Deals & IPOs

Anthropic's Record IPO Tests Investors' Nerve and Math

Anthropic's record IPO draws split verdicts from five investors, who cite 1,206% revenue growth, $131 billion in cash, costly compute, concentration risk and public backlash.

By Olivia Hart

5 min read

Buy the AI boom or beware the hype? 5 investing pros weigh in on Anthropic’s IPO
Buy the AI boom or beware the hype? 5 investing pros weigh in on Anthropic’s IPOAI-generated

What's News

  • Anthropic's IPO is poised to set the proceeds record; orders open Wednesday and trading runs through Thursday.
  • Anthropic's IPO and $131 billion in cash could help the company secure scarce computing capacity, Christian Giadolor said.
  • Early valuation estimates were $1.13 trillion to $1.3 trillion; Tuesday reports pointed to $1.5 trillion or $1.6 trillion.
  • Third-quarter revenue rose 47% sequentially and 1,206% year over year, Stephanie Link said.
  • More than 50 localities voted this month to limit or ban data-center construction, according to Ballotpedia.

By Olivia Hart

Business Insider reported that Anthropic's IPO is poised to set the proceeds record with $131 billion in cash when orders open Wednesday. Institutional and some retail investors can buy first, and shares become broadly available by Thursday's close. Five investors interviewed by the publication split between buying, avoiding or taking a measured position.

The timing sharpens their disagreement. Business Insider cited data-center opposition that helped fuel a Democratic “blue wave,” a Jensen Huang-Nvidia scandal raising national-security concerns, and a continuing AI sell-off. Investors must weigh those pressures against Anthropic's growth prospects.

What does the IPO actually offer?

Christian Giadolor, an investment analyst at Chicory Wealth who previously worked in macro and sustainable investing at Bridgewater Associates, said Anthropic's S-1 warns that it may not secure sufficient computing power. He said the IPO's $131 billion in cash could help Anthropic skip the queue, but compute costs were “skyrocketing” and he questioned whether the economics were “sustainable.”

In the first half, nearly 50% of Anthropic's revenue came from cloud service providers, Giadolor said. That mix exposed Anthropic to slower data-center construction or weaker hyperscaler demand. Giadolor also said Anthropic has signaled that it could build its own infrastructure, adding the risks of owning heavy physical assets.

Anthropic's workforce grew more than fivefold from the end of 2024 through September, according to a company figure cited by Business Insider. For Giadolor, cash may help Anthropic jump the queue, but it cannot erase its dependence on scarce capacity and long-dated infrastructure.

Why would two investors buy?

Phil Blancato, chief market strategist at Osaic, called the IPO a must-buy “if you believe AI will transform how we work and live.” Osaic oversees $810 billion in client assets and estimates that knowledge workers globally generated more than $40 trillion in earnings in 2025.

Anthropic cited IDC's estimate that AI will have a $22.5 trillion economic impact by 2031. Blancato cautioned that neither figure translates directly into revenue. “Even if Anthropic captures only a small fraction of that value, there's still room for the business to grow well beyond where it is today,” he said.

Blancato described AI taking on more work as “extreme change.” He did not dismiss the cost risk: computing and infrastructure costs in the most recent quarter exceeded revenue. Anthropic must commit to data centers years in advance, while customers can cut usage much sooner.

Lower-cost alternatives could also limit future earnings, Blancato said. His case depends on Anthropic capturing value faster than infrastructure obligations erode it.

Stephanie Link, chief investment strategist at Hightower Advisors, said yes, but with a small allocation because she expects volatility. Hightower manages $350 billion, and Link offered the same caution she gave prospective SpaceX investors earlier this year.

Link called $1.13 trillion to $1.3 trillion more palatable than the $2 trillion valuation floated earlier this year. She cited Tuesday-evening reports putting pricing closer to $1.5 trillion or $1.6 trillion. Link also cited an IPO six times oversubscribed, which she viewed as supporting demand.

Link cited what she called “amazing” revenue growth of 1,206% year over year and 47% sequentially in the third quarter. “I'm mildly concerned about the top five customers accounting for 21% of revenue, but I expect that to decline in the coming years as Anthropic signs up more customers,” she said. Link sees enough growth for a limited stake, not enough visibility for a large one.

Can the economics support the valuation?

Dhruv Maniktala, chief investment officer at True North Advisors and Western Alternative Strategies, said “maybe.” His multi-family office manages $5.9 billion and acquired Anthropic shares in the private market at “much cheaper” valuations. The current price blocks him from making a blanket buy recommendation.

He called Anthropic a great company rolling out solutions across industry verticals, but said the valuation contains an “unreasonable amount of growth built in.” To fund its projected data-center buildout, Anthropic needs $3.5 trillion in annual revenue, according to Maniktala's estimate.

Maniktala translated that requirement into $1,750 a month for every U.S. employee, including hairdressers and fast-food workers. He said the outcome is “impossible to predict” at either a $500 billion or $2 trillion valuation. He would consider a small allocation for investors with spare capital, accepting a “big unknown.”

For Maniktala, the issue is not the valuation range but the financing burden embedded in it.

Why are two investors saying no?

Kristin Hull, founder and chief investment officer at Nia Impact Capital, said no and described herself as “sitting on the sidelines.” Her concerns include Anthropic's debt load, long-term lease commitments, an untested business model, uncertain AI margins as usage rises, and complicated relationships with partners that are also competitors.

She wants evidence of independence and profit before entering. “On the business model alone, and given the growing range of competitors, I would wait to see a clearer path toward both independence and profitability,” Hull said.

Giadolor sees legal and regulatory risks beyond operating costs. Anthropic has warned that its models could pose an existential risk to humanity, while little insurance exists for models that cause harm. “If Rogue AI and this 'existential' threat emerges, it could place Anthropic in unprecedented legal jeopardy,” he said.

Hull's financial objections make the no case concrete. Giadolor adds a liability that could outlast any revenue forecast.

What public costs could follow?

Hull said investors may also be underpricing “negative externalities,” including future intellectual-property litigation, mass-surveillance and privacy concerns exemplified by Flock cameras, and environmental costs. The question is not merely whether Anthropic earns money, she said, but who carries the expense of its infrastructure.

According to Ballotpedia, more than 50 localities voted this month to limit or ban data-center construction through ballot measures. Hull linked the November election to a broader debate over whether Anthropic and its investors, or host communities, bear those environmental costs. She said the resistance could create major financial challenges but offered no estimate of the effect.

Her warning adds a political constraint that revenue growth alone cannot answer. The public case depends on private profits not becoming public liabilities. The IPO's next test is whether Anthropic can convert six-times-oversubscribed demand into durable margins before compute commitments, regulation and local opposition constrain growth.

Source: feeds.businessinsider.com

Share this article:

More from Olivia Hart

Olivia Hart

Show full bio

Staff writer covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.

2,301 articles

Related articles

« Previous articleNext article »