Futures Rollover Costs: The Hidden Bill Behind Every Contract Roll
A single WTI roll can carry a $1,200 price gap plus $6 in fees. Plus500's analysis shows how contango and backwardation decide whether rolling helps or hurts longs.
By Olivia Hart
5 min read
What's News
- Rolling one WTI contract from a $70.00 November to a $71.20 December price implies a $1,200 gap on the 1,000-barrel contract.
- At $3 per contract per side in commissions and fees, a single rollover costs $6 before spreads and slippage.
- Contango tends to produce negative roll yield for long positions; backwardation tends to produce positive roll yield.
- A calendar spread order can reduce leg risk but does not guarantee a better price or eliminate costs.
- Trading futures is available through Plus500US Financial Services LLC, an FCM registered with the CFTC (NFA ID 0001398).
A $1.20-per-barrel gap between November and December WTI crude futures equals $1,200 on a single 1,000-barrel contract — and that money moves before a trader has made or lost anything on the underlying market. That is the core problem Plus500's futures analysis lays out: a trader can call the market direction correctly and still watch returns erode through the mechanics of rolling positions from one contract to the next.
Every rollover is two trades, and both carry costs. Close the expiring contract and open the next one, and you pay broker commissions, exchange and clearing fees, bid-ask spreads, and slippage on each leg. Plus500 puts a number on it: at $3 per contract per side in all-in commissions and fees, rolling one contract costs $6 before the spread and slippage are even counted. Roll monthly or quarterly, and those charges compound with every cycle.
There is also execution risk inside the roll itself. Place two separate orders, and if the first fills while the market moves before the second fills, you sit temporarily exposed to what the analysis calls leg risk. A calendar spread order submits both legs as one package and reduces the chance of one leg filling without the other. But Plus500 is careful about what this tool does not do: it does not guarantee a better price, and it does not eliminate transaction costs.
What is the calendar spread, and why does it cost $1,200?
Two futures contracts on the same market trade at different prices simply because they expire at different times. The difference is the calendar spread. In the WTI example — November crude at $70.00 per barrel, December at $71.20 — the arithmetic works out to (71.20 − 70.00) × 1,000 = $1,200.
The analysis stresses what that $1,200 is not. It is not a fee, and it does not mean an automatic loss. The profit or loss on the November contract depends on the original entry price; once the December position opens, results depend on how that contract moves from its new entry level. The price gap is part of the economics of the roll, not a separate charge deducted from an account. In plain words: the gap changes your starting point, not your P&L.
For commodities, the gap often reflects the real cost of holding the physical asset — storage, financing, and insurance — plus supply and demand pushing nearby and later-dated contracts apart, sometimes substantially. Equity index futures work differently. Their prices largely reflect financing costs relative to expected dividends over the contract's life. When financing costs exceed the expected dividend yield, later-dated contracts tend to trade above nearer-dated ones.
Contango or backwardation: which curve is working against you?
Plot futures prices across expiration months and a pattern emerges — an upward- or downward-sloping futures curve. Plus500 defines the two regimes:
- Contango: later-dated contracts trade above nearer-dated ones, tending to create negative roll yield for a long position.
- Backwardation: later-dated contracts trade below nearer-dated ones, tending to create positive roll yield for a long position.
In a contango example, WTI trades at $70.00 in November, $71.20 in December, and $72.00 in January. A long sells November, buys December at the higher price, and then faces January at a higher price still when the next roll comes. The trader does not automatically lose money on each roll. But if the curve stays in contango and later-dated contracts converge toward the spot price as expiration approaches, that convergence creates negative roll yield, all else being equal.
Backwardation reverses the slope: November at $75.00, December at $73.80, January at $72.50. A long sells November and buys December at the lower price. If the curve holds and prices converge, the relationship can contribute to positive roll yield. Backwardation can develop when near-term supply is tight or immediate demand is strong relative to available supply — in commodity markets, the benefit of holding the physical product now also plays a role.
The caveat deserves emphasis, and Plus500 states it plainly: contango and backwardation describe the relationship between contract prices, not a guarantee of future returns. The curve can change before your next roll, and the market can move against your position.
What is roll yield, really?
Roll yield describes the contribution to returns from the relationship between futures prices across expiration dates, and how that relationship changes as contracts approach expiration and positions are rolled. For a long repeatedly rolling, contango tends to act as a headwind; backwardation tends to act as a tailwind. Tendencies — not guaranteed outcomes. A market in contango today can shift into backwardation later, so the current curve is only part of the picture, sitting alongside price movements and transaction costs.
How should traders price a roll before making it?
Plus500 breaks the decision into three questions:
- What will the trades cost? Add up commissions and exchange fees; account for the bid-ask spread and potential slippage.
- How far apart are the contracts? Check the calendar spread between the expiring contract and the next one.
- What does the curve look like? Determine contango or backwardation, and consider how continued rolling might affect returns.
For positions held across several expiration cycles, small trading costs accumulate while the curve's shape adds to or detracts from returns over time. The takeaway is simple: compare the cost of both trades, check the price difference, and identify the curve regime before rolling.
The analysis closes on a note worth preserving: these factors help assess the economics of maintaining a position, but they guarantee nothing. Trading in futures and options carries substantial risk of loss and is not suitable for every investor; clients may lose more than their original investments, and past results are no indication of future performance. Futures trading is available through Plus500US Financial Services LLC, a Futures Commission Merchant registered with the CFTC and a member of the National Futures Association (NFA ID 0001398). For anyone holding futures longer than a single expiration, the roll is not an administrative footnote — it is a cost center that deserves the same scrutiny as the trade thesis itself.
By Olivia Hart
Source: tradingview.com
More from Olivia Hart
Show full bio
Staff writer covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.
2,205 articles