Milburn review tells big UK employers: give feedback to rejected under-25s
A review by former minister Alan Milburn urges large employers to give rejected under-25s 'meaningful feedback,' targeting a drop in Neets from 13% to 5% by 2036.
By Grace Kim
3 min read

What's News
- Milburn's review proposes large employers give 'meaningful feedback' to all unsuccessful applicants under 25.
- The review targets cutting the UK Neet rate from 13% to about 5% by 2036.
- Robert Walters research found 86% of UK job hunters had applications ignored with no response.
- Ffion Johns submitted 70 applications before her first interview after becoming unemployed in June.
- Career coach Meg Burton says AI could automate responses to unsuccessful candidates.
Eighty-six percent of UK job hunters say employers have ignored their applications completely. That figure, from head-hunting firm Robert Walters, sits at the center of a new policy fight over so-called "job ghosting" — and former minister Alan Milburn wants the government to end it for young applicants.
Milburn's review into young people not in employment, education or training, published this week, recommends large employers give all unsuccessful applicants under 25 "meaningful feedback." The proposal is one part of a wider plan to cut the proportion of Neets — the label for that group — from 13% to roughly 5% by 2036.
The report's proposals relate mostly to England. It recommends that Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland adapt the principles to their own systems.
What does ghosting do to applicants?
The Milburn report calls the silence a "wall of silence" that is especially hard on young people because it gives them "nothing to learn from." It notes that applicants invest "time and emotional investment" in every submission.
Yugraj Samrai, 23, from Coventry, has submitted hundreds of applications since graduating from his marketing degree in July. He's unemployed, and 30 to 40% of the time he hears nothing back at all. The experience can make him "feel like a statistic, not a person," he told the BBC.
"I understand there are very few graduate jobs available, but at least give me a response to say whether I'll progress onto the next stage or not," Samrai said.
Ffion Johns, 24, from Llanelli, has been unemployed since June. She filed 70 applications before landing her first interview in September. She says the lack of feedback — not the rejections themselves — is her biggest problem, because she can't tell what to fix next time. She's also been ghosted after interviews several times.
"With most of these roles I'm not getting a rejection. I'm just not hearing anything, which can be quite frustrating," Johns said.
Jessica Anderson, 21, from Swindon, points to the hours behind each application. "It can really take hours and hours, so it just feels even worse to not even have that be recognised," she said.
Why don't employers respond?
Employers say they're flooded with applications in a very competitive jobs market, and responding to everyone is hard. AI is making it worse: applicants now use it to fire off large numbers of applications at once, hoping volume improves their odds.
Meg Burton, a career coach based in Leeds, says firms should at minimum tell candidates when they're unsuccessful — and argues AI could actually solve the problem it helped create, by automating those responses. Candidates who reach the interview stage, she says, deserve proper feedback.
"It doesn't have to be hugely detailed, it's just some pointers on why they were unsuccessful and what they can learn from that experience going forward," Burton said.
Can a wave of rejections demoralize too?
The government could adopt Milburn's proposals and crack down on ghosting. But that raises a second question: if candidates suddenly receive far more rejections than before, could that itself demoralize them?
Ellie McCrone, 20, from Northampton, accepts the concern but still backs feedback.
"If you are applying for hundreds of jobs and never getting anything, I think something is going wrong... You can't fix something unless you know what the problem is," McCrone said.
What can applicants do now?
Burton offers two practical defenses against ghosting. First, tailor the CV to each job rather than submitting "hundreds and hundreds of applications" that all look the same. Second, don't take silence as a verdict on your worth.
"Not hearing back doesn't mean you aren't a great candidate. Put it down to experience and move on," Burton said.
The ball now sits with the government. If it adopts the Milburn proposals, large employers face a new obligation — and thousands of young applicants would, for the first time, get an answer.
Original: gov.uk
More from Grace Kim
Show full bio
Market editor covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.
2,582 articles