alone. On September 1, John Ternus took over at Apple, with Tim Cook staying on as executive chairman. Every one of those successors now faces the same hazard: too much good advice.

That is the argument of Jason Stacy, who has spent the past eight years as performance coach to Aryna Sabalenka, the multiple Grand Slam champion with more than 100 weeks at world No. 1. Sabalenka was just named the most marketable athlete in the world, across all sports. Stacy's claim is simple: incoming leaders get an "overdose" of input from staff, former executives and boards, and they start to lose their own instincts.

"When you must make the tough decisions your gut already knows, you hesitate," he writes in a Fortune commentary. The piece reflects only his views, not Fortune's — worth remembering when a coach sells a coaching method.

What happened when the advice was excellent?

Stacy's evidence is a serve. In 2022, Sabalenka finished the year with 428 double faults, more than any other player on tour. In San Jose, she lost frustrated and crying, saying the team had tried everything. "We have done everything except the one thing you're most afraid of," Stacy told her. A technical flaw had hardened into a mental barrier.

The team brought in a biomechanist. Stacy calls him "amazing" — and then documents how quickly expertise turns into noise. The specialist found roughly 20 things to fix: rhythm, timing, foot placement, rotation, leg loading, toss, movement quality. He then wanted to rebuild her forehand as well. All valid, and far too much at once.

Stacy notes a second, less flattering dynamic. When specialists get access, they naturally hunt for problems to justify it. That human impulse adds noise, and he says leaders should expect it.

How the team cut 20 fixes down to two

Tennis coach Anton Dubrov and Stacy sat down with the biomechanist and selected one or two changes that would influence everything else. They picked two: the direction her left arm drove down after the toss, and how her right wrist turned over through contact. Everything else on the specialist's list was held back.

They also controlled delivery. The biomechanist coached only at specific practices, only at specific moments, always with Dubrov present. Some weeks he traveled with the team under the same rules. The rest of the time, Dubrov delivered the message with Stacy as an outside eye.

The result, per Stacy: one consistent voice, no overanalysis. A few months later Sabalenka won her first Grand Slam at the Australian Open and has dominated the tour since. One case study is not a method — but the mechanism, message discipline, is at least concrete.

Where does loyalty actually start?

Stacy brings his own credentials, and his own filter, to the argument. At 13 he was homeless; a dojo wedged between an adult bookstore and a pawnshop helped him off the streets. His sensei, Jan Sunderlin, told him: "Through loyalty you gain trust. With trust comes freedom. To maintain that freedom, remain loyal."

Stacy reads loyalty as layered, with the first layer owed to yourself — your code and your gut. Early in Sabalenka's career, he says, team members brought anxiety into her space, and his job was to step between her and it. Sometimes that meant asking people to leave the team, or at least the room. For a new CEO, that urgency can come from the board or from old-timers still attached to old plans.

He also flags a quieter failure mode: advice as a hiding place. More meetings, another deck. Leaders feel responsible while their gut knows which decisions they are avoiding.

What should a new CEO actually do?

Stacy's prescription is a page of paper. Before the first big meeting, write down who you are and which values hold even at a cost. Write the one or two goals for the quarter, then the year. Name whose voice will filter incoming advice — a chief of staff, a COO, one board member. If the former CEO is still in the building, agree early how their advice reaches you.

Then test every piece of input against that page: does it align with who you are at your best, or redirect you into someone you're not?

He closes with the arc of his own job. Early on, he and Dubrov shared hotel rooms and hunted cheap flights; nobody offered advice. Now everyone knocks, and the task is unchanged: protect the person who must perform.

"We don't rise to the occasion. We fall back to the level of our code," Stacy writes. In your first 90 days, make sure that code is still yours.

Source: fortune.com

Share this article:

More from Olivia Hart

Olivia Hart

Show full bio

Staff writer covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.

2,319 articles

Related articles

« Previous articleNext article »