Up to 100 Labour MPs Set to Rebel Over Rosebank Oilfield
Seventy-five Labour MPs have signed a letter against the Rosebank oilfield, with the count expected to top 100 amid cabinet splits, union pressure and £3.8bn in tax revenue claims.
By Grace Kim
4 min read

What's News
- 75 Labour MPs have signed a letter opposing Rosebank, with the total expected to reach 100 or more.
- The letter will be delivered to Andy Burnham within the next fortnight.
- Adura says Rosebank and Jackdaw will generate £1.4bn in tax revenues by the end of this parliament, rising to £3.8bn by the end of the next.
- Energy secretary Miatta Fahnbulleh is said to be minded to reject Rosebank, but the chancellor John Healy backs the plans.
- Gas began flowing from the Jackdaw platform on Sunday, Adura said.
Seventy-five Labour MPs have already signed a private letter opposing the Rosebank oilfield, and signatories expect the count to reach 100 or more before it lands on Andy Burnham's desk within the next fortnight.
The letter, first reported by the Sunday Times, says Britain's credibility as a global climate leader would be destroyed if drilling went ahead off the Scottish coast, and argues the project would not reduce energy bills. MPs from Labour's 2024 intake are playing a significant role in the campaign, but the discontent runs wider than the freshman class.
The numbers tell the story of a party under strain. One hundred potential signatories on Rosebank. A parallel rebellion brewing over Europe. And welfare changes — Alan Milburn's proposals on out-of-work benefits for young people — hitting the Commons agenda this week. Three fights at once.
Who decides Rosebank's fate?
Energy secretary Miatta Fahnbulleh is said to be minded to reject the controversial oilfield. She could still be overruled by the prime minister, and the cabinet is split: chancellor John Healy backs the plans.
The government has described its process around Rosebank as "quasi-judicial." Fahnbulleh previously told the Guardian the decision would be consistent with the UK's climate obligations, carbon budgets and the energy transition.
The prospect of government resignations looms if the drilling licence is granted. Foreign secretary Ed Miliband is unlikely to quit, but such a decision would put him in an awkward position given his past description of Rosebank as a "colossal waste of taxpayer money and climate vandalism." Miliband is a member of Sera, the Labour-affiliated environmental organisation instrumental in organising the letter. So are ministers Luke Pollard, Georgia Gould, Matthew Pennycook and others.
What are MPs saying?
"We're at a point where Reform and the Greens are on the back foot and Labour is enjoying a bounce, but a lot of people are very worried about Rosebank," one Labour MP who signed the letter said.
"Andy's big problem is also that he has let three fights start at the same time, which could prove to be very awkward. Rows about this and what our position should be on European relations have come at the same time as the debates that will come this week over [Alan Milburn's] proposals on out-of-work benefits for young people. If control of the narrative on one issue is lost it could lead to panic about another."
A second Labour MP said the concern extends well beyond the 2024 intake: "There are a good number of colleagues who just don't sign letters like this normally, but who are concerned. It's about staying true to what we told voters, and the fact that a lot of people after the summer we've had are really now making a link between the climate crisis and what their experience was when it comes to temperatures or flooding."
What's the money on the other side?
Adura, the North Sea oil and gas producer operating both Rosebank and the smaller Jackdaw field, is pushing back hard. On Sunday the company said gas had begun to flow from the Jackdaw platform, "bringing vital UK energy resources ashore in time for winter."
Claire Mueller, Jackdaw project director at Adura, put hard figures on the stakes: Rosebank and Jackdaw are expected to generate £1.4bn in tax revenues before the end of this parliament, rising to £3.8bn by the end of the next.
"With Jackdaw now producing, and other major projects including Rosebank in our pipeline, we have an opportunity to build a bright future for the North Sea, supporting jobs, investment and Britain's energy security for years to come," Mueller said.
Some letter signatories had reluctantly backed Jackdaw on the basis that it was primarily gas. Rosebank, an oilfield, drew the line.
Can this rebellion match the welfare revolt?
The letter is modelled on the one that derailed Keir Starmer's welfare overhaul plans, which spanned the new intake and veterans. One signatory sees limits to the comparison.
"I do think it will probably get to around 100 MPs and may go beyond it, but the welfare rebels were willing to be much more ruthless. The other thing is that some of the people behind that rebellion are now in government and they are wise to these things."
Burnham also faces pressure from the other direction. The Labour-supporting unions GMB and Unite are backing Rosebank heavily, hold considerable influence over his operation, and are separately voicing concern at his talk of rejoining the EU.
Squeezed between 100 potential rebels on one side and powerful unions on the other, Burnham's Rosebank call now looks like the defining test of his autumn.
Source: theguardian.com
More from Grace Kim
Show full bio
Market editor covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.
2,178 articles