Burnham weighs NICs cut for under-25s as Milburn targets youth jobs
Burnham says he will weigh NICs relief for under-25s 'very carefully' after Milburn's report urged a £5,000-to-£10,000 threshold rise for 21-24s.
By Nathan Brooks
3 min read

What's News
- Nearly 1 million UK 16-24-year-olds are not in employment, education or training.
- Milburn's report proposes doubling the NICs threshold for 21-24s from £5,000 to £10,000.
- Employers currently pay 15% NICs on earnings above £5,000 for non-apprentice 21-24s.
- Under-21s and apprentices under 25 are NICs-exempt below £50,270 earnings.
- Burnham declined a firm commitment, saying NICs changes are 'matters for the budget'.
Prime Minister Andy Burnham says he would consider cutting national insurance contributions for young people "very carefully", responding to an independent report that urges gradually lowering employer NICs for under-25s, starting with retail and hospitality businesses.
The report, published Tuesday by former Labour health secretary Alan Milburn, also proposed doubling the threshold at which firms start paying NICs for 21- to 24-year-olds — from £5,000 to £10,000 of annual earnings. That's a five-fold increase in the earnings band where employers pay nothing on young hires.
What do businesses currently pay?
The rules split young workers into distinct brackets. Companies pay no employer NICs at all for staff younger than 21, nor for apprentices under 25 — unless those workers earn above £50,270 a year.
For non-apprentices aged 21 to 24, it's different. Employers pay 15% on annual earnings above £5,000. Milburn's proposal would push that threshold to £10,000, halving the taxable band for that age group and trimming the cost of every hire in it.
Why the report landed now
The stakes are large. Official figures show nearly 1 million 16- to 24-year-olds in the UK are not in employment, education or training — so-called Neets. That's roughly one in seven of the age cohort without a job, a course or an apprenticeship.
Burnham inherited the situation, as he put it, and he's not rushing a commitment. "I think it's something you've got to consider very carefully going forward. Obviously, I've come in [and] inherited the situation," he told LBC.
He did credit his predecessor's government with one move: "I think the last government was right to offer support to employers to take on young people. So, that was one of the things that they did through the Youth Guarantee."
What does this change for employers and young workers?
For now, nothing is decided. Burnham framed his answer around two tests — evidence and cost. "I will want to look at all of the evidence in relation to it, but also the affordability of making any change to national insurance," he said.
He pointed out that some relief already exists: "There is an exemption for young people up to 21, so there is some [movement] that's been done in that area."
But he ruled out a firm promise on the timing. "But I can't give you a firm commitment today because obviously these matters are matters for the budget more broadly," Burnham said. Any NICs cut for under-25s, in other words, runs through the Treasury's budget process, not a standalone announcement.
For retail and hospitality firms — the sectors Milburn named as the starting point — the prize is a lower marginal cost on young hires. For 21- to 24-year-olds, who currently face the 15% charge above £5,000, the change would directly reduce payroll tax on every pound of salary in that band.
How Burnham distances himself from Starmer's welfare reforms
Burnham also drew a hard line between his approach to welfare and that of the last government under Keir Starmer and former chancellor Rachel Reeves, which faced a backbench rebellion over its proposed welfare reforms.
"Well, it is a very different proposition. First and foremost, it's about support for young people, opportunity for young people," he told LBC.
"It's not about an arbitrary number for cuts within the system. You've got Conservatives and Reform who are going that way. It's the crude cuts approach, and it just doesn't work. It's why they left office with a million Neets, and we're going to have to do something fundamentally different."
He said Milburn's report sketches that alternative. "I think Alan Milburn has laid out what that looks like. It is also about a very different way of providing support, so not the old top-down tick-box system of the past, but a much more localised approach."
The immediate question for employers is budget timing: whether the Treasury signs off on the phased NICs reduction, and whether retail and hospitality get first access to it as Milburn proposed.
Source: theguardian.com
More from Nathan Brooks
Show full bio
News editor covering regulation, policy and their impact on entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.
2,352 articles