Carbon Removal Takes Center Stage at Cop31 as 1.5C Threshold Slips
A record 700 CCS lobbyists and a first-ever mention of carbon removal in Cop31 negotiating text mark a turning point for the industry as the world heads past 1.5C.
By Nathan Brooks
4 min read

What's News
- A record 700 lobbyists for carbon capture and storage are attending Cop31, more than the smallest 50 national delegations combined, per CIEL.
- On Friday, CDR and CCS appeared for the first time in text informing a final Cop31 deal.
- The UN estimates 320 billion tons of CO2 must be removed this century to return below 1.5C.
- Current CDR totals about 2 billion tons a year, nearly all from reforestation; direct air capture has removed just 2 million tons.
- CDR advocates want a new global agency and inclusion in the summit's final outcome.
A record 700 lobbyists are pushing carbon capture and storage at Cop31 in Antalya, Turkey — more delegates than the smallest 50 national delegations combined, according to the Center for International Environmental Law (CIEL). Their presence signals how fast the debate over cleaning up carbon, rather than just cutting it, has moved into the mainstream of UN climate diplomacy.
On Friday, for the first time, both carbon capture and storage (CCS) and carbon dioxide removal (CDR) appeared in a text that will inform the basis of a final deal at the talks. CDR proponents, gathered at a summit pavilion called Think Negative, want a dramatic scale-up of carbon removal to pull the planet back from an imminent "overshoot" of internationally agreed temperature thresholds. They have pressed Turkey and Australia, which jointly preside over Cop31, to include CDR in the summit's final outcome, and they want a new global agency to coordinate removals.
The backdrop is blunt. The UN has acknowledged the world will soon surge past a 1.5C rise in global temperatures since the pre-industrial period, unleashing worsening heatwaves, floods and droughts as countries keep burning fossil fuels. Even with reduced emissions, the planet's temperature won't fall back below that level for thousands of years without rapid CO2 removal. The UN recently estimated that 320 billion tons of CO2 must be removed this century to get back under 1.5C.
What does this change for the carbon removal industry?
Right now, not much — and that's the point. CDR remains small-scale: roughly 2 billion tons of carbon removed a year, almost all through reforestation. Technological approaches that vacuum CO2 directly from the air have removed just 2 million tons — a thousandth of the total — and leading companies in the field are badly underperforming and struggling financially. Investor cash is flowing elsewhere, notably into artificial intelligence, leaving the sector nascent and under-resourced.
Yet countries have leaned on the theoretical promise of carbon removal in their climate plans for years. If the world is to bend the temperature curve back to safe levels rather than just flatline it, that promise has to become operational fast.
"CDR still sounds unreal to people but we spent a whole year trying to make it into the agenda of Cop31," said Göker Avci, a decarbonization strategist at CDR Türkiye. "We spoke with the presidency about making it into the final decision and they have started to realize the potential."
Removal takes several forms: direct air capture, crushing rocks that lock away carbon, and protecting or seeding forests and mangroves.
"CDR's really been missing from the discussion and debate even though it's been in all the models for decades," said Injy Johnstone, a net zero expert at the Max Planck Institute. "It's the only solution that we have to actually balance out those emissions and it return from the state of overshoot."
Johnstone argued the effort shouldn't rest on entrepreneurs alone: "Really these efforts shouldn't have to be led by the entrepreneurs kind of doing their thing on the ground, we have to get more vocal about it and actually also start to put in place these kinds of procedures," she said of the push for an international CDR framework.
Why environmentalists are pushing back
Campaigners warn that banking on removal is dangerous. Large, potentially harmful changes to land use and the oceans would be needed to store enough carbon, and the promise of future cleanup removes pressure to cut emissions today.
"The focus should always be on cutting emissions now, it's very dangerous to assume that we can put more emissions into the atmosphere and then assume we will have technology in the future to just remove them again," said Rachel Kennerley, a carbon capture campaigner at CIEL. "These are hypothetical technologies and part of the problem we're seeing here is that we're seeing the normalization of this overshoot peak and return pathway. That return element is at the moment hypothetical. I mean, I think it's impossible."
CCS — capturing emissions at the source of a polluting facility and burying them — draws even sharper fire. Kennerley called it a "greenwashing exercise" used by large oil and gas companies to extend the age of fossil fuels. Still, she conceded the two processes play parallel roles: "I think they fulfill similar kind of diversionary roles from mitigation. I think they're both allowed for prolonging fossil-fuel use, basically."
Her preferred path: keep the 1.5C exceedance as small as possible by eliminating fossil fuel use, then let reforestation slowly absorb excess CO2 over many hundreds of years until temperatures dip back down.
Advocates counter that the emergency's scale leaves no alternative. "It's the only tool we have," said Johnstone. "We need this, we need this fast, and we need to be really seeing it on a scale that rivals the global energy industry in terms of its kind of footprint in the world."
If CDR lands in Cop31's final text, a sector that pulled 2 million tons from the air last year gets its first real policy mandate — and a very long way to go to reach the UN's 320-billion-ton century target.
Source: theguardian.com
More from Nathan Brooks
Show full bio
News editor covering regulation, policy and their impact on entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.
2,232 articles