Money & Markets

After $100 Oil, S&P 500 Declines Were More Common: SignalPilotLabs

SignalPilotLabs found that the S&P 500 fell in 46.7% of months following $100 WTI, versus 35.5% after other months, though 30 observations could not rule out chance.

By Daniel Okafor

3 min read

Oil over $100: stocks fell more often after, 46.7% vs 35.5%
Oil over $100: stocks fell more often after, 46.7% vs 35.5%AI-generated

What's News

  • The study covered 489 months from January 1986 through September 2026.
  • WTI closed at $100 or more in 30 months across eight runs.
  • The S&P 500 fell in 46.7% of months after $100-plus oil, versus 35.5% after other months.
  • The same-month decline rate was 43.3% after $100 oil, versus 35.5% otherwise.
  • Only 1,521 of 10,000 random 30-month draws produced at least 14 declines.

By Daniel Okafor

The S&P 500 fell in 14 of 30 months after WTI crude closed at $100 or more, a 46.7% rate versus 35.5% after other months, SignalPilotLabs found.

The TradingView analysis began with a $103.37 October WTI value in the St. Louis Fed’s FRED database. SignalPilotLabs then checked every month from 1986 and compared WTI with the S&P 500.

What did the study measure?

SignalPilotLabs paired monthly WTI crude, identified as FRED:DCOILWTICO, with the S&P 500’s monthly closes, identified as SP:SPX. The sample ran from January 1986 through September 2026 and contained 489 months.

Within that sample, WTI closed at $100 or more in 30 months, grouped into eight runs. For each occurrence, SignalPilotLabs tested whether the S&P 500 fell during the same month and during the following month, then compared both outcomes with all other months.

SignalPilotLabs wrote the two tests and the bar before pairing any month. The predetermined framework reduced the risk that the author would select a comparison only after finding a favorable pattern.

What did the analysis find?

In the month after a $100-plus WTI month, the S&P 500 fell 46.7% of the time, or 14 of 30 months. SignalPilotLabs calculated that the index fell 35.5% of the time after months outside that group.

During the $100-plus month itself, the S&P 500 fell 43.3% of the time, compared with 35.5% after other months. The typical percentage move in the following month was +0.31%, compared with +1.31% after other months, SignalPilotLabs reported.

Could the result be luck?

SignalPilotLabs split the comparison around 2010. Through 2010, the S&P 500’s next-month decline rate after $100 oil was 62.5%, against 36.3% after other months. From 2011 onward, the corresponding rates were 40.9% and 34.1%.

The sample still contained only 30 months arranged in eight runs. In 10,000 random draws of 30 months, 1,521 produced at least 14 S&P 500 declines. That result missed the bar SignalPilotLabs had set before the test.

SignalPilotLabs called the evidence “A lean, not a rule.” The analysis did not establish that $100 oil reliably predicts a decline in any single month.

Which periods generated $100-plus oil months?

SignalPilotLabs counted eight $100-plus months in 2008, five in 2014 and five in 2022. In 2026, WTI closed at $102.86 in March and $108.64 in April.

During those two 2026 months, the S&P 500 fell 5.09% in March and rose 10.42% in April, SignalPilotLabs reported. The two observations therefore cut in opposite directions.

How did the chart present the evidence?

SignalPilotLabs charted monthly S&P 500 closes from January 2007 through December 2015 on a log scale. Equal vertical steps represented equal percentage moves, making the display work like a ruler for percentage changes.

Each run of WTI months at $100 or more was shaded. A short mark identified each month: orange for an S&P 500 decline and grey for a gain. Ten of the 23 marks shown were orange, SignalPilotLabs said.

SignalPilotLabs first drew the chart from 2007 through 2026, but 238 candles proved too thin to read. The author switched the display to 2007 through 2015 after completing the statistical test and said the change affected only the picture.

What should investors take from the finding?

“Treat it as a lean to watch, not a reason to sell,” SignalPilotLabs advised. The analysis labeled its findings observations rather than recommendations.

The result does not explain why oil was high. SignalPilotLabs noted that 2008, 2014 and 2022 were very different years. It also does not establish an effect for other oil-price levels or in other markets, and it uses monthly closes from the past.

What does the finding leave unanswered?

Each future $100-plus WTI close adds another observation to the 30-month record. For now, SignalPilotLabs supports treating the 46.7% next-month decline rate as a lean to watch, not a standalone reason to sell stocks.

Source: tradingview.com

Share this article:

More from Daniel Okafor

Daniel Okafor

Show full bio

Correspondent covering money, funding and market shifts around entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.

2,189 articles

Related articles

« Previous articleNext article »