Amazon's $5 NYC Delivery Fee Threat Splits Its Own Customers
Amazon's in-app warning of up to $5 in higher delivery fees if NYC's Delivery Protection Act passes has split readers, with backers citing worker pay and critics calling it a logistics 'nightmare.'
By Amara Osei
2 min read

What's News
- Amazon warned NYC customers of up to $5 per order in higher delivery fees if the Delivery Protection Act passes.
- The bill before the NYC Council would require companies like Amazon to directly employ delivery drivers instead of contractors.
- Mayor Zohran Mamdani supports the Delivery Protection Act.
- Roughly three dozen reader comments debated the bill after Amazon's in-app notice appeared on Thursday.
- One reader called last-mile delivery 'inherently unpredictable and messy' and said people would lose jobs.
Amazon told New York City shoppers it could raise delivery fees by up to $5 per order if the Council passes the Delivery Protection Act — and roughly three dozen Business Insider commenters split sharply over who wins the standoff.
The bill, now before the New York City Council, would require companies like Amazon to directly employ their delivery drivers instead of using contractors. Mayor Zohran Mamdani supports the measure. Amazon pushed back last Thursday with an in-app and website notice tagged with a bright red "Attention" label, warning customers of the potential fee increase.
The move drew reactions from Amazon customers to the speaker of the New York City Council. It also triggered a running debate among Business Insider readers, whose comments sketch the fault lines the Council will have to referee.
What do supporters of the bill say?
Several commenters backed the Delivery Protection Act, arguing it would benefit the workers who deliver Amazon orders in the city and level the field for other businesses.
"It is time these trillion dollar companies to pay their workers their fair share," one commenter wrote.
Another compared Amazon to "the robber barons of old trying to dictate laws that it may not like." The same commenter added: "I'm hoping we restore mom and pop stores."
Some readers dismissed the fee threat outright. Even if Amazon charges more for delivery, they wrote, New Yorkers will absorb the cost or shop elsewhere. One commenter put it bluntly: "You can just take the hit to your pockets like the rest of us normal people do every day. Or just leave the city then. I'm sure another company will be happy to take your place."
Why do opponents call it a logistics problem?
Other commenters said the proposal could hurt businesses Amazon currently contracts with under its delivery service provider model. One reader argued that last-mile delivery is "inherently unpredictable and messy" and lends itself to contractors rather than full-time employees.
"Anyoneeee who thinks this is a good idea doesn't know what they are talking about," that commenter wrote of the bill. "People will just lose their jobs."
"People who don't work in the industry don't understand what a nightmare for logistics this legislation will be," another wrote.
A third put the stakes on both sides of the transaction: "The only losers will be the customers and the 100's of people who do the deliveries."
What happens next?
The bill remains before the New York City Council, with Mamdani's backing giving it political momentum. Amazon, for its part, has put a price tag on its opposition — up to $5 per order — and a public channel for it, using its own app to reach shoppers directly. Whether customers blame the Council or the company for that cost may decide how much leverage each side holds as the vote approaches.
Source: feeds.businessinsider.com
More from Amara Osei
Show full bio
Senior reporter covering companies, deals and strategy in entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.
2,503 articles