New scorecard checks Flock Safety cameras at 10 major retailers
Fight for the Future's 10-retailer scorecard maps known automated license plate reader use, while the group presses Home Depot and Lowe's to cut ties with Flock.
By Nathan Brooks
4 min read

What's News
- Fight for the Future's scorecard covers 10 major retailers.
- Only a handful of businesses answered the group's questionnaire.
- Costco uses ALPR cameras at less than 12 locations nationwide.
- The research draws on questionnaires, third-party reporting, crowdsourced spotting and privacy policies.
- Home Depot and Lowe's were targeted in a campaign to cut ties with Flock.
By Nathan Brooks
Fight for the Future has released a scorecard covering 10 major retailers and what the group knows about their use of automated license plate readers, including Flock Safety cameras, ahead of the holiday shopping season. The checklist can flag a retailer’s use or disclosure without proving that every location has a camera.
The scorecard lands amid increasing criticism of Flock Safety and other ALPR vendors. Fight for the Future cited reports of misuse by officers, high error rates that can lead to dangerous police encounters, and concerns about access by Immigration and Customs Enforcement to Flock Safety’s nationwide camera network.
Flock and other providers say the cameras have helped investigators investigate legitimate crimes, rescue kidnapped kids and track stolen cars. Flock Safety’s nationwide scale complicates local control, however, because the network spans jurisdictions.
Fight for the Future says investigators in one jurisdiction can frequently access data captured by cameras elsewhere, which makes it hard for local officials to understand and contain privacy risks. The organization also reports that many municipalities have ended contracts with Flock and other providers; in some cases, officials have covered cameras while waiting for the service provider to remove them.
What does this change for shoppers and retailers?
For shoppers, the scorecard is a screening tool, not a complete store directory. The group says many businesses do not use ALPRs at every location. Costco, for example, told Fight for the Future that it uses the cameras at “less than a dozen locations nationwide,” so a national chain’s scorecard entry cannot tell shoppers whether their particular branch has cameras.
Private companies’ opacity remains the constraint. Fight for the Future notes that private companies aren’t subject to freedom of information laws, leaving shoppers without the records requests they could use against government agencies. That gap matters because many businesses deploy ALPRs in their own parking lots to track vehicles, sometimes share the data with law enforcement, and can keep those practices outside public view.
The scorecard partly fills that gap. Fight for the Future says many major brands acknowledge in their privacy policies that they might use the technology, and some indicate they may share device information with law enforcement. A policy disclosure still leaves the store-by-store question open.
The project combines direct answers with outside evidence. Fight for the Future sent questionnaires to retailers. Where companies did not respond, it used third-party news reports, crowdsourced camera spotting and published privacy policies.
“We got responses from just a handful of [businesses],” said Reem Suleiman, senior campaign director at Fight for the Future. The sparse response rate leaves privacy policies, reporting and shopper observations carrying more of the evidentiary load.
Fight for the Future encourages people to send tips about retailers using the cameras and requests to add specific stores to the scorecard. Those additions can clarify whether a broad privacy-policy disclosure masks a limited deployment.
The group also wants the debate to extend beyond public-sector camera contracts. “Retailers also need to be brought into the conversation,” Suleiman said. Before releasing the scorecard, Fight for the Future organized a campaign with home improvement influencers that called on Home Depot and Lowe's to cut ties with Flock.
For retailers, the scorecard makes ALPR deployment a customer-facing issue. They can expect emails generated by the scorecard, scrutiny of what their privacy policies disclose, and requests to refrain from ALPR use. Silence on the questionnaire, however, does not establish that a company has no cameras; it mainly signals that the public record remains incomplete.
The scorecard gives shoppers direct links to retailer email addresses and suggested text for those requests. It also offers a route for shoppers to ask questions before buying, rather than waiting for a government records process that does not exist for private operators.
“We don’t have a FOIA request that we can do for companies or a public records act request that we can impose upon companies, but nothing’s stopping us from writing to them,” Suleiman said. “Nothing’s stopping people from letting these companies know what they want and what they expect.”
For Flock and other vendors, the near-term test is whether retailers disclose more specific deployment and data-sharing practices before holiday shopping. More complete answers would narrow the uncertainty now filled by policy language, outside reporting and crowdsourced sightings; continued silence would keep the scorecard partial.
Original: flocksafety.com
More from Nathan Brooks
Show full bio
News editor covering regulation, policy and their impact on entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.
2,368 articles