Economy & Policy

Milburn review to propose legal guarantee of jobs or training for under-25s

Milburn's review will urge a legal guarantee of jobs or training for under-25s, paid for partly by curbing their access to universal credit health payments and Pip.

By Amara Osei

3 min read

Minister backs legal right to job support for young people
Minister backs legal right to job support for young peopleMarkoLovric / pixabay

What's News

  • Milburn's review, published Tuesday, recommends guaranteeing under-25s a job placement or training.
  • Under-25s would lose access to the universal credit health element and Pip under the plan.
  • Eligibility for subsidised six-month job roles widens from next April, triggered after 12 months out of work instead of 18.
  • McFadden confirmed some reassessed claimants will receive less than they get today.
  • Milburn wants "billions" in extra work-support spending over the next decade.

Former Labour cabinet minister Alan Milburn will recommend on Tuesday that every under-25 in the UK be guaranteed a job placement or training to help them find permanent work. Work and Pensions Secretary Pat McFadden has already backed putting that guarantee into law.

McFadden told the BBC's Sunday with Laura Kuenssberg that job support should be given a "legislative underpinning", adding the level of assistance on offer was currently "vague". Asked whether he agreed with a guarantee, he said: "I do think we need some legislative underpinning to this." He added the offer "needs to be more firm," saying: "People need more certainty about what they are entitled to."

What does the Milburn review propose?

The long-awaited review, published Tuesday, is also expected to say under-25s should no longer be able to claim the health element of universal credit, or personal independence payment (Pip), the main disability benefit in England and Wales. Some could be eligible for a new "additional cost allowance" covering day-to-day costs linked to health conditions.

Milburn told Kuenssberg the government should divert money away from the benefits system toward work support, and he wants "billions" extra spent on that help over the next decade. He said reduced entitlement for some claimants should come with a new "duty on government" to provide young people with apprenticeships, college places, job coaching, or a job.

He argued previous schemes, including the Kickstart programme during the Covid pandemic, failed to cut long-term joblessness because they were temporary.

Who loses benefits under the plan?

McFadden confirmed some current claimants will see entitlements reduced when the government moves younger claimants onto a new benefits system at scheduled reassessment. Some "would not receive what they would get today", he said, while others, such as those with long-term disabilities, would receive an increased amount.

That cuts into sensitive political territory. Labour MPs scuppered a previous benefits-cutting plan under Sir Keir Starmer last year, and reducing existing entitlements could prove controversial again on the backbenches.

How the guarantee would work in practice remains unclear. McFadden said the legislation would have to be drafted "carefully". Local councils already carry specific legal duties in areas like child protection and homelessness, but duties on central government tend to be far broader, such as operating a "comprehensive" health service.

What did the Conservatives say?

Shadow work and pensions secretary Helen Whately said her party backs reducing welfare spending but attacked the legal guarantee. It might "sound a nice thing to do," she said, but ministers would do better cutting taxes and regulations on businesses so youngsters find "real jobs".

She called it "absurd" that the government had increased taxes on employers to "subsidise things that look like jobs", adding: "Just stop doing the taxing."

What else did Milburn propose?

The former health secretary also said:

  • A sustainable reduction in welfare spending "cannot be achieved in two or three years", warning "crude cuts" to benefits would create additional costs for government elsewhere
  • GPs should not be responsible for signing sick notes declaring people unable to work
  • Ministers should "look very carefully" at Labour's manifesto commitment to phase out the reduced minimum wage for 18-to-21-year-olds, noting moves toward it had "imposed a lot of cost" on firms

The review lands as the government widens eligibility for its scheme offering jobless under-25s subsidised six-month roles on the minimum wage. From next April, claimants will be offered a role after 12 months of unsuccessful job hunting, down from 18. It is the second expansion this year, after the maximum age rose from 21 to 24.

The political test now falls on Starmer's government: converting a legal guarantee and benefit cuts into legislation without repeating last year's backbench revolt.

Source: BBC Business

Share this article:

More from Amara Osei

Amara Osei

Show full bio

Senior reporter covering companies, deals and strategy in entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.

2,136 articles

Related articles

« Previous articleNext article »