Economy & Policy

Milburn youth hiring plan offers up to £5,000 in incentives

Milburn proposes higher National Insurance thresholds, hiring payments of up to £5,000 and an opportunity guarantee, while employers warn guaranteed hours may complicate youth recruitment.

By Nathan Brooks

4 min read

It's too expensive to hire under-25s, say firms. Will Milburn plans help?
It's too expensive to hire under-25s, say firms. Will Milburn plans help?12019 / pixabay

What's News

  • Milburn proposes raising the National Insurance threshold for ages 21-24 from £5,000 to £10,000 over five years.
  • Employers would receive £3,000 for hiring someone who has been NEET for six months, plus £2,000 for employers with fewer than 50 staff and another £2,000 for care or disability.
  • A related BBC analysis projected savings of only £200 million a year by 2036 from the NEET reforms.
  • The Employment Rights Act is due to be enacted next year.
  • Kickstart funded two six-month, 25-hour placements at Aetha in 2020; one worker stayed for five years.

Alan Milburn's report proposes hiring payments of up to £5,000 for employers taking on a young person who has been NEET, meaning not in education, employment or training, for six months. It would also raise the National Insurance threshold for people aged 21 to 24 from £5,000 to £10,000 over the next five years.

The BBC's company interviews found that recent increases in National Insurance and the minimum wage had raised the cost of taking on staff. Milburn's report seeks to get more 18- to 24-year-olds into work.

What does the Milburn plan change for employers?

Milburn's package lowers employers' National Insurance costs for 21- to 24-year-olds and offers targeted payments to employers taking on young people who have been NEET for six months. The proposed opportunity guarantee could widen the applicant pool by improving routes into education, training and work.

Milburn recommends prioritizing retail and hospitality. The Recruitment and Employment Confederation (REC) said reducing NI costs directly addressed what firms needed to decide to hire. The British Chambers of Commerce (BCC) welcomed the proposal but said it should extend beyond those sectors.

The BCC warned that a narrow sector focus could add complexity and block potential career paths. UKHospitality chief executive Allen Simpson said raising the threshold was the right recommendation and would provide immediate support for job creation.

Bournemouth café owner Ben Blades put the hiring problem in numbers. He said: "My labour costs are already over 45%. We simply cannot justify the extra cost to put on an extra staff member to train someone up for three months." He said squeezed hospitality margins had made it more sensible to hire someone with prior experience.

Hiring incentives for harder-to-place workers

Under the proposal, the payment structure would work as follows. Eligibility would depend on the employer's size and the young worker's circumstances.

  • Any employer taking on a young person who has been NEET for six months would receive £3,000.
  • Small businesses with fewer than 50 employees would receive an extra £2,000.
  • An additional £2,000 would follow if the young person had been in care or was disabled.

The combined payment could therefore reach £5,000. A related BBC analysis put the projected saving from the NEET reforms at only £200 million a year by 2036.

Ally Fir runs a bookshop in Westbourne with her partner Matt. She said an incentive scheme for small firms would let her hire more, especially young people, and that she would join immediately. Despite receiving job applications every single day, she says employment costs make it impossible to take on more staff.

Tom Parsons runs design consultancy Aetha in Poole, Dorset. In 2020, the Kickstart Scheme funded two fully funded six-month job placements for young people at his firm, each offering 25 hours a week.

Parsons said: "One of them stayed with us for five years and the other one I think about three years. And it completely changed the game for them". He said a similar scheme would really help, although the cost of hiring remained a huge barrier.

The guaranteed-hours risk

Milburn's report warns that a flagship government employment-rights reform could weaken youth hiring. Ministers plan to abolish zero-hours contracts they describe as exploitative and replace them with guaranteed-hours contracts based on the hours workers normally work.

Much of the detail remains unsettled, and the Employment Rights Act is due to be enacted next year. Milburn said the change could cause problems at a time when the youth labour market is already weak.

The REC said companies were particularly worried about guaranteed hours. It argued that tackling the NEET problem gave ministers a chance to reconsider the measure, which Milburn said could weaken youth hiring.

A wider pool of applicants

Milburn also proposes an "opportunity guarantee". Under the plan, young people would have a legal right to a route into education, training or work and would receive support to use it. The report says this could help businesses struggling to recruit.

Dean Greene, 35, is a sales director at the waste-management facility Williams Environmental. He said the company received few applicants for an ad for a marketing and sales role, with no huge uptake from the 16-to-24 age range.

Greene thinks the waste industry's dirty image may deter applicants, but he remains confident many would respond if they knew the role was available. He cited his own path: Greene started as an admin officer scanning paperwork at 18 and remained with the company for 17 years.

For employers, the immediate calculation is whether lower NI and payments of up to £5,000 offset training costs and the uncertainty created by guaranteed hours. The proposals will be judged on whether they prompt employers such as Blades and Fir to hire inexperienced young workers while ministers finalize reform for an Employment Rights Act due next year.

Source: BBC Business

Share this article:

More from Nathan Brooks

Nathan Brooks

Show full bio

News editor covering regulation, policy and their impact on entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.

2,352 articles

Related articles

« Previous articleNext article »