Innovation & Tech

New York Bill to Ban Facial Recognition Sweeps MSG Into a Reckoning

A majority of NYC Council members back Intro 213 to curb facial recognition at venues like Madison Square Garden, with Mayor Mamdani urging: 'It is time to ban the scan.'

By Amara Osei

4 min read

How Madison Square Garden became a facial recognition flashpoint
How Madison Square Garden became a facial recognition flashpointPexels / pixabay

What's News

  • A majority of NYC Council members sponsor Intro 213, which would curb facial recognition in public accommodations; Mayor Zohran Mamdani supports it.
  • MSG Entertainment has used facial recognition since at least 2018 and sued Wired for defamation in 2026 over reporting on leaked data.
  • In 2023, Rite Aid agreed to a five-year ban on facial recognition after FTC findings of false positives targeting people of color.
  • Wicket's opt-in facial ticketing serves about 75 teams worldwide; half of Browns season ticket holders use it.
  • An August Reuters/Ipsos poll found 47% of Americans oppose AI license plate cameras; 38% favor them.

A majority of New York City Council members have signed on as sponsors of Intro 213, a bill that would curb facial recognition in public establishments from shops to stadiums — and Mayor Zohran Mamdani has endorsed it in a statement shared with Fast Company.

"No fan should have to worry about their biometric data when they're already worried about their team losing the game," Mamdani said. "It is time to ban the scan and protect New Yorkers' privacy and civil rights."

The bill's sponsor, Councilmember Shahana Hanif, ties the push to decades of surveillance concerns in the city, including the NYPD's post-9/11 monitoring of Muslims. "I grew up in the backdrop of 9/11, and saw what surveillance, racial profiling, and a surveillance state is capable of," says Hanif, the first Muslim woman elected to the City Council.

She and other advocates also point to Madison Square Garden Entertainment's use of the technology at MSG and Radio City Music Hall, deployed since at least 2018. In late 2022, a woman escorting her daughter's Girl Scout group to Radio City's Christmas show was denied entry. The reason: a company policy barring lawyers from firms involved in litigation against MSG Entertainment, enforced by facial recognition.

How MSG became the flashpoint

MSG Entertainment — which did not respond to multiple inquiries from Fast Company — has said the policy prevents "improper disclosure and discovery" during litigation. The incident drew public outrage and a letter from New York State Attorney General Letitia James warning the policy could violate the law and citing concerns about potential racial and gender bias in facial recognition software. Studies have found some systems perform worse on darker-skinned people and women, though vendors say newer versions address those gaps.

The controversies have compounded. MSG venues have been accused of pulling a Radio City concertgoer from an admission line over a shirt mocking CEO and Knicks owner James Dolan, and of tracking a trans woman's movements at the stadium. A data breach earlier this year reportedly exposed a secret dossier of anti-facial recognition activists the company maintained.

"I think Madison Square Garden has been a real eye-opener for a lot of people at all of the horrible ways that surveillance can go wrong, especially in public spaces like sporting stadiums," says Reem Suleiman, senior campaign director at Fight for the Future.

After Wired reported in July 2026 that MSG maintained records of some celebrities' gender identity and sexual orientation, MSG Entertainment sued the outlet and its reporters for defamation, alleging they "cherry-picked" leaked data to "manufacture a false narrative portraying MSG as targeting the LGBTQIA community for discriminatory purposes." Wired called the lawsuit "baseless and ridiculous."

Critics also note MSG reportedly turned off its facial recognition system for the July 3 wedding of Taylor Swift and Travis Kelce. "That goes to show how unnecessary the technology is when they were happy to turn it off at one of the highest-profile, highest-security events of the year," says Will Owen of the Surveillance Technology Oversight Project (S.T.O.P.).

The backlash goes beyond MSG

Sentiment is shifting broadly. In an August Reuters/Ipsos poll, 47% of respondents opposed Flock Safety's AI license plate cameras in their communities; only 38% favored them. Retailers face scrutiny too. In 2023, Rite Aid agreed to stop using facial recognition for at least five years after the FTC alleged it generated false positives, particularly for people of color, leading to customers being wrongly flagged, harassed, and reported to police. Wegmans, which discloses its use under New York City law, says it "collects facial recognition data and only uses it to identify individuals who have previously been flagged for misconduct," and does not share it with third parties.

Is opting in enough?

On the vendor side, companies argue voluntary systems are different from mass surveillance. Wicket, founded during the pandemic in 2020 with the NFL's Cleveland Browns, lets fans enter with a selfie-linked face scan. "They didn't need to pull out their phone, they didn't need to touch anything, they didn't need to talk to anybody," says COO Jeff Boehm. About half of Browns season ticket owners use it, and roughly 75 teams worldwide have deployed it, along with events like Salesforce Dreamforce.

Boehm stresses the system is opt-in, stores only mathematical "template" data rather than raw images, and has tested accurate across demographic groups at NIST. "The teams own the data—we do not," he says. FaceFirst and eConnect market venue security and VIP-detection tools; Gatekeeper Systems, FaceFirst's parent, declined to share details, and eConnect declined an interview.

Critics aren't reassured. "Our faces are not worth handing over for perhaps slightly more convenient check-ins to venues," Owen says. It remains unclear whether Intro 213 would bar even voluntary programs like the Mets' Wicket-based ticketing; a team spokesperson didn't respond to an inquiry.

Hanif says negotiators are still refining the language. "Right now, I think we really want to get to a place where the bill language satisfies all the parties, between the council and the mayor," she says. "And then we'll push it for a full vote."

Original: legistar.council.nyc.gov

Share this article:

More from Amara Osei

Amara Osei

Show full bio

Senior reporter covering companies, deals and strategy in entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.

2,503 articles

Related articles

« Previous article