Economy & Policy

NYC Lawmakers Weigh Options Replacing Amazon Direct-Hire Mandate

New York City lawmakers are rewriting the Delivery Protection Act, trading an Amazon direct-hire mandate for a menu of carriers, licensing and city oversight.

By Nathan Brooks

4 min read

NY City Lawmakers Weigh Overhaul of Amazon Delivery Worker Bill
NY City Lawmakers Weigh Overhaul of Amazon Delivery Worker Billcdz / pixabay

What's News

  • About 40 Amazon delivery service partners operate in New York City, hiring couriers to handle Amazon packages.
  • The Delivery Protection Act has the backing of an overwhelming majority of City Council members and Mayor Zohran Mamdani.
  • Revised legislation could come up for a City Council vote within a few weeks if an agreement is reached.
  • Amazon would surrender control of delivery routes, daily quotas and hiring under the option-based draft.
  • Last-mile delivery facilities would need licenses from the Department of Consumer and Worker Protection.

New York City lawmakers are rewriting the Delivery Protection Act, the measure that would have put thousands of Amazon couriers on the company's own payroll. The bill has won the backing of an overwhelming majority of City Council members and Mayor Zohran Mamdani, and it has pushed Amazon into open conflict with the city.

Under revisions now under discussion, Amazon would pick from a menu of options rather than accept a single direct-hire mandate:

  • Employ delivery workers directly
  • Use carriers such as UPS or the US Postal Service
  • Contract with fully independent third-party operators

People with knowledge of the matter say the legislation could reach a City Council vote within a few weeks if lawmakers reach agreement.

What does Amazon give up?

The compromise would rewrite how much control Amazon keeps over the companies that actually deliver its packages. One person familiar with the talks said it would require a complete change from Amazon's current operating model. Amazon would surrender oversight of contracted carriers, including:

  • Control of delivery routes
  • Daily delivery quotas
  • Hiring, firing and disciplining employees

The revised bill would let Amazon keep its network of small-business delivery partners, but grant them autonomy and subject those relationships to greater city oversight.

Amazon spokesperson Steve Kelly said: "We've made clear we're willing to work with anyone who wants to make progress on this matter."

Kelly also said: "We appreciate that Speaker Julie Menin has met with numerous stakeholders on this bill, including us, and we'll remain engaged with her and her team as work on the bill continues to try and reach the best outcome for New Yorkers."

Jack Lobel, a spokesperson for Speaker Julie Menin, said her office is "working around the clock with the bill sponsor and stakeholders to achieve legislation that protects workers, jobs, and street safety. A range of options are still on the table."

Why the small-business coalition cracked

Amazon and its delivery partners initially presented a united front against the bill. Amazon bankrolled a lobbying group that included many of its partners, and those businesses opposed the legislation.

That alliance began to fracture when some owners started meeting on their own with city officials, according to a person familiar with the negotiations who asked not to be identified because of private talks. They wanted greater transparency into how Amazon sets routes and determines how many packages drivers handle in a shift.

The meetings marked a breakthrough, the person said. The owners began pressing Council members for protections from Amazon's requirements, arguing their dependence on the company left them little leverage. They ultimately persuaded the bill's sponsors that the small businesses, not just their drivers, needed protection from Amazon.

About 40 Amazon delivery service partners, small businesses that hire couriers to handle Amazon packages, operate in New York City. Many owners opposed the bill because they said it would put them out of business.

Licensing survives the rewrite

Even if the direct-hire mandate goes, the revised legislation would keep a new regulatory layer in place. Amazon and other companies operating last-mile delivery facilities would need licenses from the city's Department of Consumer and Worker Protection, which would investigate complaints and make sure safety standards are met.

Amazon has threatened to pull its logistics operations out of New York if it must directly employ all of its delivery workers, as the bill currently proposes. The bill's backers argue outsourced workers endure unsafe conditions while Amazon reaps the benefit of cheaper labor.

What does this change for drivers and partners?

For the roughly 40 delivery businesses, the shift from a hard mandate to a menu of options is the difference between a business model they could lose and one they can run with autonomy. The price is city oversight: a license, complaint investigations and safety inspections on facilities that today sit outside the city's regulatory reach.

For Amazon, the fallback to UPS, the US Postal Service or independent operators turns a direct-hiring cliff into a choice among three contracting paths, each requiring less control over routes and labor than Amazon exercises now.

If sponsors hold the fractured coalition together, the City Council could vote within a few weeks. If they don't, the direct-hire trigger, and Amazon's threat to move its logistics operations out of the city, both stay on the table.

Source: insurancejournal.com

Share this article:

More from Nathan Brooks

Nathan Brooks

Show full bio

News editor covering regulation, policy and their impact on entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.

2,611 articles

Related articles

« Previous article