Economy & Policy

Ten Indicators Called the Fed's Last Two Cycles. Here's What They Say Now

A ten-indicator framework flagged the Fed's 2022 tightening and 2024 easing in advance. Here's the full scorecard, from M2 growth to Fed funds futures.

By Nathan Brooks

4 min read

The 10 Indicators That Signal Where Rates Are Headed
The 10 Indicators That Signal Where Rates Are HeadedAI-generated

What's News

  • Nine of ten indicators signaled tightening in March 2022; the Fed then hiked +525 bps.
  • Six of ten indicators signaled easing in August 2024; the Fed then cut −175 bps.
  • Fed funds futures implied ~7.2 hikes in March 2022 and ~8.7 cuts in August 2024 over 15 months.
  • Indicators are benchmarked against historical interquartile ranges when Trimmed Mean PCE ran 2%–2.5%.
  • March 2022 readings included M2 growth of +10.6% and Brent crude up +71.8% YoY.

By Nathan Brooks

In March 2022, nine of ten macro indicators flagged that the Federal Reserve should tighten — and Fed funds futures priced in roughly 7.2 hikes before the Fed delivered +525 basis points. By August 2024, the same framework flipped: six indicators pointed to easing, futures implied about 8.7 cuts, and the Fed subsequently delivered −175 basis points.

That's the track record laid out by TradingView analyst QuantitativeAlpha in a new study that benchmarks ten indicators against their historical interquartile ranges — drawn from periods when the Dallas Fed's Trimmed Mean PCE inflation rate ran between 2% and 2.5%. Readings outside that range signal tightening or easing; readings inside it signal holding rates unchanged. A tenth indicator, the Federal Funds Forecast (FFF), reads the market-implied rate path straight from 30-Day Fed Funds Futures.

What does the framework actually measure?

The first nine indicators span monetary aggregates, credit, labor, commodities and market pricing. Each gets a simple verdict. The scorecard from the study's two test dates:

  • Fed Treasury Holdings YoY: +18.5% in March 2022 versus a +4.6% median — tightening. −12.1% in August 2024 — easing.
  • 2Y Treasury minus Fed Funds spread: +123 bps in March 2022 versus a +44 bps median — tightening. −142 bps in August 2024 — easing.
  • Fed Funds minus Taylor Rule: −1,204 bps in March 2022 versus a −70 bps median — tightening. +1 bp in August 2024 — hold.
  • Bank Loans and Leases YoY: +5.7% in March 2022 against a +7.6% median — hold. +2.4% in August 2024 — easing.
  • M2 Money Supply YoY: +10.6% in March 2022 versus a +5.0% median — tightening. +2.0% in August 2024 — easing.
  • U3 Unemployment minus NAIRU: −54 bps in March 2022 versus a +23 bps median — tightening. −22 bps in August 2024 — hold.
  • Hourly Wage minus Productivity growth: +791 bps in March 2022 versus a +144 bps median — tightening. +128 bps in August 2024 — hold.
  • Brent Crude YoY: +71.8% in March 2022 versus a +10.5% median — tightening. −13.5% in August 2024 — easing.
  • 10Y Breakeven Inflation: 2.6% in March 2022 versus a 2.3% median — tightening. 2.2% in August 2024 — hold.
  • Federal Funds Futures: +181 bps of implied tightening over 15 months in March 2022. −217 bps of implied easing in August 2024.

Why each block matters for practitioners

The mechanics are straightforward. When the Fed's Treasury holdings shrink, more paper lands on private balance sheets, bond prices fall and borrowing costs rise — that's the quantitative-tightening channel, and the −12.1% contraction in August 2024 was the mirror image of the +18.5% expansion two years earlier.

The rate-spread block works off expectations. A positive gap between the 2-year Treasury and the fed funds rate means markets expect higher short rates; the +123 bps reading in March 2022 was nearly triple the historical median of +44 bps.

The Taylor Rule gap is the framework's shock absorber. The study calculates the prescribed rate as 2% equilibrium real rate plus GDP deflator inflation, plus 0.5 times the inflation gap, plus 0.5 times the output gap. In March 2022 the actual fed funds rate sat 12 percentage points below prescription — historically accommodative — which itself argued for tightening. By August 2024 the gap had closed to +1 bp, arguing for a hold.

Credit, money and labor indicators capture the real economy. M2 growth of +10.6% in March 2022 — more than double the +5.0% median — flagged inflationary pressure; +2.0% by August 2024 did the opposite. The labor market told a subtler story: unemployment sat 54 bps below NAIRU in March 2022, tight enough to fan inflation, but by August 2024 the gap of −22 bps landed inside the historical range.

What does this change for rate positioning?

For portfolio managers and rates traders, the practical takeaway is a checklist you can run monthly against freely available FRED data. The framework caught both regime turns before the Fed moved — futures implied 8.7 cuts ahead of a −175 bps cycle that actually delivered, meaning market pricing overshot, but directionally nailed the pivot.

QuantitativeAlpha's own caveat deserves weight: historical relationships and market-implied expectations evolve as economic conditions, inflation dynamics and Fed policy responses change. The scorecard is a compass, not a guarantee — but it's a compass that read the last two turns correctly.

Source: tradingview.com

Share this article:

More from Nathan Brooks

Nathan Brooks

Show full bio

News editor covering regulation, policy and their impact on entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.

2,232 articles

Related articles

« Previous articleNext article »