Economy & Policy

Russia Tops 70 Gigatonnes of Exported CO2, Analysis Finds

Russia exported 70+ gigatonnes of CO2 since 1850, Saudi Arabia 60 and Australia 25+, per Carbon Brief data released during Cop31, where Australia serves as president.

By Grace Kim

4 min read

Russia, Saudi Arabia and Australia named as biggest CO2 exporters in history
Russia, Saudi Arabia and Australia named as biggest CO2 exporters in historyAlan_Frijns / pixabay

What's News

  • Russia exported more than 70 gigatonnes of CO2 since 1850, the most of any country.
  • Saudi Arabia ranks second with about 60 gigatonnes; Australia third with over 25 gigatonnes.
  • Australia's first Cop31 draft text on Monday called for "the immediate transition away from fossil fuels in energy systems."
  • Climate Analytics says Australia is permitting coalmines that would operate until 2088.
  • Fossil fuels make up about two-fifths of Australia's export economy.

By Grace Kim

Russia has exported more than 70 gigatonnes of CO2 since 1850, more than any other country in history, according to a Carbon Brief analysis of fossil fuel exports seen by the Guardian. Saudi Arabia ranks second with about 60 gigatonnes. Australia sits third with more than 25 gigatonnes, not far ahead of Venezuela.

The analysis apportions responsibility for CO2 emissions based on the country extracting the fossil fuels, not the country where the CO2 is released — a reversal of how most emissions accounting works. Under conventional measures, big exporters often look like modest emitters, because those figures count fossil fuel use, not extraction for sale abroad.

What does the extraction-based count change?

The reframing matters politically. Australia's contribution to global heating more than doubles when its fossil fuel exports are counted, even though the country ranks lower on standard emitter lists built around domestic consumption.

The US and China — the world's two biggest current emitters — still bear greater historical responsibility than Russia, Saudi Arabia or Australia under the new accounting, because both have burned their own supplies on top of importing vast quantities of fossil fuels.

Australia's fossil fuels make up about two-fifths of its export economy, and the country has yet to set an end point for their use or export.

Why does this land at Cop31?

The findings surfaced in the second week of Cop31, the UN climate summit now under way in Turkey — with Australia serving as its president. Saudi Arabia, second on the exporter list, has long been an obstructive force at annual UN climate summits.

Louise Hutchins, convener of the Make Polluters Pay International Coalition, said: "This analysis tells you a lot about what's going wrong with climate negotiations. Here at Cop31, governments claim there's not enough money to tackle the climate crisis, while Australia, Russia and Saudi Arabia, that have amassed fortunes from fossil fuels, continue to wield pivotal political power in this consensus-based process."

She added: "Responsibility is on the wealthy, the powerful and the profiteers. Those who made fortunes from fossil fuels must pay for the damage."

On Monday afternoon, Australia issued a first draft of a potential Cop31 outcome containing a call for "the immediate transition away from fossil fuels in energy systems." That language builds on Cop28 in Dubai in 2023, which called on all countries to contribute to a global fossil fuel transition but set no timetable or workplan.

The prospects for the language look thin. Many countries, including Saudi Arabia, have hardened their positions since Dubai, and the absence of the US under Donald Trump removes pressure to find compromises. Saudi Arabia, Russia and allies in the Arab group and others are even opposing the idea of having a cover text at all, which could stymie negotiations further.

Is Australia scaling back extraction?

No, according to separate analysis published on Tuesday by Climate Analytics. The thinktank found Australia, despite presiding over Cop31, appeared to have no plans to curtail its own fossil fuel extraction. Coalmines are still being permitted that would remain in operation until 2088 — long after all countries are supposed to have reached net zero emissions, around mid-century.

"It's abundantly clear Australia is not 'doing its part' as the prime minister claimed here in Turkey last week," said Climate Analytics CEO Bill Hare. "There is a deep contradiction in a government position that champions climate ambition abroad but plans for continued fossil fuel exports, with approvals for coalmines and gasfields that lock in production for decades."

Prime Minister Anthony Albanese attended Cop31 last week, but at home he faces pressure from a resurgent One Nation party, which is riding high in the polls, spurns net zero and denies climate science.

Australia, Saudi Arabia and Russia were approached for comment.

What are campaigners demanding?

Asad Rehman, chief executive of Friends of the Earth, said: "It's time for the deadly tango between the producers of fossil fuels, and those locked into dependency on oil and gas, to have its last dance. We must turn off the tap on fossil fuels and push richer nations to commit to a fair, fast and fully funded phaseout. That means real public finance, and access to the technology that can make it possible, for the countries bearing the brunt of climate breakdown."

With climate finance talks once again in stalemate at Cop31 and several more drafts of the cover decision text likely, the "immediate transition away" language faces an uncertain path. How much survives will test whether consensus-based negotiations can discipline the three countries that have profited most from exported carbon.

Source: theguardian.com

Share this article:

More from Grace Kim

Grace Kim

Show full bio

Market editor covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.

2,178 articles

Related articles

« Previous articleNext article »